Amazing staff and food!!! Highly recommended this place

2nd anniversary, absolutely amazing . Had the wagu beef and it was outstanding worth the money

The midweek special is the best value around and the food is beyond delicious!

We had an excellent dinner at Rothmans. I would highly recommend to anyone looking for an authentic new york steakhouse experience. Check it out!

Delicious food, excellent service, and good ambiance even for being outside in the parking lot.

Dined outside and enjoyed the nice space they created adjacent to the main restaurant building. Food was superb and service very prompt. Highly recommended.

The $49 summer special is incomparable. Just an amazing deal . Filet mignon and lobster tail were great, creamed spinach was just right. Only issue was they were out of the reasonably priced wine we ordered and they didn't offer any comparably prices alternative.

We had the opportunity to dine outside at Rothmann's the other night. They tried hard to make the experience delightful with a tent in the parking lot, chandeliers and white tablecloths. The staff was attentive, but still it takes longer for the food to come from the kitchen. It was a humid night and slightly uncomfortable with no breeze in the tent. The experience was still nice, the staff excellent and food of high quality. We had the price fixe menu, which offered abundant portions. If you prefer to eat outside during these days, I would certainly recommend Rothmann's Steakhouse.

Food was great but service didn’t meet the price point.

Anniversary

Dined mid week and had the three course special.....great value.

The summer special is a great value. Food cooked to perfection, abundant side dishes and fantastic service.

My friends and I had a great time for my friend’s birthday. Food was amazing. Will be back again soon!

This Long Island classic never disappoints. The $49 Prix fixed menu was above and beyond. Generous portions of surf and turf cooked to perfection. Even during a period of social distancing, they made us feel warm and welcome. Dining is offering outside or inside both with attentive service. Highly recommend.

The $49 price fixe is a great deal. For the outside seating the tables were nicely spaced. People were eating inside, but while the tables themselves may have been placed apart, people eating at one table were too close to the next table for my comfort.

Wonderful meal! The Prixe Fixe excellent!!!

Great special- $49 for a three course meal with great options. Probably the best deal on Long Island. Sunday-Thursday only. Overall a great restaurant with both indoor and outdoor dining. Highly recommended.

Food and service excellent

Rothmans refused to honor a coupon we had for a special priced 3 course dinner. Although they said it was not good on Saturday , there were no restrictions indicated in the pennysaver ad#bait and switch? It’s a great place with great food but what they did to our party of 5 was scandalous. If I had a good email address I would have tried that first to post a picture of the ad. Be careful of
Their advertising of special prices !!

Horrible service

Great place. Nice to see it back open. I miss the banana cream pie though.

Great steak! Excellent service. Wonderful experience. I will be back!

LONG wait b/w app and main courses when no one was there.

If you are closed then dont allow reservations to be made. What a joke

I have been coming to Rothmann’s steak House for the last 10 years I come once a month food is great the people bringing out your food is great but lately I’ve been having problems with the Waiter I was there on Sunday and the waiter I got this is the fourth time this happened to me they don’t come and ask you if you want to drink they just come at like they just don’t care I think management should know that they should train the waiters a little bit better

Outside dining was hot and buggy. Recommendations: add fans (overhead preferred and spray for flys and yellow jackets )
Food and staff service was excellent.

Fantastic food as always with amazing service. First place my wife and I went for date night since the lockdown and so glad that we did!

Outside dining , perfect night, staff wore masks , felt very safe , table distance was good, food as usual was great
Celebrated my birthday , with a candle

This special occasion dining experience was marred by rushed service and a tilted table.

Excellent service and meal - always pleased with what we get.

PERFECT AS ALWAYS...WE LOOK FORWARD TO EACH AND EVERY VISIT,WAITERS ARE SO NICE TO OUR GRANDCHILDREN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Oysters were terrible.

Sunday-Thursday pre fixe menu is AMAZING. Lobster shrimp bisque Has chunks of lobster and shrimp in a flavorful bisque. The Surf and Turf (lobster and filet) is an amazing value. The desserts are delicious and side selection is extensive.

Another excellent meal at Rothmann's! The food and service is terrific.

Consistently great food and service. It’s a high end steakhouse so don’t get sticker shock. My favorite restaurant of all time.

We ate outside and it was quite noisy. Nothing much could be done about that. The food is always good, but pricey.

Food was terrible. Service eh. Such a disappointing experience

The steak was the best we have ever eaten in recent memory. It was the porterhouse and we had it for 4. Zero complaints! Everything we ordered was delicious and on point.

I would make one suggestion to Rothmann's and every restaurant right now. You are taking all these precautions and doing great! BUT....you refill water glasses with the same pitcher for every customer. I don't mind any potential germs and I welcome exposure to build immunity. Many elderly folks dine and may be exposed to potentially fatal germs (ie COVID). My suggestion is a water bottle on each table to refill tap water glasses instead of a communal pitcher.

As always, Rothmans was superb. It was my birthday and I was there with my wife and my children. We had a wonderful meal and a wonderful time!

Very attentive and had a nice evening celebrating a birthday.