The service and ambiance at Red Circle Inn were outstanding. However, the food wasn't quite worth the amount of money we paid for dinner. I would not revisit this location again.

We had a birthday dinner there and it was just wonderful in all aspects. Highly recommend!! Very romantic place!

The food at the Red Circle Inn was scintillating. Amanda, our server, and her wait staff were personal and attentive. Then, after our meal, the kind staff gave me a brief tour of the upstairs of the building as I was interested in the history and architecture. The experience was remarkable. I will come again.

Great food, great service, prompt seating. COVID protocol excellent.

If you are looking for a local establishment that offers class, excellent food and friendly service, Red Circle Inn is for you. Please support your local small businesses!

We dine at Red Circle often. It’s one of my top 5 go-to’s in the area. Valentine’s Day was no different. I was not aware of the special menu. But they had some great choices. Just a little disappointed we were put in the back dinning room. I hate that room... it’s like dining in a basement. We arrived at 4:30 so almost all tables were available, but we were told the main dining room already had reservations. Made me feel like our reservation was not as important as someone else. Then my favorite part on Red Circle is the toffee that comes with your bill. They did not serve toffee on Valentine’s Day. Instead they made heart candy that tasted like wax. A special day did not feel very special. Especially with us dinning out has been cut back due to Covid-19 and concerns for my husbands health which is poor.

We loved our dinners, service was good except the hostess forgot about us waiting in the bar after we had reservations. Otherwise a good experience

Absolutely my favorite fine dining restaurant anywhere! Food is always unique and exceptionally good. The atmosphere is classy, cozy and comfortable.

We have never been disappointed with a visit. My wife and I have officially declared the Red Circle Inn as “our place”!

Red Circle Inn has a wonderful supper club feel. The ambiance is quiet, relaxed and cozy. Our service was exceptional, Vicky did a wonderful job being attentive yet not intrusive. All of the food was excellently prepared and high quality; I loved my beef wellington. It's a great place to have a memorable meal and enjoy a quiet, relaxed atmosphere.

I had a wonderful birthday dinner! The food is always amazing!

Great place with excellent service and our meal was fantastic

We dine at The Red Circle Inn every few weeks and love it every time. Amazing staff, delicious food and charming atmosphere!

Unfortunately our experience was not pleasant. It was an hour wait for our meal. The chicken was dry. We than got a complimentary dessert. We got home to eat it and the cake was dry and old. I would have had a better experience at a fast food place.

Food was better than expected, service was great, precautions were taken.

oysters Rockefeller was outstanding
the filet was also top level
never had a bad dinner there
service personnel the best

Excellent service. The whitefish was outstanding as usual. The bluefish special was good, but a bit strong tasting

The food was excellent! Mary Anne was amazing!

Food, service, wine all wonderful. Mary Ann great

I highly recommend the Beef Wellington which is absolutely delicious. The Lemon Soufflé with Raspberry Sauce is also absolutely delicious.

Great ambiance. As a lone diner, it was very welcoming. Food and service exceptional as usual!

The Red Circle Inn is definitely a dining experience for all to enjoy....special occasion, anniversary, etc. The service is outstanding without being obtrusive, but the good service is only overshadowed by the exceptional food. This is a restaurant that I would highly recommend.

Another wonderful experience here.

Always great. Food is fabulous and the service great.

Ambiance, service were outstanding! Food was definitely 5 star, plentiful and absolutely delicious with more than enough on our plate. And of course, the bark to top off an amazing, enjoyable evening. Our server, while we missed Vicki, was outstanding. Thanks for such a great experience!

I have been coming since I was a kid. This was the worst food I have ever eaten there we have had Christmas parties there also. It’s was disappointing. And our guests food was not good either.

We were seated in a back room that had no ambience — really bad, closed-off room! Still a good dinner, but I won’t go back without making sure of good seating!

always excellent. the best of the best people and food

Great service and amazing food.

Fans of Capital Grill, Eddies, Mr.B's or Carnevors or any Bartoletta Resturant will be disappointed here. Mid tiered price and food.

Honestly disappointing. We have been frequent guests at Red Circle over the past three years and generally enjoyed our visits. On this occasion, the entree was served lukewarm at best. The steak was warm, green beans cool, and the potato was so cool, it would not melt butter. To our chagrin, the server never asked us about our meal once served. We left without a dessert and likely will not return.

This is always our place for special occasions as well as just fine dining. My Filet was perfect as was the Grouper special ordered by my wife and one of our guests. The other guest ordered the Wellington which she said was fantastic.

The owner is almost always there insuring that everything is attended to. just a great Independent Restaurant in Lake Country. Wisconsin.

The food was good though a bit over cooked for our taste. I had the duck & my husband had pork. Both sauces were excellent. I had salad & my husband had the clam chowder both again excellent. Our service was not spot on had to wait for my wine flight in fact needed to flag our server down. Both servers felt awful and made up for it with a free coffee & dessert. The carrot cake alone is worth the drive. I’d go back just for another piece. The place was nicely decorated and it had plenty of charm. Tables well spaced for the current pandemic. Over all it’s a special occasion place

Have always enjoyed going to the Red Circle Inn. Everything is always consistent and the food is very good.

Outstanding dinner in all respects. The duck had crispy skin, hot, tender meat with a superior cherry sauce. Tha lemon sole special was moist with a light crab stuffing. Service was attentive without being obtrusive. All our wants were addressed promptly.

Server should have checked on us more often. bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb

Our dinner was very enjoyable. Our waitress was perfect; attentive and warm while not over doing it. Most of the food was exceptional. My only criticism would be the veal shank seemed rather dry and may have been a day or two old. Everything else was spot on. Virus protocols were followed.
We look forward to returning.

Always the best!

Anniversary. Great deserts on the house :)

The food was fantastic!

My wife and I split the rack of lamb. It was excellent! We paid the split charge and each got a salad and vegetables and potatoes and it more than we could eat.

Omar gave us great service period and the drinks were excellent too.

Highly recommended!