We love Rothmann's! Great food, fresh food, love the steak and the sides. Would definitely recommend the Sunday brunch!
Rothmans is my favorite restaurant on Long Island and they alway exceed my expectations.
Everything was pretty good and I would return. Everyone in our group pretty much agreed on two things the deserts were ehhh waste of time. The manager John was very rude with no personality. The hostess said he was new and she apologized. Aside from the poor management and below average deserts we would return.
The best steakhouse on Long Island. Hands down I’ve been to them all. Service Is top notch, drink selection is on point. If your in the mood for an amazing steak dinner then this is the place. Steaks are always cooked perfectly and the menu runs deep.
food was prepared to our liking. service was very good. Everything was done with class and taste
Excellent service and fantastic food
Just a great solid place.
Appetizers were quite good, entrees not so much. Wife ordered the $55 lamb chops, they were so fatty, through-out every bite, they we're un-edible. No joke. Worst chops she ever had. Manager took them off the bill, I ordered the Asian marinated skirt steak, it was ok, but my fault, not the right dish to order in a steak house. We should have ordered a straight up Porterhouse for 2. I think the high end chain steak houses have better food. On a nice note, beautiful restaurant and the service was impeccable, however, you just need to stick with their basics apparently.
Service was excellent. Very attentive, but not obtrusive. We both ordered steaks - my wife’s was perfect (med-rare), but mine was over cooked med-well instead of med-rare. Appetizer (calamari) and desert (flan) were delicious. The seating area was lively, but not loud, with a mix of couples, families and groups. I would recommend.
Great food...attentive staff.
Excellent in every way. Our first visit and we will be sure to return.
We were a party of 4 and we went for the brunch. We arrived a little before our reservation time of 11am and were seated promptly. The Brunch buffet was delicious and very good value based on what was included.
We weren't rushed at all.
The service was slow or non-existent. We had to 'hunt' down our waiter for additional drinks and coffee. This area needs to be improved! If we had attentive wait staff, then I would give the service a five star review...but this put a damper on our otherwise enjoyable brunch.
Was pleasantly surprised and will try it again
The food was good, but we had a bit of a problem with a sauce that spilled on someone. I wasn't really happy with how it was handled. It was an accident and I am sure it probably doesn't often happen, but it was really awkward. I was disappointed since I had hoped my guests would have had a great night dining there.
We always have a top notch experience at Rothmann’s! Whether it’s to spoil ourselves for no good reason or to celebrate a special occasion we are never disappointed and always have a fabulous time! The wait staff is amazing- we never want for anything at the table because they are always at least one step ahead! The steak is the best on LI! We also love Sean. He always takes his time to talk to us about the wines and never disappoints with his recommendations for us. Thanks for always taking good care of us and always giving us a great experience!
Great, as always. I travel from Manhasset to Rothmann's rather than go to closer steak houses because the ones nearer me are so obnoxious. My only food complaint: the Brussels sprouts were mushy (tasted like they'd been fully steamed before they were roasted). Huge thank you to the man who might have been the sommelier! He brought us our wine and other drinks, and gave us a very interesting education on the type of gin in one of the drinks. It really was interesting! Great guy, very friendly and knowledgeable.
The meal was flawless. We had the special Chateaubriand for 2 that we ordered rare. The meal was prepared correctly with an excellent surface sear, finished off with a uniform rare interior. The portion was also sizable for two. The sweet potato fries were extra crispy, but the creamed spinach was laking. Too much spinach and not enough cream....this is not supposed to be a healthy dish!
Returned to Rothmann's Sunday Brunch and it was excellent.....prime rib was cooked perfect, slightly pink and very tasty....skirt steak was juicy, nice crust, flavorful....unlimited lobster tails is a great deal, they were slightly on the tough side though, perhaps overcooked a few minutes.
Great fresh pancakes, eggs benedict is their weak spot, almost no hollandaise sauce on these and eggs were very runny....excellent seafood selection. nice salads...desserts are small bites rather than cakes, pies, etc but very good.
Considering the surf and turf alone is regularly $49, at $49 for the whole brunch, it's a good buy. Waiter was very accommodating.
This was my third visit to Rothmann's for brunch. I was a little early this time and was seated waiting for the rest of my party to arrive. I realized something pretty awesome about this place. They remembered me as a repeat customer. The nice hostess, Francesca, made me feel very welcome from the minute i walked in. She engaged me in conversation while i was waiting for my friends. She remembered the last couple of visits i made there and that made me feel special. Our server and the gentleman at the carving station remembered me as well. Always pleasant, engaging and personable. The food is pretty good but when you couple it with a great staff, it makes for a better memorable time. Rothmann's should be commended for it's hospitality. My compliments to the staff.
The food was fantastic! The service was fantastic! Most steakhouses have tables on top of each other to maximize the amount of people in the restaurant. Not at Rothmanns. There was sufficient space between tables which made for enjoyable conversation without hearing all of the conversations around us. We never felt rushed and the waiter was very accommodating. Can’t wait to go back!
We went for our friends Birthday. It’s is by far the best steakhouse out there , never disappointed
Everything was excellent, can't wait to go back. Beef was cooked perfectly.
This was date night with my wife and I. My head waiter’s service was almost horrible. Every other table my head waiter spoke too, read off the specials of the day and even joked around. He was rude to us. The only reason I gave a 3 is because of the waiter’s helper. The helper was AMAZING, respectful and attentive. If I could judge this restaurant on the HEAD LEAD WAITER, I would have given -1. My wife did not have a good time and with young toddlers at home that we paid a babysitter for, we were saddened and disappointed by our experience.
Waiters were very nice, but service was very slow. Three of us, no wine, no dessert, still took an hour and forty five mins to get out if there. Valets were also very slow. Place is nice, food was good. Might have just been a bad night.
Solid place to eat with great service. Wobbly table was the only downside. Makes it tough to cut a steak when the whole table shakes.
Valentine’s Day dinner.. Our food was great.. friendly staff and great atmosphere.. would definitely go again and recommend friends and family..
It was a lovely time. Food was excellent. The surroundings were elegant.
Other then the hostess not finding my opentable reversations and feeling a little rushed due to Valentine’s Day. Everything was good
Knowledgeable staff. Offered great recommendations for dinner and wine.
Great service! Highly recommend Rothmanns. Can’t wait to go back
The server breaks the cork on a very valuable bottle of wine. Did not place the worm deep enough. Sommelier should have extracted the cork. A cork that cannot be saved for the special occasion. Difficult to get the waiter’s attention. Service became slow toward the end. Very busy but the management should have anticipated that on Valentine’s day and added more staff. The food was very good. Steak cooked to perfection. Been to this restaurant quite a few times over the years. Food is the consistent expectation. Need some improve in other areas.
Birthday Dinner was fabulous. We tried tuna trio sushi and it was great!
Very friendly and attentive wait staff. Food was delicious, One of the steaks was ordered medium rare and was served rare, but the waiter took care of it promptly. Very warm and inviting atmosphere I would highly recommend it and go again.
Food was average fish was dry. Steak was cooked medium well asked for medium. Lobster Mac and cheese bland and lobster was very fishy
In the reservation I was asked if it was a special occasion , I said a birthday. Nothing was mentioned. We got porterhouse for 4 ( $200 worth of steak) and it was over cooked I little disappointed
Very good food, excellent service. Could be a bit quieter, but we had a great dinner. Would certainly recommend.
Always enjoy a night out at Rothman’s. The porterhouse for two was excellent. Our waiters were attentive and encouraging.
Wait staff was impeccable !
Food was excellent!
Great anniversary dinner. Food amazing. Excellent captain Zakir.
Steve at the bar was outstanding as well as our service and meal. Perfect night all around !