Exceptional and relaxing dinner. Service was seamless.

Excellent experience! We so appreciate the individualized attention we received from the maitre'd , Diego, and our server , Johnny. Very personable, and the food was excellent

Amazing meal. Great service.

The food, service, and ambiance were wonderful! We had a lovely dinner!

The hostess was amazing! So warm and friendly. But our waiter was a total dud and the food unremarkable. It was pricey but I’m not sure what we paid for. Certainly not the service.

Relief from the heatwave inside this classic NY landmark restaurant. Early dinner on a Tuesday so it was very quiet. A generous portion of salmon and mashed potatoes. It could have used a bit more flavor. The dinner rolls were a let down. They were cold and dry. They didn’t ruin the meal. I will always return to Rosie’s

Never disappointed! Staff and food were great. Would recommend this restaurant.

Es la 3ra vez que visitamos NYC y cenamos en este lugar. Relación precio/calidad muy buena

We ended up inside due to rain making the day humid. Very attentive service, the food was good.

Our waiter was very distracted and the service we received was not up to par with the other restaurants we visited while in NYC. We had high hopes because the restaurant was across the street from our hotel. The food was okay, but not great. And for the price I paid for crab cakes, I expected a better quality meal.

Great service and great people, the host was amazing. Great energy.

We met our daughter and friend for a dinner. The staff was friendly and attentive and the atmosphere was quiet and relaxed. We were able to relax and take our time ordering. The menu had a nice selection and the food was good. The prices were also reasonable. I would go back again.

Restaurant is closed. We had open table reservations for two days. Restaurant was closed when we got there.

One if my favorites. Always a great place with wonderful staff.

Great atmosphere.
Great food.
Great background music.
Overall a pleasant experience.

Been there many times. Always good food. Service was great this time but no one was there. Still enjoyed the food and had a great time.

excellent service from the door to dessert - what a treat!!! I loved loved and will definitely be back

This place has a nice variety of dishes, and everything we had was very tasty! The host was exceptionally nice. The service could have been a bit more attentive, but he was busy. Overall, it was a lovely experience. Don’t hesitate to go.

Server was rude. Food was good. Getting her to take our order and get a glass of water took real effort

Foood was terrible and so was service

Felt so lucky to have Kathleen serving us- she was wonderful!

The food was mediocre. The crab cake sandwich was definitely not lump crab. Bland with fillers and had a fishy taste. The California grilled chicken sandwich was also bland. Fries were well done. Price was average for NY. Would not make a point to go back.

Our favorite go to spot before seeing a show. Service and food always great!

Convenient location for theater district. Wait staff was reasonable attentive but not friendly. Food was just OK .

Everything about it was terrible, including the manners of the host.

Diego was an incredible host, and my food was perfect. The entire experience was 5 stars!

It was fully amazing birthday dinner!
We enjoyed the crab cakes and the fish and chips totally!

Great people - Great Food!

Great pre theatre brunch location for 9 people. They had a regular menu as well as a prix fix menu. The regular menu had lots of choices but did have limited salads. The menu had just changed and they had eliminated a couple of very good sounding salad options. Never the less, the service was great, and there was plenty of room to spread out.

Fabulous gentleman barkeep downstairs got us the bottles of Veuve Clicquot and Dom Perignon 2008 along with the style of goblet from which I prefer to drink. With his attention to our wishes the late evening was enhanced in our enjoyment!

Pub Grub ... hungry eating, good portions.
Friendly staff , busy environment more an after work meet-up than a choice !
Enjoyable group atmosphere.
Not fine dining, good for a casual first date.

The beet salad was very good .
I ordered Shepard’s pie it was okay. My husband had French onion soup
Was good but not very hot . His steak was tough .. food was okay .. it was close to hotel and it was satisfying.

Food and service was outstanding.

We had an excellent time. The food was good, the servers were friendly and prompt. One in our party had a food (dairy) allergy, and the accommodated perfectly.

Norwegian salmon was excellent. Norwegian salmon was excellent.

Was amazing food and service. We were there for our 20th Anniversary dinner before going to a show. Everything came in a timely manner and the amount of food was perfect. The service was outstanding. Deserts were delicious. Will recommend to anyone wanting an amazing dinner.

Dinner plate had small portions

GREAT location. Vibrant place to go to dinner with the family. Great selection.

Everything was wonderful.

I have been a long term fan of Rosie O'Grady. My wife and I haven't dined their in long time and it was a pleasure to return.