Sunday: 10:30am til 2:00pm
Monday - Wednesday: 5:00pm-10:00pm
Thursday - Saturday: 5:00pm-11:00pm
We can accommodate up to 180 people in our three unique, beautifully appointed dining rooms. Or choose one of our private party room offering the elegant style and grace of an authentic Long Island Gold Coast Mansion. The Library Room can comfortably accomdate 50 guests while the Pine Room can accomodate 40 guests.
Once again, this great old steakhouse served up great food in a warm and friendly manner. One of the true great beef houses, and the absolute best one east of the NYC line!
Porterhouse was delish! Just wish sides were larger for the price
For the price bone-in ribeye was very bland. Cooked medium.
The steak was not great. We all ordered premium steaks and it was tough even cutting through it. The best thing was the oysters and the apple cobbler. Definitely not worth the money.
3 of our party of 4 were underwhelmed with our steaks and the appetizers. The wine selection was good as were the Manhattans and the" just a taste" dessert. I remember outstanding meals in the past.
Crowded, noisy,food was fine, waiter forgot our tea
Have not been here in a few years because the food was terrible so I was not overly disappointed when 7 of our 9 people had a horrible meal and the service was even worse not really sure how this place stays in business
Great service. Excellent steaks . Nice wine selection
Rothmann's is by far my favorite steakhouse. We sat, as requested, in the library room which I like a lot. Service was great as usual. However, and I hate to write this, but I ordered my filet mignon medium well and it came very well done. There was a piece that was so charred I couldn't eat it. I had to ask for steak sauce to make it a bit moist. We will continue to go, but I will order medium next time. Still love Rothmann's though.
Special family and friends from Korea
Filet mignon was rather chewy and dry. Asked for additional Demi glase & was given chunky steak sauce instead
We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves at Rothmann's Sunday brunch for the second time. My only complaint is that the servers at the lobster/clam/oyster bar and sushi bar left before we were finished with those sections (about 2 or 2:30). Although food was available at those sections I did want some sashimi from the sushi bar which was not available without the attendant.
Honestly, I've been there many times but not for awhile and this time, I was disappointed. We were there to celebrate an anniversary, my sword fish was fishy, the Petite Fillet Mignon was tough and prices were considerably elevated. Higher prices for less quality, leaves me wondering if I will return. However, the service and atmosphere was good.
Outstanding service and the food is cooked to perfection. The staff are personable, professional and knowledgeable. An all around fantastic experience.
Asked for medium rare and got well done. Had to wait for 15mins for the right steak and when it came out the steak was horrible and had no flavor. Everything needed salt. Disappointing b/c I enjoyed this place in the past and have been there several times before.
The restaurant was so noisy that we could not even converse with the people sitting next to us. We all ordered the porterhouse steaks for 2 medium rare, and they were both served medium. Although the meat was pink, it was very dry (highly unusual for a prime meat of this cut). The pricing was comparable to Peter Lugers and Bryant and Coopers. However, the quality of the steak was not even close. We will not be returning.
Food was excellent but the service was blah. It is not usually like that.
Seafood platter was great start and bone-in NY strip was cooked perfectly. Great wine recommendations from the sommelier.
The Rothmann's team did a great job helping me celebrate my 30th Birthday with my family. Everything from the food to the service and overall hospitality was top notch. The Sommelier Sean really knows his stuff and provided impeccable wine service. We really felt very comfortable the entire time and the food was absolutely outstanding. Job well done!
Love their Dinner for Two special available M-Th for $50 pp. Great choices and portion sizes and the food is fabulous!
As usual, everything was excellent! The only reason I rated the review 4 stars instead of 5 stars was due to a loud table relatively close to us. Other than that, excellent food and wine!!
Sunday brunch was great - plenty of good food. Good service.
I have been to Rothmans on many occasions. The food, atmosphere and service never fails. I have recommended this restaurant to many people and have always had great comments.
The Sunday Brunch at Rothmann's is amazing. Made to order pancakes, waffles & omlettes. Cold seafood and sushi, salads breaks cakes and a chocolate fountain. Wow!
Waiter service was excellent. One manager had weak interpersonal skills and was poor at resolving error with order.
First time at Rothman's, will definitely return.
Food was exceptional and service very attentive.
Management and staff were both amazing. Food was perfect. The deal offered Monday-Thursday can’t be beat!
We really enjoyed our meal here! Our waiter was attentive yet not intrusive. Our decision to dine early meant we had a quiet uncrowded restaurant to enjoy.
Awesome as always the petite fillet was excellent char perfectly cooked and a 3 pound steam lobster was awesome cream spinach best yet blows Lugar's out of the water and the roasted garlic mashed were awesome
The food was perfectly seasoned. The service was first class. The value was good. Will be returning soon.
Dominick was a wonderful waiter. The food was delicious !
Great value, great food, but dessert options could have been better!
9 of us for a college graduation celebration. Great food, great drinks, great service!
I love the ambiance. So clubby for Long Island.
However, I was not impressed with my porterhouse steak. Moreover, this was a birthday and I expressly wrote on Open Table that it was a celebration. No one remembered, however, the waiter did return with a candle on melted ice cream.
The manager did express regrets, but it was too late.
Food was exceptionally delicious and the service was exceptional. We enjoyed it.
I took my Mother to Rothmann’s for Mother’s Day. We both loved it. From the appetizers to the dessert were wonderful. All of the staff were very nice. We will be back soon.
Had a great time as always .. good food great ambiance
Awesome service and food