Diners' Choice: Neighborhood gem restaurants in West Virginia

OpenTable

Updated July 05, 2025

Looking for the best restaurants that are the best neighborhood gems in West Virginia? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Muriale's Italian Kitchen

5.0

5 (31)

$30 and under

Italian

Fairmont

About the restaurant

Since 1969, Muriale’s has been crafting authentic Italian recipes that have been passed down over many generations, assuring quality and service, from our family to yours. Along the way, our guests have been our best marketers. By telling your friends about Muriale’s, we have continued to grow. By telling us what makes your taste buds come alive, we have cultivated a menu that reflects your tastes. Whether you are dining here, utilizing our curbside pickup service, or letting us cater for a special event, we are confident in our ability to meet your tastes and exceed your expectations.

Top review

Andrea

Dined on Jun 18, 2025

Had a wonderful experience for my birthday! Food was delicious! Will be back for sure

Cafe Oliverio

4.9

4.9 (18)

$30 and under

Italian

Morgantown

About the restaurant

## Cafe Oliverio: A Taste of Italy in the Heart of West Virginia Step into Cafe Oliverio and be transported to a world of authentic Italian flavors and warm hospitality. This family-owned restaurant, nestled in the vibrant Wharf District, has been a Morgantown favorite for over two decades. The menu boasts a symphony of classic Italian dishes, each crafted with fresh, seasonal ingredients and time-honored recipes passed down through generations. From the delicate Angel Hair Crab Balls to the hearty Mushroom Sacchetti, every bite is a testament to the Oliverio family's passion for good food. The atmosphere is as inviting as the food itself. The warm, brick-lined interior is adorned with twinkling lights and lush greenery, creating a cozy and intimate ambiance. Whether you're enjoying a romantic dinner for two or a lively gathering with friends, Cafe Oliverio provides the perfect setting for creating lasting memories. Beyond the delicious food and inviting atmosphere, Cafe Oliverio is known for its exceptional service. The friendly and attentive staff is dedicated to ensuring your dining experience is nothing short of extraordinary. So, whether you're a seasoned foodie or simply looking for a taste of Italy, Cafe Oliverio is the perfect destination. Come savor the authentic flavors, warm hospitality, and

Top review

Cynthia

Dined on Jun 7, 2025

We LOVED the special cocktail- Manhattans. My all time favorite lasagna in Morgantown area- it was delicious! Everyone’s dinner was excellent. Our server was polite, attentive and non intrusive. We had a nice evening close to home- THANKS for coming to Cheat Lake!

Oliverio's Ristorante

4.8

4.8 (371)

$30 and under

Italian

Morgantown

About the restaurant

Known as West Virginia's preeminent Italian restaurant, Oliverio's on The Wharf was established in 2001 in Morgantown's newly renovated Wharf District. This Tuscan-inspired eatery, with its big-city feel and small-town charm, is open seven nights a week. Featuring nightly specials, homemade sauces, Italian dressing, and breadsticks, great seafood and steaks, creative appetizers, locally sourced desserts, and an extensive wine and cocktail list. Three generations of Oliverios participate in the daily operation of the four-location family-owned business. The tradition of quality food and superior service has been passed down for generations from our family in Calabira, Italy, to your table. All the love and care that went into these recipes shines through every dish served. Join our family today for Italian cuisine at its very best!

Top review

Terry

Dined 3 days ago

Service was very good, and the food was outstanding

Stefano's

4.8

4.8 (16)

$50 and over

Italian

Morgantown

About the restaurant

A Taste of Italy in the Heart of West Virginia: Stefano's Restaurant

Located in Morgantown, Stefano's Restaurant brings you authentic Italian cuisine in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Perfect for romantic dinners, special occasions, or a night out with friends, our menu features a variety of Italian classics made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Enjoy shareable appetizers and perfectly cooked pasta dishes, all complemented by an extensive wine list and a fully stocked bar.

Stefano's offers more than just a meal; it's an experience. Our intimate dining room, adorned with Tuscan décor and the sounds of opera, creates a romantic ambiance for an unforgettable evening. Our attentive staff ensures you feel like a valued guest.

Whether you're a food enthusiast or just seeking a delicious meal, Stefano's is the ideal destination. Come and savor the warmth, flavors, and passion that make Stefano's a true culinary gem.

Top review

HollyVIP

Dined on Jun 24, 2025

Stephano’s never disappoints ! The best fine dining experience in Morgantown and the surrounding area. We go there for the cozy ambience as well as the amazing food. My Strip Steak with Mushrooms Diane was perfectly cooked, my husband’s Chilean Sea Bass over Lobster Risotto was absolutely delicious (as usual)! Darian, our server, was a delight…very personable and attentive. Go to Stephano’s. You will not be disappointed.

Bricks & Barrels

4.7

4.7 (1190)

$31 to $50

Steakhouse

Charleston

About the restaurant

Bricks & Barrels is a steak and seafood experience voted three consecutive years as Charleston's Favorite Restaurant in the annual People's Choice Awards. Known for its unique ambience that relaxes the mind and rejuvenates the spirit, Bricks & Barrels features four semi-private dining areas that give the sensation of dining inside a whiskey barrel. The restaurant’s interior features wooden whiskey barrels used as dining tables contrasted against the rustic brick façade. But the food & drinks are the highlight, with the Green Tomato Napoleon being a favorite appetizer. The Mediterranean Chicken was nominated for Charleston's best dish by The Food Guy, a local food critic: bone-in chicken breast braised in capers, figs and olives created a beautiful symphony of flavors (sweet, tart, salty, earthy) on a colorful, gorgeously presented plate." Charleston's Favorite Bartender Drew serves specialty cocktails, local craft beer and award-winning wines. Memories are made at Bricks & Barrels.

Top review

Mary

Dined 7 days ago

Bricks & Barrels never disappoints. The red snapper with lobster sauce is amazing

Guesthouse Lost River

4.7

4.7 (281)

$31 to $50

American

Lost River

About the restaurant

The Guesthouse Kitchen & Bar offers fresh-from-scratch, American-inspired dishes in a comfortable mountain lodge-style setting. Our menu includes dishes made from scratch, inspired by, and made with locally sourced proteins, ingredients, and seasonal produce whenever possible.

We invite you to come find yourself in Lost River!

Top review

Kevin

Dined on Jun 20, 2025

Absolutely delicious Gary & Jesse are outstanding host of the entire Guesthouse....the food was superb, the vibe is delightful and the staff impeccable. We can't wait to go back...🤩

The Blennerhassett Hotel & Spa

4.4

4.4 (124)

$31 to $50

American

Parkersburg

About the restaurant

For more than a century, The Blennerhassett has imparted upon its guests the uniquely attentive service for which its name has become legendary. We are rooted in history and tradition, and strive every day to maintain a seamless fusion of past, present and future. Our entire staff is committed to fulfilling the needs and surpassing the expectations of every guest.

Top review

AndrewVIP

Dined on Jun 25, 2025

I would have given 5 stars. The dinner was outstanding with great service but the breakfast on 6/25 was poor. I was the first one in the restaurant for Breakfast and had to wait 20 minutes to get omelette and hash brown casserole. Only two other people were in the restaurant after me. Everything including the coffee was like warm at best. Hashbrown casserole looked like it was left over from the day before (inedible).

Oxley House

4.4

4.4 (63)

$30 and under

American

Elkins

About the restaurant

Experience the essence of West Virginia at the Oxley House. Located in the historic Tygart Hotel in Elkins, our restaurant showcases the best of Appalachian cuisine. Indulge in elevated dining while immersing yourself in the flavors of the region. The Oxley House has some of the finest food and drink Elkins has to offer. From casual fine dining, specialty cocktails and steakhouse classics to local craft beer and mouth-watering desserts, there is something to satisfy every appetite.

Top review

John

Dined 2 days ago

Don’t order the crab cakes. Mostly bread with very few slivers of crab. Blackened salmon is somewhat spicy for typical tastes. Sangria was fine. Deserts (gelatinous, strawberry rhubarb pie, peanut butter pie) were all good.

The Varsity Club

4.4

4.4 (29)

$30 and under

American

White Sulphur Springs

About the restaurant

The Varsity Club, The Schoolhouse Hotel's flagship restaurant, features upscale southern classics. This venue can seat over eighty people and features a full bar, serving creative cocktails, an exciting wine list, local brews, and more. Tufted leather banquettes and lively plaid fabrics create a timeless environment where guests can enjoy everything from grilled steaks to house-made salads and she-crab soup.

Top review

Patricia Clark

Dined on Jun 19, 2025

Excellent food - from appetizers to dessert! We ended up ordering too much because it all sounded so good - and there were no leftovers! We had a large party of 9 - everyone loved their choices. Service was excellent and appropriately on time.

Dockside Grille

4.2

4.2 (116)

$30 and under

Contemporary American

Morgantown

About the restaurant

Dockside Grille is an all American bar and grille that sits right on beautiful Cheat Lake. We are a two level restaurant with the most beautiful view.

Top review

Eileen

Dined on May 17, 2025

Mackenzie was so sweet. Food was delicious and beautiful view. Parking was tough though!

Explore Diners' Choice best of West Virginia

Explore more Diners' Choice lists