Rudy's Redeye Grill

Excellent food, service, and atmosphere. We always enjoy Rudy's.

Steak was tough, potatoes augraten were hard. Noisy and overbooked. Chicken was barely warm.

Valentines Day

They sat us at a table that

I had an issue with my steak not being cooked properly or seasoned. The owner was walking around asking all the tables how things were going and I wasn't going to say anything but he insisted and I explained. He asked how they could make it better and I just got a different cut of meat. The replacement was very good and met all expectations. Very happy with the way the restaurant strives to make sure everything is great. Thanks for a great first time experience.

I always enjoy eating at Rudy's because of the excellent menu and the specials they promote on special days like Valentine's Day. The service is usually excellent which it was this time, other than a longer wait than usual for a glass of wine to arrive at my table. The food was super, but I did have to send my tuna back because it was delivered when it was cool and had to be rewarded. The chef came out and apologized. The special heart shaped cheesecake was delicious and there were left overs even with two people eating it. I recommend it to others.

All the food was good except my pork chop. It was not tender so I left most of it.

Food was delicious. Everyone enjoyed the atmosphere.

Good job by all!

Our waitress was efficient but not very friendly. The restaurant was packed. Service was impacted by the amount of people in for dinner. The food was good.

Rudy's is an excellent place to dine and the food is well prepared and presented! Really enjoyed dinner their with my children!

We had a great time. Mary our waitress was just what we were looking for. Competent but non-intrsive

Our server was amazing. She was patient and kind even after my husband accidentally spilled a beer on her and the floor. The food was outstanding. The environment is kind of loud so it is hard to hear the people at your table, but I am not sure there is much that can be done about that.

Dinner was amazing the service was impeccable always a good time thank you

My first meal was HORRIBLE. The fish was dry and luke warm, but I told the waitress and within 10 minutes I had a replacement meal of steak and shrimp and it was the best food I've had in a long time. Lesson learned on the halibut!

We totally enjoyed our evening at Rudy's Redeye Grill. From making reservations online, to our excellent waitress, to the tasty food, the overall experience was awesome!

The food was great and the ambiance beautiful. The service was a tiny bit slow, but it was not the fault of the server. I think she had too many tables to take care of. Maybe you were a bit understaffed that night.

High priced for a dry chicken breast. I have had my mother in laws crockpot all day dried out chicken breast before which that is hard to choke down,and this was worse. Except we paid 160.00 for this unfortunate meal. I had one rudytini which was great:") we got sat next to the pool side so it smells of chlorine and the children kept hitting our seats. Very unenjoyable.

Great service, the food was okay, not as good as it's been in the past. My New York was flavorful but a bit tough, enough to drop a star. Overall 4 out of 5 stars.

2 out of 3 orders were wrong.

We always enjoy going to Rudy’s redeye Grill to get together with friends!

Favorite Neighborhood Gem. Best food and atmosphere.

Busy, had dinner before a play across the street.
Great food. Felt a little rushed to make the play as it was very busy.

Our waitress in the back corner booth was amazingly helpful!

Hostess very snarky

It was very good except the noise is loud and annoying. The waitress was excellent.

Food was virtually unpalatable. The "hot" dishes were lukewarm at best. The long shallow pans on the buffet tables were not heated or covered, exposed to sneezes or any other foreign matter. The almost cold turkey slices (this was a Thanksgiving buffet) were dry. All the meats were presliced; there were no carvers. The dining area is adjacent to the liquor bar. Tables were crammed together. We were cheek by jowl next to diners at adjacent tables. It was exceedingly noisy; piped in music made it moreso.
Staying at home and eating frozen dinners would have been more satisfying and pleasanter.

I was very disappointed in the portion size of the walleye for the price of $25. Looked like a sunfish fillet Everything else was good.

Great food ,had the best maitress.

We had such great service at our last visit to Rudy's. We had a couple of mishaps at our table (our fault) but the server was cheerful, understanding, and attentive. That is one we reason we continue to visit Rudy's often.

Love this place! Nice atmosphere, good food, great drinks!!

My wife & I each had the pan-fried walleye and it was delicious. The service was great & the atmosphere was awesome. We will definitely be back.

The food was excellent and the service was great! The ambience is wonderful too. Great place to enjoy an evening out.

A bit noisy in the main dining area.....much better in the pool area. Overall would return and highly recommend.

I have been going to Rudys for 25 years. Consistently amazing in all aspects.

Waitress was amazing and attentive, we got seated right away with our reservations as well. Food was delicious--only complaint is fish was a just a little over cooked. Overall this was an awesome experience for my husband and I for our anniversary dinner. Highly recommend!!

Some diners enjoyed their food, ind felt it bland and over-cooked. Our waiter came across as ‘rushed’. Once our meals were served he didn’t return until we finally flagged him down. Had a nice time but could have sold more beverages had we received a little more attention.

Great food! We were packed in like sardines, we literally had to move tables to get around When getting in or out of our chairs. Inches away From the neighboring table peoples elbows to yours when sitting down.

Great ambiance and good food and of course the absolutely best drink the Ruditini! Had an issue with food temperature that was fixed quickly.

Excellent food and service! Noise was a bit too loud.

Great waitress and the food was amazing! Great ambiance!