Red Circle Inn & Bistro

Everything was great!

A very nice performing restaurant. Promptly seated for our reservation. Service was professional and expertly managed. Menu items were prepared as described perfectly and served hot.

As it has been on past visits, the Red Circle was great. Good and service above the rest.

Mary Ann our server was outstanding.

Every time I have visited Red Circle Inn - the experience has been great. They have the unique ability to attend to you at just the right moments and serve your food and drinks with perfect timing and temperature.

Great setting and a really nice bar area. We ordered 3 dinners in our group, appetizers, several drinks, and desert. I did think it was a little loud in the dining area. Otherwise, everything was great... the only issue was that the pork tenderloin I had was somewhat over-cooked, which I did pass along to the waitress. I did not have them redo it, because we were a little pressed for time, and the garnish and sauce on them was outstanding, so it tasted great all-in-all. Salmon dishes couldn't have been better.

Had the alder planked salmon - delicious, fresh! Served with tasty potatoes and green beans. The old fashioned was best I’ve ever had. Thanks for memorable dinner

We love, love the place. Been going there for a very long time. The food. The service outstanding. This restaurant excels in everything they do.

Service was great with Sissy. Food was fantastic

We had a wonderful evening in an understated elegant atmosphere. Did not expect the Veteran’s Day special event when we booked the reservation but that’s what makes a restaurant like this, a class act.

First time diners. Very impressed. Food was outstanding, portions perfect.

This restaurant never disappoints! If you want a quality meal in a lovely environment, this is your go to place!

The service, menu selections and “extras” make this the restaurant a rare find!

You have to try a soufflé!!! Where else can you get soufflé???

Service really missed the usual quality this evening. We ordered a bottle of wine and asked to have it brought with our entrees. When our entrees arrived, our waitress (Jamie) said she would check on our wine. It finally arrived about 10 minutes later, after we had eaten more than half of our entrees. I told Jamie that she should not open the wine, and we will take it home. She talked to the manager who told her we could not take an unopened bottle out of the restaurant. We had to open it, sample it, and have it re-corked, which we did. Upon completion of our meal, I asked for a box for the rest of my duck entree. When Jamie brought our bill, I asked about my duck. She dashed into the kitchen and told me my duck had been thrown away. She did have the cook prepare another duck for me to take home. This was not a very pleasant dining experience.

Another great meal at the Red Circle Inn. Went with another couple. We all had delicious dinners.

Food was outstanding as always. I had a New York strip, Oscar style, that was perhaps the best steak I have ever had. My dates Beef Wellington was excellent. Service was great.

I love this restaurant! It is by far my favorite place to eat. They have the best carrot cake around! The staff is friendly and the food is always delicious!

As usual we are never disappointed. Everything was wonderful

Great food and very classy. I would recommend do a special occasion or a romantic date. Reasonably priced for the quality of food.

Everything was great- food and service etc all excellent!

The food as always was well made and imaginative. The staff is very friendly.

Norm and his staff did an outstanding job of hosting us for this lovely Saturday night dinner .
Will be back soon.

The presentation was eye appealing & the taste was delicious. Our servers Catherine and Jamie made us feel special. We will definitely be back.

Every thing was excellent! Will be dinning again for our anniversary shortly.

We visit Red Circle at least 2-3 times per year. Always a wonderful meal, great presentation, great service. Has always been very consistent.

Each time, excellent experience. Absolutely wonderful food. Only so so food was souffle, which you either love or nah.

Overall a good experience for a first visit. Initially not super-attentive to keeping our water glasses full, but picked it up after a couple refills. I had the filet mignon and it was expertly prepared and very flavorful. My wife had the chicken ratatouille and it was very good. We split the turtle cake for dessert and it was very disappointing. The cake was dry and tasted like it had been frozen and then thawed and served. The icing was hard and dry. Lastly, and this is more of a pet peeve of mine, the butter was chilled and crumbly. When serving warm bread, you should also serve soft butter - that aside, the bread was delicious. We will definitely return.

We had an enjoyable birthday dinner at the Red Circle. The food, atmosphere, and service were all excellent. The portions were generous but not overwhelming, so just right. We will be there for more special occasions in the future.

This restaurant would have gotten a five star rating, but our table was located right next to the kitchen door and there was a constant in and out and every server had to walk by our table. We wanted something quiet and romantic but all that ruined it for us.

Old and dated decor. Dark, no ambiance and needs a facelift to bring a younger, more vibrant crowd in. Pricey!

Great service, salmon and crab cakes were amazing.

Red Circle Inn equals fine dining in Waukesha county. They offer a very prime, tender, well-prepared filet, and is one of few places that offers that filet prepared ala Wellington. There is also a great osso bucco, duck, and veal picatta.

Great service, very knowledgeable server, delicious food, outstanding venue!

We had a very enjoyable dinner. Everyone was very friendly and professional. The food was outstanding. I would definitely recommend this for a nicer dinner.

Really just a lovely experience. Great vibe! Jeanine the hostess/ server/ manager is the core of energy at the Red Circle Inn. The restaurant is tastefully decorated and the food is delightful. Every time we dine here we say “ why don’t we come here more?” We Look forward to upcoming wine dinners and the chefs thoughtful presentations.

This is so awesome! Treated like royalty. Our favorite place.

Lovely place with historic charm. Three out of four dishes were spectacular. Service was exceptional. Desserts were also to die for!

We ate in the bar area as we love the jazz duo on Tuesday eves. The bar does get crowded and noisy at times. Food is great.

My friend Sarah and I really had a wonderful time, and didn't realize this was the longest standing restaurant in Wisconsin! The food was out-of-this-world, our waitress was attentive, and the atmosphere was beautiful. We've dined now at dozens of places in the last year, in we both agreed this is in our Top 5 of all time!

Food and service was was outstanding as usual! Will be back!

The service was excellent, the baked Brie & Grand Mariner soufflé were outstanding. The duck was hard to pull apart & would have preferred an orange sauce but it tasted good. Beans were very good. Next time we would not have the house salad