Diners' Choice: Italian restaurants in Surrey

OpenTable

Updated April 05, 2025

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Surrey? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Caffe Piccolo

4.8

4.8 (213)

£25 and under

Italian

Farnham

About the restaurant

Welcome to Caffé Piccolo
Surrey has been the home to Caffé Piccolo since 1995. Offering its guests the very best taste of Italy.

We are proud to be an independent, family-run, Italian restaurant with a relaxing, family-friendly atmosphere.

The oak panelling, original fireplaces and dried hops scale the wooden beams of this historic building.

Whisking you away from the frenzy and traffic of life and placing you anywhere from the top of the boot in Milan to the tip of the toe in Sicily ready to explore epicurean delights, created by Chef Darius.

A casual-elegant dress code is recommended.
We suggest you make a reservation in order to secure your table.

Top review

James

Dined 7 days ago

Caffe Piccolo is my go to place for birthdays and special occasions. The food is great and the lovely old building makes every evening something special. Well done!

Rosso Mazara

4.7

4.7 (316)

£25 and under

Italian

Chobham

About the restaurant

If you’re craving Italian food but don’t have the chance to fly to the Italy, Rosso Mazara might just be the next best thing. Let our Italian chefs surprise you with a mix of tradition and innovation. Rosso Mazara is an authentic Italian restaurant in the heart of Chobham. We strive to remain faithful to traditional cuisine while only serving the freshest ingredient directly from Italy.

Top review

David

Dined on Apr 9, 2025

A really nice neighbourhood Italian restaurant. Nice food and nice people. Highly recommended

Discover more

Experience

Live Italian Music

Valentina - Weybridge

4.7

4.7 (491)

£25 and under

Italian

Weybridge

About the restaurant

Valentina Bar & Kitchen Weybridge offers a changing seasonal menu using ingredients from the VALENTINA delicatessen next door and hearty recipes that have been handed down through the family for generations.
A catering service is offered, as well as home delivery of Italian food within a 5 mile radius of the store.
Customers can choose from more than 50 Italian, Spanish, French and international wines.

Our restaurant is open for breakfast, lunch and dinner, as well as offering our home daily roasted coffee and pastries throughout the day.

Top review

John

Dined 3 days ago

Consistently good food here, nice calm atmosphere last night as well which was just right.

Cambio Marcia

4.8

4.8 (100)

£26 to £40

Italian

Guildford

About the restaurant

Cambio Marcia, an independent Osteria, blends traditional Italian culinary heritage with contemporary flair. Nestled on Swan Lane, a stone's throw from Guildford High Street, Cambio Marcia welcomes guests to its distinct ambiance across two floors of a characterful building adorned with Ligurian artwork.

Top review

AdsVIP

Dined 4 days ago

A wonderful restaurant, delicious food with friendly and outstanding service

Pianillo

4.6

4.6 (78)

£26 to £40

Italian

Chertsey

About the restaurant

A warm welcome to Pianillo Chertsey, the home of the very finest italian food. Pianillo has been established in Chertsey, London since April 2024. Pianillo is a family established restaurant. Since our arrival in Chertsey, we have had the privilege of serving our beautiful customers, who have now become also our friends.

Top review

Marie

Dined on Apr 21, 2025

Beautiful restaurant, amazing food, friendly staff, will definitely be returning when in the area, absolutely worth trying if you love Italian food.

Fratelli

4.5

4.5 (26)

£25 and under

Italian

Haslemere

About the restaurant

Fratelli , is a new Italian Restaurant in Haslemere. Our goal is to offer you a warm welcoming experience, giving you the opportunity to taste and enjoy authentic and traditional Italian dishes. In our restaurant, in a friendly and family atmosphere we are looking forward to share with you moments, whether you are visiting us a romantic night out, larger party or corporate event, we guarantee that you will be looked after by our friendly and attentive staff.

Top review

Michelle

Dined 6 days ago

Our first time dining and we were impressed with the service, menu options, the quality of the food and the price. My pork was a little salty but that might just be my taste buds as I rarely have salt. My husband is a spaghetti Bolognese addict and he said it was one of the best. Our daughter had lasagne which was cheesy and creamy. The desserts were yummy, and we were surprised at the final bill. A relaxed atmosphere for all the family, and would recommend a visit ( the pizzas looked fab, and very generous in size!)

Amarone Italian Restaurant

4.6

4.6 (87)

£26 to £40

Italian

Cranleigh

About the restaurant

AMARONE ITALIAN RESTAURANT

Welcome to Amarone Italian Restaurant.

Amarone Restaurant is a modern Italian family run restaurant, serving traditional and authentic Italian flavours in Cranleigh.

Our goal is to offer you a warm welcoming experience, of exceptional quality, traditional snd authentic Italian dishes.

In our restaurant, in a friendly and family atmosphere we are looking forward to share with you all your upcoming memories. Whether you are visiting us for a romantic night out, large party or corporate event we guarantee that you will be looked after by our friendly and attentive staff.

Using only the finest ingredients the menu is inspired by dishes from every region of Italy whilst remaining harmoniously in tune with the seasons.

Top review

Yann

Dined on Apr 15, 2025

Definitely recommend. Delicious food, well presented. Service was attentive and accommodating. Ambience was positive. Will absolutely come back. 😊

Piccolino - Virginia Water

4.6

4.6 (420)

£26 to £40

Italian

Virginia Water

About the restaurant

Fun fact: Virginia Water is the only place outside of London to make it into the top 10 most expensive postcodes. This green and pleasant land in the heart of Surrey boasts stunning countryside and of course, Virginia Water lake, making it the ideal oasis of calm within commuting distance of London. And of course, Virginia Water is also home to one of the area’s best Italian Restaurants, Piccolino.
Piccolino, an authentic Italian Restaurant, is a proud fixture of the Virginia Water dining scene. Located on London Road, Piccolino in Virginia Water proudly boasts an open kitchen, wine boutique, cocktail bar and a substantial alfresco terrace featuring a fully retractable roof to ensure the ultimate alfresco experience rain or shine!
Italy’s diverse cuisine is the heart and soul of Piccolino in Virginia Water. We visit the regions, meet the producers and are committed to sourcing the best quality ingredients.

Top review

Poppy

Dined on Apr 17, 2025

Overall good experience, good service, food was delicious and didn’t take long to arrive

Discover more

Experience

Club Lunch

Spaghetti Tree - Walton on the Hill

4.6

4.6 (995)

£26 to £40

Italian

Tadworth

About the restaurant

Spaghetti Tree Walton-on-the-Hill has a very contemporary feel and is an ideal party venue. The restaurant also has a unique location with the best views overlooking Walton Pond. Spaghetti Tree has a history dating back to 1985. We are a small family-run business and the philosophy behind our restaurants is that it is best to keep it simple, traditional, fresh and affordable. Also, and probably most important of all, keep it in the family.

Top review

Ian

Dined 4 days ago

Lovely venue. Good menu and tasty food. The portion size was good, I could only two courses. There was a buzz in the restaurant and later in the evening a live singer who was good, she did try not to be invasive. Unfortunately for me and this is a personal thing with the restaurant noise and the music it causes me a problem hearing my fellow diners, but it did add to the atmosphere. We would certainly return.

Discover more

Experience

Father's Day

Experience

Bottomless Cocktail Brunch

Ciao Italia

4.6

4.6 (963)

£26 to £40

Italian

Banstead

About the restaurant

Family run for over 20 years, Ciao Italia Restaurant in the heart of Banstead Village, offering authentic Italian cuisine with a large selection of fresh fish, quality meat, pasta dishes and mouth watering starters. All classic and traditional dishes, beautifully presented and at reasonable prices.

Ciao Italia Restaurant is the perfect setting for a business lunch, quiet dinner for two or a family celebration. Enjoy your meal with family and friends where you will be welcomed in a warm and friendly atmosphere.

Visit our website for more details www.ciaoitalia.co.uk

Top review

Nicole

Dined 4 days ago

Very friendly and welcoming local restaurant with delicious food.

Discover more

Experience

Quintet Jazz Band - Thursday 1st May

Experience

ABBA DUO Live Music Night

Explore Diners' Choice best of Surrey