We spend the day preparing delicious, one-of-a-kind meals. Our pasta is hand made daily, and our ingredients are source locally and are always fresh!
Italy is known for more than just the cuisine, which is why Roma also offers the fine Italian wines to compliment the food. Along with regular wine selections, a Reserve List is available for those wine enthusiasts with a taste for something special.
Menu
John is the best! Food is amazing. Thank you Chef.
This was the first time we went to this particular restaurant. The waiter was very knowledgeable about the menu, told us a little about the restaurant’s history, and was very attentive without being overbearing. The salad, main courses, and desserts we had at our table were all delicious. We WILL be dining there again!
Excellent as always! Fabulous Italian food and authentic.
This was our first time there and we LOVED it! Food was excellent and the service was wonderful!
Great food and really great service!
Great date location. It was quiet so we could take. Authentic Italian feel. Great experience.
We had a very enjoyable time at Roma. All of the course selections were wonderful. Jennifer got everything we needed promptly and made some excellent recommendations.
We had a delightful double date with some of our best friends for Valentine’s Day dinner. The pasta and seafood special, scallops, were delightful and as always the desserts and wine list fully appreciate it! We love how intimate and personal our experience always is here!
Authentic, flavorful and attention to every detail. I feel like I'm in Rome every time we have dinner here.
Loved this restaurant. A true Italian experience with excellent service and a personalized touch. Tucked away in the back of Monon Square which is going to be razed. I certainly hope that Roma will continue thereafter as it is a jewel. Reasonably priced including the wine list. Bottle of Barolo was delish. Gnocchi was so good I wished for another serving. If you haven’t tried Roma, you are missing out. Next time you crave Italian food give this place a shot.
Way overpriced for very mediocre food.
Delicious food, nice atmosphere, great authentic italian-owned and operated restaurant. Outstanding service with no rushing us.
Waitstaff were professional and nicely dressed. Host was polite and accommodating. Loved the ambiance!
Tucked away in a run down little mall in Carmel, once you clear the entry you enter a very quaint, comfortable Italian restaurant that clearly cares about your experience. The food was very good, service was great. The authentic Italian feel was just what we were looking for. We will make this a new go to place for sure. Great wine list but no liquor, must only have wine and beer license.
Best gnocchi I have ever had outside of my grandmothers kitchen! I highly recommend this restaurant!
Food was excellent again and one of the great things here is the consistency of staff. We had a same server as once before with great service as always. It was reasonably quiet. By 8 as we finished the restaurant was almost full on a Friday.
One disappointing change was the charcuterie board is no longer on appetizer menu. It was a favorite, best in the area.
First time here for my wife and I. Our pasta was fresh, as fresh as making it the same day. Finishing it off with Gelato was perfect. John provided excellent service. We highly recommend Roma Ristorante.
My husband and I ate here for the first time on a Saturday night. The service here is lovely. The food is the best Italian food in the city. I was so surprised by this delightful restaurant.
Absolutely loved this restaurant and can’t believe we’ve never eaten there before after living in Westfield more than 10 years. Not a fancy place but truly authentic, delicious Italian food. We will be back soon!
Food was good. The menu knowledge of the waitress was average and at authentic Italian restaurant, this is important for uneducated consumers.
Great food and cozy dining area
Best Italian food in Carmel, IN
Great food at a reasonable price. Waitress was extremely efficient. It was a little too noisy for us. We could not hear each other talk.
Always an enjoyable dining experience!!
The place was absolutely incredible! Great food!
Lovely restaurant. Instrumental music would be preferred, allowing conversation.
Had an assortment of appetizers, all were outstanding. For entrees 2 had the special of the evening, 1 had the Pappardelle Boscaiola and last 1 had a filet with Gorgonzola sauce. All of us were totally satisfied. I have been to Italy a half a dozen times and this restaurant is absolutely the authentic best! Try the gelato, it is amazing!
We love this restaurant ! The service and the food are always wonderful.
Wonderful restaurant and amazing service and food! We will definitely be back!
Get the Rack of Lamb! It was excellent; well grilled with beautiful presentation
Perfect date night or before a Palladium event- always great!
Outstanding. We’ve been to Italy 5 times and struggle to find Italian cuisine in Indy even close to the real thing. But Roma is the real deal. Pasta aldente, sauce superb and not overbearing or soupy, with a good wine list. Great menu and specials. And the service is terrific! If Olive Garden is your idea of great Italian food I’m so sorry. Visit Roma to experience authentic Italy. Ciao!
Great food and service. We will be back. Good for group or a date
Anniversary
Delicious, home made Italian food by Italian chef. Thoughtful preparation and freshest ingredients. Pasta hand made every day. Knowledgeable wait staff. A must for people who really enjoy good food.
We have dined many times at Roma. The menu is both interesting and delicious and the service is always prompt and friendly. Don't miss this gem, tucked away in the back corner of Monon Center strip mall. Plenty of free parking right on the doorstep!
Have eaten here three times while attending concerts at the Palladium. We walk the Monon Trail there, always great food.
Ding on service was due to waiting a fairly long time before our server acknowledged us. In all fairness, they had a large party on the next room. Food was very good, nice portions. Large party probably caused a lot of the noise level issues.
Wonderful food. Wait staff was thoughtful with suggestions and friendly without being intrusive. We recommend this restaurant highly. Quality is outstanding—do not be put off by the appearance of the shopping center/strip mall in which it is located.
Always good food and good service
