Nearby points of interest
Nearby points of interest
About Rothmann's Steakhouse
Rothmann’s upholds the traditions of the past by serving a classic steakhouse menu with great additions from the present. We serve only the best, USDA Prime Dry-Aged steaks. Inventive daily black board specials with sushi and fresh local fish. A redesigned bar with an expanded whisky and bourbon list should broaden you palate. And our new wine dispensing system that pours 2, 4, or 6 ounce pours of first growth Bordeaux and cult Napa cabernets to perfection. Come experience the grandeur of Long Island’s famed Gold Coast for yourself, where prime dry-aged steaks and great wine have become tradition.
East Norwich, NY 11732
Steakhouse, Sushi, Seafood
Hours of Operation:
Monday - Wednesday: 5:00pm-10:00pm
Thursday - Saturday: 5:00pm-11:00pm
$50 and over
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
We offer complementary valet seven days a week.
Private Party Facilities:
Whether you're having an intimate dinner, a private party, a business event or a gala celebration Rothmann's is the perfect setting for you and your guests. Our event planner will help you make your special event absolutely perfect. And of course, the food and service at Rothmann's is nothing short of impeccable.
We can accommodate up to 180 people in our three unique, beautifully appointed dining rooms. Or choose one of our private party room offering the elegant style and grace of an authentic Long Island Gold Coast Mansion. The Library Room can comfortably accomdate 50 guests while the Pine Room can accomodate 40 guests.
Private Party Contact:
Christina Volpe: (516) 922-2500
Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, BYO Wine, Corkage Fee, Fireplace, Full Bar, Non-Smoking, Outdoor dining, Private Room, Takeout, Weekend Brunch, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Special Events & Promotions:
Our event planner will handle everything for you, right down to the smallest detail. They'll help you choose from a sumptuous selection of world-class cuisine, while our friendly, knowledgeable sommelier will help you pick the perfect wines to compliment your menu. Evening events can be hosted in either of our two private parties and afternoon parties are available Monday - Saturday. Our private library room holds 55 guests while the pine room holds 40 guests.
Rothmann's Steakhouse Ratings and Reviews
Nice spot to bring a business dinner guest or a romantic interest. Pricey, but worth it. The bar area has been redone since the last time I was there. Besides the steak loving public, Rothmann's also seems to cater to the upscale 30 something crowd. With the bar area and dining area separate that did not create any distraction. Recommended.
The wine list is extensive and has many wonderful half bottle options so you can try more than one without overdoing it. The sommelier is outstanding and loves to talk about wine and will gladly recommend something if you're not quite sure what you want. The service is attentive without being intrusive which makes it a great place if you want to actually talk with your companions. The food is a nice combination of steak house classics and some more inventive fare all of it executed with skill.
The servers here acknowledged that we were all talking too much so gave us an indicator (menues piled together) to let them know we were ready to order. This way they didn't keep asking if we were ready. The steak Diane was phenomenal and the various appetizers were amazingly flavourful. Their wine list is impressive!
I been to quite a few steak house and this bone-in fillet is the best steak that I ever had.
I would see on the television food shows where the host comments on the steak melting in
his mouth....his is the first time I actually experience that....Most delicious I ever had.
The service at Rothmanns was fantastic and the food was delicious. My dinner party included my husband and myself, but we saw a few large groups at dinner celebrating special occassions. It is suitable for both small and large parties. It is perfect for a quiet night out with friends and loved ones. I was very happy with my dining experience.
Went with my brother for dinner on the Friday before labor day. I had been to Rothmans both out on LI and in NYC many times over the years. Both places are expensive but worth if you enjoy a dry aged steak. Last Friday they outdid themselves. We both had the large boneless sirloin, charred, medium rare. The steaks and were cooked to perfection and the taste was off the charts.
Possibly one of the best steaks I have ever eaten, and I've got a well of experience to draw on for comparison. The salad and sides were terrific as always but I'll remember the steak for a long time.
It was an overall nice dining experience. I have been here before for brunch and thought the food was better on my previous visits. The buffet seemed to be less extensive and the quality of the lobsters was fair. I will probably try it again, but I am not running to get there!
I had been to Rothman's once before and was extremely satisfied. This meal they was excellent as well! Starting with the lobster Mac & Cheese, a perfectly cooked cut of steak and a few glasses of wine. Rothman's is a great place to celebrate a special occasion or just have a great meal !
Food was mediocre at best - no clue how they stay in business. Cocktail sauce with bread, who came up with that - very odd combination. T-bone steak was very fatty and lacked any real flavor, Amish chicken was undercooked, server had to be flagged down anytime we need something (they were not busy at all). We ate very little yet the server nor the manager that walked around(but never looked over at any of the tables) asked if everything was okay. Would not recommend - very dissapointed, there are far better places to get steak in New York. Chain quality food with fine dining prices - not fair to diners.
We celebrated our 2nd wedding anniversary here. We had a wonderful time. I ordered the petite filet minion cooked to perfection. My husband had the swordfish which he loved!! Our accompaniments were grilled artichokes and potatoe croquets. All was unbelievable! Service was ok. The ambiance was terrific. We had a really comfy booth too.
We went for Sunday brunch at the 10:30 seating. there was no alcohol served until noon. All the servers did was to clear off the dishes since it was a buffet. a gratuity of 18% was added to the bill. That was too high considering that the servers did very little.
Rothman's has a lovely atmosphere and more people waiting on you than I have ever had before. The meal started with a basket filled with a variety of rolls and bread which were all good. My husband enjoyed his baked clams and salmon. I had chicken provencale (basically chicken parm) which was good but not exceptional. The portion was huge, 3 cutlets on a piece of bread. We shared an order of potato croquettes which were excellent. I had the fried brownies sundae for dessert. It included 4 brownies and ice cream. It was a chocolate lover's dream! Price was reasonable for the food, service and atmosphere.
We dine in fine steakhouses a lot. Maybe because of being too busy with graduation parties we had a bad experience. We were seated in a noisy backroom where there were 2 large parties. The one large party was out of control - loud with people going back and forth and many standing around talking, no one from the restaurant made any effort to control the crowd.
Our service was poor. We couldn't tell the wait staff from bus boys. We had 4 men who were clearing, taking orders, serving and they were not friendly or attentive. They were more concerned with clearing and rearranging the tables from large family that departed than waiting on our table. The food was good but not great. We don't need to give this place another try.
We really enjoy Rothmann's for a special dinner. Our dinner, this time, did not disappoint us. The food is consistory well prepared and the wait staff was attentive but not obtrusive. We recommend Rothmann's for a special dinner and will definitely go back again.
Rothmann's is the best steakhouse on LI. Excellent food, good service, lovely setting. The food is terrific but could benefit from some expansion in the healthy categories for the women of the men who love their steaks -- we might like some veggie options. A perfect spot for Father's Day!
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.