Diners' Choice: Italian restaurants in Finger Lakes

OpenTable

Updated June 05, 2025

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Finger Lakes? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Cristo's Wood Fired Pizza and Pasta

4.9

4.9 (536)

$30 and under

Italian

Rochester

About the restaurant

CRISTO'S WOOD FIRED PIZZA and PASTA. Come enjoy our rustic charm and open kitchen. Featuring Appetizers, Salads, Wood Fired Pizza, Pasta, Chicken Dishes and Nightly Features including homemade Desserts. Live Music Wednesdays 5-8.

Top review

Jason

Dined on Jun 6, 2025

Great food great service! We will be be back soon!

Tony D's

4.6

4.6 (734)

$30 and under

Italian

Rochester

About the restaurant

Tony D's is a trendy pizzeria that also offers traditional Italian dishes. The restaurant is popular for its authentic signature pizzas. It makes each one from scratch using only fresh and high quality ingredients. The ambiance at Tony D's is modern, vibrant and sleek with a young and trendy atmosphere. The restaurant also offers a full-service bar where guests can enjoy their favorite drinks.

Begin the meal with an appetizer like marinated meatballs cooked in a classic red sauce, crispy calamari served with house special sauce or the shrimp scampi. Diners are welcome to create their own pizzas at Tony D's. Topping options include tomatoes, onions, peppers, chicken, beef, shrimp, crab and more. Guests can also dig into an entree like penne a la vodka or the pan roasted veal rib chop.

Top review

wendy

Dined 4 days ago

We really enjoyed our meals - nice ambiance although very loud and difficult to hear each other over the noise. Service was fine although we were disappointed that the high top we reserved was not available and there was no mention of the special occasion that we noted in our reservation. It’s pricey but we will be back again.

Prosecco Italian Restaurant and Jazz Bar LLC

4.6

4.6 (1265)

$30 and under

Italian

Farmington, New York

About the restaurant

We are open for dine-in, takeout, and online ordering Tuesday-Sunday 4pm-9pm. Please contact the restaurant at 585-924-8000 for reservations or to place an order. We are also available for private in house events or catering (pick up or delivery) during our business and non business hours. Call 585-924-8000 for more information or to place your catering orders.

Top review

DIANNE

Dined 4 days ago

I had the eggplant parmesan and it was delicious. I can hardly wait to eat my leftovers tonight. The salads are always fresh and the bread is excellent.

Discover more

Fettuccine con Funghi

Veneto Pizza and Pasta

4.7

4.7 (780)

$30 and under

Italian

Rochester

About the restaurant

Veneto Pizza & Pasta located in the heart of the historic East End is reopening October 2023. It has been completely remodeled due to a fire that occurred on 1/4/23. Same great staff, food and open kitchen with a new modern vibe. Featuring Appetizers, Salads, Pizza, Pasta, Chicken Dishes, and Nightly Features including homemade Desserts. Full Bar, Wine, Beer, Soda.

Top review

TomVIP

Dined 4 days ago

An excellent dinner with outstanding service. Kudos to Aliyah and the entire team!

Discover more

4.7

4.7 (1074)

$31 to $50

Italian

Rochester

About the restaurant

At Amore Italian Restaurant & Lounge, authentic dishes, exceptional wines and spirits, and a vibrant atmosphere come together to bring you a wonderfully satisfying dining experience. Here, the flavors of Italy and the Mediterranean are brought to life using fresh, seasonal ingredients – creating a meal you’ll truly love.

Top review

Steve

Dined on Jun 10, 2025

Nice experience with great food and friendly service

Discover more

Bocaccinis Italian Bistro

4.7

4.7 (32)

$31 to $50

Italian

Fairport

About the restaurant

Immerse yourself in the warmth of authentic Italian cuisine at Bocaccini's Italian Bistro. Experience culinary delights where every dish is a masterpiece, crafted with fresh, seasonal ingredients and a passion for tradition. Our menu features classic and innovative options, including hand-tossed pizzas, pastas, succulent seafood, and tender steaks.
Indulge in signature dishes like Salmon Fra Diavolo, featuring Norwegian salmon in spicy white wine marinara with baby spinach and asiago risotto. Or try the Carbonara, a mix of grilled chicken, baby spinach, and smoked bacon, all tossed in a creamy peppered bacon sauce finished with pecorino romano.
Our inviting atmosphere encourages you to enjoy a glass of fine Italian wine while surrounded by friendly diners. Whether celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a night out, Bocaccini's offers the perfect setting for an unforgettable experience. Join us and discover the true essence of Italian hospitality. We look forward to welcoming you.

Top review

Andrea

Dined 5 days ago

The hostesses and waitress were absolutely lovely—polite, helpful. We sat outside on a beautiful evening and could hear the great band that was playing inside. Food was excellent and prices were reasonable. Thank you for a wonderful evening out.

Fiamma Centro

4.4

4.4 (1354)

$30 and under

Italian

Rochester

About the restaurant

Fiamma is a full service authentic Italian Restaurant featuring the first truly authentic Neapolitan Wood burning pizza oven in Monroe county. With an all natural flame our oven maintains an internal temperature of 1000 degrees cooking the pizza in 45 seconds leaving it with a truly unique taste and texture. The rest of our menu is reflective of traditional southern italian dishes native to the Campania region. With diverse ingredients and seasonal fruits and vegetables we strive to offer only the freshest available seasonal dishes. As the seasons change so will our menu.

The small, quaint dining room was designed to resemble an old fashioned Italian osteria. Rich with wood and other earth elements Fiamma is a warm inviting atmosphere. The Italian countryside was inspiration for both the menu and the dining space. While at Fiamma you will be greeted with a smile, and treated like family.

Top review

Patricia

Dined 2 days ago

An absolutely perfect evening out with friends. Everything was delicious!

Capitano Steak and Seafood

4.4

4.4 (69)

$30 and under

Italian

Webster

About the restaurant

Capitano offers a memorable dining experience with stunning waterfront views and a welcoming atmosphere. As the newest waterfront restaurant in Webster, we invite you to enjoy a menu filled with fresh seafood, steak, pasta, and delicious brick oven pizzas and wings. Our extensive wine and specialty cocktail list features selections to complement every dish.
With a large bar perfect for social gatherings, Capitano provides a vibrant space for enjoying drinks with friends or colleagues. In addition to dining in, we offer catering services and host private events, making Capitano the perfect choice for any occasion. Whether you're here for a celebration or a casual meal, our exceptional service and inviting setting make every visit feel special.
Join us for an unforgettable meal by the water!

Top review

Chris

Dined 2 days ago

We had oysters, and lobster tails for dinner. Well worth it! The drinks were amazing as well!

Portico at del Lago Resort and Casino

4.5

4.5 (2669)

$50 and over

Italian

Rochester

About the restaurant

Welcome back to the award-winning Portico by Fabio Viviani! del Lago Resort & Casino is accepting reservations for Portico!
Reservations are highly encouraged on weekends and special event nights.

Located inside del Lago Resort and Casino, GUESTS MUST BE 21 TO DINE IN PORTICO, due to regulations on the casino floor. Once inside bask in the warm glow & Casino, hospitality paired with exceptional cuisine. Premium steaks cooked to juicy perfection, the freshest, most succulent seafood and fresh pastas are the hallmarks of success at Portico by Fabio Viviani – where the ambiance rivals the exquisitely prepared signature dishes.

Top review

Deborah

Dined 2 days ago

this is the first time in many years of dining at PORTICO that I was disappointed in the food , not ALL of the food , I had ordered the strip steak special which was on the 50/50 menu, the steak would have been more tender if it had been made of rubber ,,,the calamari was excellent and my dining companions were very satisfied with their meals .

Discover more

Popular dish

USDA Choice Filet Mignon

Popular dish

Wagyu Meatball

Delmonicos Italian Steakhouse - Rochester

4.2

4.2 (1246)

$31 to $50

Italian

Rochester

About the restaurant

Delmonico’s Italian Steakhouse offers unforgettable meals in an equally unforgettable atmosphere. Our guests enjoy the Italian-themed music with plenty of Frank Sinatra and the Rat Pack; the caricatures on the walls; the big-city feel; and the warmth of the wood-paneled dining rooms. Above all, they love the feast for all of their senses provided by our 24 oz. signature Delmonico steak.

We also serve homemade Italian specialties, including pasta, seafood dishes, bruschetta, garlic bread, salads, chicken dishes, and cannoli, as well as a great selection of wines.

Top review

Kim

Dined 2 days ago

Fantastic dinner, service was great. Our waitress, Amber was attentive but didn’t feel like we were rushed. She was fabulous getting our dessert to go when we ate plenty but wanted to take a sweet treat for later. Thank you Amber for a lovely evening.

Explore Diners' Choice best of Finger Lakes

Explore more Diners' Choice lists