J. Gilbert’s – Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood - Worthington
Thanksgiving Dinner Special Menus & Offers
Join us for our 3-course Plated Turkey Dinner (reg. menu also served)
Adults: $39, Kids 12 & Under: $19
Thursday, November 22, 2018
Bread crumbs all over banquette seat. Staffer who seated us let us wipe it off ourselves and acted offended when we commented on it. No apology given. It was peak time but an apology and some acknowledgment would have gone a long way toward making our experience as good as we have come to expect at this restaurant.
Always a good choice! Never have had a bad experience here! They always make it right.
We spontaneously decided to go one evening this week when I received an email with a coupon. The restaurant was busier than expected but the layout provides a cozy experience. Our waiter, Raynor, was excellent - super personable! The swordfish special that night was excellent. The experience turned what would have been a boring evening at home into a very nice date night.
I go to J. Gilbert's for my birthday dinner every year, and I am never disappointed.
Excellent as always
Went for a Birthday dinner. Wine and food were great. 3 course meal plan was excellent!
Wonderful food and service
My Wife's BBQ Ribs had way too much gristle. Out of our party, there were several different steaks that were not cooked as ordered. The lobster mac-and-cheese was dry, and lacked cheese. None the less, we still
were able to enjoy ourselves.
We went to J Gilbert's for date night and it was perfect... nice wine, we split a trio of filets and so had room for a dessert of berries in creme Anglaise before going to a movie nearby.
Outstanding meal! The scallops are in a class of their own! Lobster mac & cheese.... enough said!! Beautiful restaurant, over the top wine menu. Our server Erin was a GEM! She made the whole expierence extremely fun! Hope to get back soon! I'd highly recommend this place to anyone!
J Gilbert's is our go to restaurant. It feels like a neighborhood place. Great steaks. Try it.
J Gilbert's never disappoints! I go at least once a month and the food, service and wine list are one of the best in Columbus.
Good food nice atmosphere excellent server his name is Alan
We had a great time and the service and food was fantastic!
WE have been regulars for many years. The food, service and atmosphere is always excellent and consistently so. It is our favorite place in Columbus Ohio.
Strip Steak was cold and no flavor. Waiter was friendly but would forget things.
Always awesome, This is the restaurant we compare all others to to determine value and how well we like them.
We come for our anniversary the last two years and it has been superb everytime we come. Love it
One of the best meals I've experience in Columbus. Steak was perfect and on par with the top steakhouses in Columbus. The sides were to die for.
Not one miss on any of the food at our table of 6. Everyone had a great meal and raved about it days later. Excellent choice for my sons 18th birthday. My 16 yr old ordered the Tomahawk Steak! 32oz on the bone. Huge cut of meat and cooked to perfection.
We had Porthouse steak, Filet Mignon, Tomahawk Steak, Ribeye Cowboy Cut, Salmon, Blue Cheese Chips, Lobster Mac and Cheese, Burnt Ends Mac and Cheese, Cream Corn with Bacon.
Excellent as always
We were in Columbus for a concert and they do a fine job and very attentive. We will be back
Love J Gilbert’s for the food and normally top notch service but server was really bad this trip. Had to ask for refills. Asked 3x for steak sauce. Sat finished for 10-15 min with no sign of server. Someone else stopped by to take empty plates at that point we had to ask that person to get him. He forgot we had items ordered to go. Extremely slow and inattentive. Will ask for a different server if we get the same person again.
Food was delicious.
Yearly family date on 10/31
The food was delicious and our server did a great job
Quiet, cozy, and romantic setting with excellent food and service. Impressive wine list, portions, and desserts.
Enjoyed the food, and great service from our waitress. It had been a while since I have eaten here, the Cajun filet with mushroom risotto was perfectly executed, sourdough bread was delivered piping-hot to our table.
Very bad experience there. 3 times in a row now. Our dinner took almost an hour to arrive and then was not prepared correctly. The recook took 25 minutes. We love J.Gilberts. I am not sure what’s going on there. Very disappointing..
I read on the site that there would be live music on Saturday at 7:00 there wasn’t any. Was seated in a back room no music no fireplace. Would not go back
We celebrated several special occasions at dinner. Jackson, our waiter, did an outstanding job. His menu suggestions were excellent. The stuffed sole special was enjoyed by half our group and the other half raved about the beef. A wonderful evening with delicious food and outstanding service.
Loved all of the selections of sides, especially the carrots. Food was very good (good portions) and the menu was diverse. We enjoyed speaking with our waiter, Patrick.
It was wonderful
We went for a later in the evening dinner and was not disappointed. The menu is fantastic and we were not disappointed with our entrees. In addtion to the great food, our waiter, I think his name was David, was nothing short of fantastic.
To sommarize, Jackson and Austin rock! Portions seems to be shrinking over the years, especially the crab in the bisque. Overall, we always enjoy outselves and the food.
JGs has always been one of our favs but very disappointed last night... salmon not cooked as i asked for well done, carrots hard, server didn't take my coupon off check.. disappointing experience
Filets were cooked to our specifications and delicious. The scallops were wonderful, better than the crab cake which still gave a solid showing. The mushroom risotto was outstanding, and we're not risotto people normally - lots of large flavorful bites of mushroom throughout. Sourdough bread is served warm and very tasty, nice crusty exterior with soft inside. The pablano potatoes were a bit over hyped. It's a on the pricey side, but the food stand up to the price well. Good for special occasions and nicer inside than you might expect from the location and exterior. Will definitely return for another visit.
Always a great experience here. The food is delicious and my steak has always been cooked exactly how I order it. The only issue on this visit was I thought our meals came out a little slower than usual but it was a week night and we had a large party. It was still a wonderful meal. I love to go here.
Always good food and service. Charlotte was an exceptional server.
The food was excellent aged sirloin and filets were awesome. Service and the waiter was exceptional for having a sweetest day celebration. A little noisy from a large group sitting near us however they left before our dinner came which made the night wonderful. We will be back and recommend to our friends
My husband and I decided to celebrate our anniversary by eating out at different restaurants from Saturday through Monday (our actual anniversary day). Our first dinner was here. What a wonderful way to start celebrating!!! Aimee was the best waitress ever. Recommendations to try were excellent, from soup to meals to desserts. Will definitely go back (and that’s an hour and a half drive from home).