W.L. Goodfellows and Co. Inc. - Permanently Closed

Fruit Smoothies

Our Specialty Fruit Smoothies are made from all-natural fruits with no preservatives. Choose a favorite from our list below or make your own creation from our fruit flavors. Blended with ice until creamy, cool and refreshing. Mango, Strawberry, Pina Colada, Banana, Passion Fruit or our Wild Berry blend

• Island Smoothie

  Mango, Passion Fruit, Pineapple and Coconut blended with ice

• Geneva Mocktail

  Strawberries, Bananas and Coconuts blended with ice

• Takes Two To Mango

  Mango and Passion Fruit blended with pineapple juice

• Caribbean Passion

  Passion Fruit, Mango, Wild Berry and Strawberries with juice

• Mango & Coconut Dreams

  Mangos blended with our creamy Pina Colada and fruit juices makes for a refreshing fruit sensation in a glass

• Wild Berry Bliss

  Our Wild Berry Blend of Strawberries, Raspberries, Blackberries and Blueberries blended with ice

• Banana Berry Burst

  Our Wild Berry Blend of Strawberries, Raspberries, Blackberries and Blueberries blended with Bananas and pineapple juice

Frozen Spirits

• Tahitian Teaser™

  A Goodfellows original, Malibu Coconut Rum mixed with tropical fruit to create this refreshing frozen cooler

• Cookie Monster™

  Oreo Cookies chunks blended with Edy's Vanilla Ice Cream and crème de menthe

• Banana Split™

  A blend of bananas, amaretto liqueur and vanilla ice cream. You have to taste it to believe it

• Strawberry Shortcake™

  A blend of amaretto liqueur, Edy's Vanilla Ice Cream and strawberries. Treat yourself

• Tropical Freeze™

  Cruzan Banana Rum and ice blended with Mangos, Passion fruit and Coconuts

• Wild Mango Cream™

  Wild Berries & Mangos with Edy's Vanilla Ice Cream blended with Parrot Bay Coconut Rum

• Monkey Business™

  A Goodfellows original. Edy's Chocolate Ice Cream, blended with fresh bananas crème de cacao and banana liqueur

• Oreo Mudslide

  We blend Carolan's Irish Cream, Kahlua, Vanilla Vodka with Oreo Cookies and Edy's Premium Vanilla Ice Cream

• Orange Dreamsicle™

  Amaretto liqueur, vanilla ice cream and orange juice. Tastes like the ice cream pop!

• Nuts & Berries™

  Frangelico and Carolan's Irish Cream blended with vanilla ice cream and four types of berries. It's berry-licious

• Mango-Mambo™

  Mango and coconut along with vanilla ice cream blended with Captain Morgan Spiced Rum & Stoli Vanil

Daiquiris - Coladas Margaritas

Our selection of delicious frozen Daiquiris, Creamy Coladas and Magnificent Margaritas. All are made with sweet, fresh fruits and blended ice

• Delicious Daiquiri Flavors

  Mango, Strawberry, Wild Berry Blend, Passion Fruit, Strawberry-Banana and Banana

• Creamy Coladas Flavors

  Pina Colada, Mango-Banana, Banana, Melon, Strawberry & Strawberry-Banana

• Frosty, Fruity Margarita Flavors

  Traditional Lime, Tropical Mango, Fruity Strawberry, Frosty Strawberry-Banana and Very Berry Framboise

• Berry Passion Margarita

  Jose Cuervo Tequila blended with creamy passion fruit. Swirled with our Wildberry Blend

• Mango-Rita

  Jose Cuervo Gold Tequila, creamy mangos and ice blended to smooth perfection

Martinis

Our selection of original and popular martinis & classic cocktails. Many of our recipes feature Sobieski Rye Vodka, rated as one of the top five vodkas in the world. Enjoy one of our martini selections with a friend or a perfect stranger

• Apple-Tini

  Sobieski Vodka, Sour Apple Schnapps, lemon and lime juices

• Beach Bum Martini

  Malibu Coconut, Cruzan Banana & Pineapple Rums, pineapple juice

• Black Cherry Blossom

  Sobieski Black Cherry Vodka, Cointreau, fresh squeezed lemon juice

• Chambord Kamikaze

  Sobieski Vodka, Cointreau, Razzamatazz Liqueur, lemon and lime juices

• Chocolate Berry Martini

  Carolan's Irish Cream, Sobieski Raspberry Vodka, white crème de cocoa, Hershey's Syrup drizzle

• Cosmopolitan

  Sobieski Cytron Vodka, Cointreau, lime Juice, and a splash of cranberry juice

• The Creamsicle

  Pinnacle Whipped Cream Vodka, Sobieski Orange Vodka, and cream

• Dark Chocolate Martini

  Godiva Dark Chocolate Liqueur and Sobieski Vanilla Vodka

• Karamel Kiss

  Sobieski Karamel Vodka, Godiva Dark Chocolate Liqueur, and RumChata

• Karamel Kolada

  Sobieski Karamel Vodka, cream of coconut, and pineapple juice

• Key Lime Martini

  Sobieski Vanilia Vodka, Lime Juice, Triple Sec and pineapple juice, sugar rim

• Lemon Chiffon

  Sobieski Lemon Merengue Vodka, Triple Sec, and cream

• Lemon Drop

  Sobieski Cytron Vodka and lemon juice, sugar rim

• Mandrin Sunset

  Sobieski Orange Vodka, Watermelon Schnapps and orange juice

• Melon Patch

  Sobieski Cytron Vodka, Watermelon Pucker Liqueur and Midori Melon Liqueur

• Mint Chocolate Chip Martini

  Bailey's, Green Crème de Menthe, Frangelico Liqueur, cream, Hershey's Syrup drizzle

• Orange Crush Martini

  Sobieski Orange Vodka, Grand Marnier, lemon, lime and a splash of orange juice

• Pomegranate Martini

  Pama Liqueur, Sobieski Cytron Vodka, Fresh lime juice and a splash of cranberry juice

• The Pink Limon

  Bacardi Limon Rum, Cointreau, fresh squeezed lemon juice, cranberry juice, sugar rim

• Raspberry Ganache

  Sobieski Raspberry Vodka, grenadine and cream

• Raspberry Limonata

  Sobieski Raspberry Vodka, Cointreau, fresh squeezed lemon juice, sugar rim

• Raspberry Mochatini

  Sobieski Vodka, 3 Olives Triple Espresso Vodka, and Chambord Liqueur

• Red Apple Saki-Tini

  Sobieski Vodka, Sour Apple Schnapps, Saki, cranberry and lemon juices

• Rootbeer Float

  Art in the Age Organic Root Liqueur, RumChata, and cream

• The Seduction

  Sobieski Orange Vodka, orange and cranberry juices, and a splash of grenadine

• Sobieski Signal

  Sobieski Cytron Vodka, orange and cranberry juice

• Snicker-Tini

  Frangelico Liqueur, Bailey's, Crème de Cacao and cream

• Sunny Days

  Sobieski Orange Vodka, Fresh Squeezed Oranges, Simple Syrup, and a splash of cranberry

• Tutti Frutti Martini

  Italian for All Fruits. Sobieski Orange Vodka, Razzmatazz Liqueur, orange and cranberry juices

• Vanil Martini

  Sobieski Vanilia Vodka and Tuaca Liqueur

• Ward Eight

  Gentlemen Jack, lemon and lime juices, orange juice and grenadine

• Washington Apple

  Crown Royal, Sour Apple Pucker Liqueur and cranberry juice

• White Chocolate Martini

  Sobieski Vodka, Godiva White Chocolate Liqueur

Wing Fest - Wings & Boneless Strips

Plump, Juicy Wings and Jumbo Boneless Chicken Tenders are dredged in our seasoned batter. Fried golden brown then tossed in your choice of our popular wing sauces

• Buf-Fellow Wings*USD 9.95

  Heat Index: 6. Our original hot sauce. Crisp, plump wings are tossed in our most popular sauce and served with bleu cheese dressing and celery

  • Buf-Fellow Strips*USD 10.95

• Memphis Mesquite BBQ Dry-Rub WingsUSD 10.95

  Heat Index: 1. Tossed with our new Memphis-Dust dry rub! This Mesquite BBQ is a whole lotta good

  • Memphis BBQ StripsUSD 10.95

• Koji Korean WingsUSD 10.95

  Heat Index: 5. Authentic flavors of east meets west with our spicy Korean BBQ Sauce! Have your wings drenched with this delicious creation!

  • Koji Korean StripsUSD 10.95

• Honey BBQ WingsUSD 10.95

  Heat Index: 3. A little spice, a little sweet and a whole lotta' BBQ

  • Honey BBQ StripsUSD 10.95

• Grim Reaper WingsUSD 10.95

  Heat Index: 10+ Extremely hot! Served with Bleu Cheese and celery

  • Grim Reaper StripsUSD 10.95

• Garlic Dijon WingsUSD 10.95

  Heat index: 4. Dijon mustard and sweet honey along with unique seasonings. Tossed with fresh crushed garlic. Deliciously additive!

  • Garlic Dijon StripsUSD 10.95

• Italian Parmesan WingsUSD 9.95

  Heat Index: 1. A blend of 12 Italian herbs and seasonings. Generously dusted with parmesan cheese. Served with homemade marinara

  • Italian Parmesan StripsUSD 10.95

Specialty Wings

• Mango Habanero WingsUSD 11.95

  Heat Index: 9. Ripe mangos for some sweet and hot and spicy habanero peppers to bring on the heat! We call it our Sweet Heat!

  • Mango Habanero StripsUSD 11.95

• Hawaiian Heat WingsUSD 11.95

  Heat Index: 4. Caramelized pineapple, fresh papaya and kiwi. Blended with the right mount of Chili Peppers to kick up the heat

  • Hawaiian Heat StripsUSD 11.95

• Sweet Thai Chili WingsUSD 11.95

  Heat Index: 7. Made with fresh Thai Chilis to create an Asian crafted sauce that's spicy and sweet and distinctly Goodfellows

  • Sweet Thai Chili StripsUSD 11.95

Happy - Tizers

Mozzarella Fresca: Bruschetta tossed with a diced fresh mozzarella ball. "Molto Buono". $4 extra

• Classic French Onion Soup CrockUSD 5.95

  Fresh made from scratch. Large cut sweet white onions simmered in our rich beef broth until tender. Topped with a toasted French Bread wafer covered with a thick blanket of provolone cheese and baked until bubbly. Finished with crispy onion frizzles

• Lobster & Crab Bisque

  Whole Maine lobsters are simmered for hours for our full-bodied stock. Fresh cream, brandy and herbs are added with a generous amount of sweet lobster & crabmeat to make every spoonful of our exceptional bisque delicious!

  • CupUSD 6.95
  • BowlUSD 9.95
  • Take Home A QuartUSD 24.95

• Soup of the Day

  Made from scratch using the freshest ingredients. Fresh Is Best!

  • CupUSD 3.95
  • BowlUSD 4.95

• House-Made Mozzarella Planks*USD 9.95

  A signature best-seller! Made with whole milk mozzarella cheese. Each of our thick, wide mozzarella planks are hand-cut, then hand-coated with our seasoned Italian bread crumbs. Deep fried and served with marinara sauce

• Fresh Baked Pretzel SticksUSD 8.95

  Thick, jumbo baked Bavarian pretzel sticks served with our white cheddar jalapeno cheese sauce and honey dijon for dipping

• Fried Button Mushrooms*USD 6.95

  Perfectly coated in Italian bread crumbs then deep fried golden brown. Served with marinara sauce and shaved parmesan

• Nacho MadnessUSD 10.95

  The ultimate nachos! Fried crispy warm tortilla chips layered with spiced beef, refried beans and cheddar cheese sauce. Topped with a mound of shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, green onions, black olives and homemade pickled jalapeno slices. Served with sour cream and salsa for your dipping frenzy

• Lobster Mac N' CheeseUSD 15.95

  Not your ordinary Macaroni and Cheese! We start with pulled sweet Maine lobster meat tossed in our rich blend of Gruyere and Wisconsin Cheddar Cheeses. Baked Au Gratin with a light coating of our parmesan-panko seasoned crumbs

• Crispy Thai ShrimpUSD 12.95

  Large, tender gulf shrimp dredged in seasoned batter and lightly deep fried. Tossed in our spicy Asian remoulade sauce spiked with a blast of our Rajun Cajun seasoning

• Spinach & Artichoke Pita Dip-Arita*USD 11.95

  You'll always find the extraordinary at Goodfellows. This creamy blend of spinach, artichoke hearts, parmesan cheese and seasonings is served warm with toasted pita chips covered with diced plum tomatoes, scallions and melted jack & cheddar cheese. Enough for two

• Bruschetta RomaUSD 10.95

  A mound of diced plum tomatoes, red onion, roasted red peppers and garlic tossed with olive oil, seasonings and a dusting of shaved parmesan cheese. Served with toasted french bread

• Clams CasinoUSD 10.95

  "The Best We've Ever Had"! What our guests tell us after enjoying this popular "classic". Green peppers, pimentos, butter, garlic, bacon and spices make this a Goodfellows favorite

• Steamed ClamsUSD 10.95

  Steamers, as we call them along the Jersey Shore, are always popular favorite. We serve a dozen fresh, locally caught top neck clams steamed and served in their own broth with fresh lemon wedge and drawn butter

• Cheddar & Bacon Idaho Skins*USD 9.95

  Baked Idaho potatoes are hand-scooped into thin skins then fried lightly. Filled with melted cheddar and jack cheeses and topped with thick strips of real bacon. Served with sour cream

• Calamari FrittiUSD 11.95

  Thick, hand cut squid rings and tentacles dredged in our seasoned tempura batter then lightly deep fried until tender. Served with marinara sauce

• Mushrooms Fromage'USD 9.95

  Fresh mushroom caps stuffed with creamy, herb seasoned cheese. Topped with a sprinkle of panko-parmesan crumbs and drizzled with garlic butter and shredded gruyere cheese then oven baked

• Stuffed Deviled ClamsUSD 7.95

  Fresh local clams, steamed in seasoned broth. Diced and mixed with a mirepoix of fresh sauté vegetables and seasonings. Stuffed back into their natural shells. Lightly breaded then fried. Served with our own tartar sauce and lemon

• Goodfellows SamplerUSD 15.95

  A sampling of our most popular appetizers, including Our Original House-Made Mozzarella Planks®, Hand-Scooped Cheddar & Bacon Potato Skins,Our Original Buf-fellow Wings and Chicken Fingers. Served with selected sauces for dippin'

• Fried Ravioli*USD 8.95

  Large homemade cheese ravioli lightly hand-breaded in our Parmesan panko bread crumbs. Fried until golden brown & crispy. Served with our marinara sauce for dippin'

• EdamameUSD 7.95

  Tender green baby soy bean pods sautéed in sesame oil, garlic and seasonings. A great choice for those seeking to enjoy a high fiber, high protein snack

• Chicken Fingers*USD 8.95

  Our boneless chicken tenders are lightly breaded, deep fried and served with our honey-dijon dipping sauce. Add Fries or Onion Rings for an extra charge

• Crab Rangoon Spring RollsUSD 9.95

  Thin, crispy spring rolls are hand-stuffed with our unique blend of cream cheese, crabmeat, green onions and seasonings then lightly fried. Served with our Sweet & Spicy Thai Chili Dipping Sauce

• Grilled Chicken Nachos GrandeUSD 10.95

  Crisp, warm rainbow tortilla chips topped with diced tomatoes, sliced green onions, black olives and diced chunks of marinated, grilled chicken breast. Topped with a layer of melted monterey jack and cheddar cheeses. Served with salsa and sour cream

• Soup & SaladUSD 8.95

  A Cup of our house-made Soup of the Day coupled with a crisp side salad made with California iceberg and romaine greens, sliced plum tomato, sliced cucumber and garlic toasted croutons

Make It Better - Extra

• Make it a Side Caesar InsteadUSD 1.00

• French Onion Soup InsteadUSD 1.00

• Lobster and Crab Bisque InsteadUSD 3.00

Hand - Tossed Pizza

Our Extraordinary Italian Crust, San Marzano Tomatoes, the finest cheeses and imported ingredients are in every Goodfellows' Pizza. It's a tradition our Great Grandmother started years ago of preparing food with love and care

• Classic Cheese Pizza

  Topped with our plum tomato sauce and special blend of mozzarella cheese

  • SmallUSD 9.95
  • LargeUSD 13.95
  • X-Thin SmallUSD 11.95
  • X-Thin LargeUSD 15.95

• Classic White Pizza

  Fresh crushed garlic, olive oil, ricotta and mozzarella cheese

  • SmallUSD 11.95
  • LargeUSD 15.95
  • X-Thin SmallUSD 13.95
  • X-Thin LargeUSD 17.95

• Nonna's Margherita Pizza

  Our Great-Grandmom's favorite. Fresh mozzarella and our San Marzano tomato sauce with a chiffonade of fresh basil leaves

  • SmallUSD 11.95
  • LargeUSD 16.95
  • X-Thin SmallUSD 13.95
  • X-Thin LargeUSD 18.95

• Sausage Fresco Pizza

  Not your ordinary sausage pizza! Our plum tomato sauce and special blend of mozzarella cheese topped with fresh, locally made mild Italian sausage chunks placed generously over this pie

  • SmallUSD 12.95
  • LargeUSD 16.95
  • X-Thin SmallUSD 14.95
  • X-Thin LargeUSD 18.95

• Trenton Tomato Pie

  This backwards pizza is made crust first, then cheese and lots of our San Marzano Sauce on top

  • SmallUSD 10.95
  • LargeUSD 15.95
  • X-Thin SmallUSD 12.95
  • X-Thin LargeUSD 17.95

Calzones & Strombolis

• Loaded CalzoneUSD 13.95

  Stuffed with lots of pepperoni, meatballs, spicy Italian ham, mushrooms, ricotta and mozzarella cheeses. Served with tomato sauce for dunkin'

• Steak StromboliUSD 11.95

  Stuffed with thin slices of grilled chip steak, fried onions and lots of shredded mozzarella cheese. With a side of tomato sauce

• Pepperoni StromboliUSD 10.95

  We got your pepperoni and plenty of it! Slices and slices and slices of pepperoni encased in our fresh baked dough with mozzarella cheese. Served with tomato sauce

Pizza Toppings

• Mozzarella CheeseUSD 2.00

• Fresh Mozzarella CheeseUSD 4.00

• PepperoniUSD 2.00

• MushroomsUSD 2.00

• Green PeppersUSD 2.00

• Black OlivesUSD 2.00

• BroccoliUSD 2.00

• SpinachUSD 3.00

• OnionsUSD 2.00

• Diced TomatoesUSD 2.00

• Jalapeno PepperUSD 2.00

• Roasted Red PeppersUSD 3.00

• Ricotta CheeseUSD 3.00

• Sweet Italian SausageUSD 3.00

• MeatballsUSD 3.00

• BasilUSD 2.00

• ChickenUSD 4.00

• Real BaconUSD 4.00

• Spicy Capicolla HamUSD 3.00

Hand-Crafted Burgers

With Our House Brined Garlic-dill Pickles. We've been crafting great burgers for over 31 years using a blend of fresh ground sirloin steak cuts. Fire-Broiled and served on a toasted Artisan Brioche Roll. Served with a choice of house-made macaroni salad, coleslaw or French Fries or substitute for a choice below. Seasoned Fries $1.59, Sweet Potato Fries $1.79, Thick-Cut Onion Rings $1.99. Add Ons: Applewood Smoked Bacon $1.50, Side Salad $2.99, Side Caesar $3.29

• Goodfellow BurgerUSD 11.95

  Our all-time, most popular and famous burger is seared over an open flame. Topped with aged melted cheddar cheese and strips of thick-sliced Applewood Smoked Bacon

• Havarti Bourbon Bacon Jam BurgerUSD 13.95

  We turn sweet molasses bacon into our savory bacon jam spiked with bourbon. Finished with melted Havarti cheese, caramelized onions and Horseradish aioli

• Pepper-Jack Avocado Stack BurgerUSD 13.95

  A thick sirloin burger stacked with sliced Pepper Jack Cheese, smoked Applewood Smoked Bacon, fresh avocado slices tomato and a ring of sliced red onion

• Black N' Bluez BurgerUSD 13.95

  Double-coated with our fantastic Rajun-Cajun' seasoning. This BBB is flame-seared then topped generously with slightly Melted Gorgonzola Bleu Cheese along with strips of Applewood Smoked Bacon

• Jersey Sunshine BurgerUSD 13.95

  Our fresh ground sirloin burger topped with a slice of grilled Taylor Pork Roll and melted aged cheddar cheese. Finished with an over-easy farm fresh fried egg. Served on a bakery fresh toasted Brioche Roll

• American Cheese BurgerUSD 10.95

  This great classic burger favorite represents the heart and soul of America. Topped with melted American cheese. Green leaf lettuce and sliced tomato upon request. Add Applewood Smoked Bacon for a little extra!

• Turkey BurgerUSD 10.95

  Lean ground turkey flame-grilled and topped with sautéed onions and melted aged cheddar cheese

• Rajun Cajun BurgerUSD 11.95

  Coated with our spicy famous Rajun' Cajun' seasoning and flame broiled. Topped with sautéed onions and melted aged provolone cheese

Signature Salads

Goodfellows entrée salads are all natural. All our salads start with cool, crisp salad greens and fresh garden vegetables. Our specialty dressings are freshly prepared making Goodfellows salads unique

• Chop House SaladUSD 15.95

  Goodfellows Signature Salad and our best-seller starts with a mixture of freshly chopped fork-ready ingredients including crisp romaine lettuce, spicy grilled cajun chicken, red onion, red bell pepper, plum tomatoes, crisp golden delicious apples, yellow corn, gorgonzola cheese, bacon, hard-boiled egg and walnuts, tossed in our special House-made Chop House Balsamic Vinaigrette

• Krunchy Oriental Chicken SaladUSD 12.95

  Fresh romaine greens with mandarin orange pieces, sweet bell pepper slices, slices of fresh plum tomatoes, shredded jack and cheddar cheeses and crispy Chinese noodles. Topped with our battered and crispy fried chicken breast slices and our Asian Sesame Dressing

• Caribbean Fiesta SaladUSD 12.95

  Ribbon sliced romaine and iceberg lettuces, avocado, black beans, yellow corn, diced plum tomatoes and red onion with a sprinkling of shredded cheddar cheese. Dressed in our Cilantro-Lime Vinaigrette, topped with carved slices of marinated grilled chicken and cracked red tortillas

• Mango-Citrus Salad with Pears & AlmondsUSD 13.95

  Mixed baby lettuce greens tossed in our Mango-Citrus Vinaigrette with crumbled gorgonzola cheese, sliced almonds, pears, tomato, diced bacon, sun-dried cranberries and caramelized balsamic red onions

• Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato SaladUSD 12.95

  Chunks of fresh mozzarella cheese, sweet salad peppers, red onion, cucumbers, black olives, plum tomatoes and pepperoncini on a bed of romaine and iceberg lettuces. Tossed in our house made Vinaigrette

• The Iceberg WedgeUSD 8.95

  A cool, crisp wedge of iceberg covered with our chunky bleu cheese dressing, diced plum tomatoes, thick sliced red onions and fresh cooked bacon bits

• Buf-Fellow Chicken Tortilla SaladUSD 12.95

  Boneless chicken strips in our seasoned batter, lightly fried and tossed in our wing sauce. Served over crisp iceberg greens with jack and cheddar cheeses, smoked bacon and red onions in a Grande Tortilla Bowl. Topped with crumbled bleu cheese and drizzled with our Sriracha Ranch Dressing. Served with ranch dressing

Caesar Salad

We use fresh California Romaine,tossed with our creamy Caesar dressing, toasted croutons and shaved parmesan cheese. Salad Dressings: Buttermilk Ranch, Vinegar & Oil, Chunky Blue Cheese, Thousand Island, Creamy Italian, Asian Sesame, Honey Dijon or Balsamic Vinaigrette

• Goodfellows CaesarUSD 9.95

  Just the Caesar please. Fresh Romaine tossed with our creamy Caesar dressing. Topped with toasted croutons and parmesan cheese

• Chicken CaesarUSD 12.95

  Our most popular super-sized Caesar with grilled, carved chicken breast

• Black N' Bleu Steak CaesarUSD 16.95

  Marinated angus sirloin steak coated in Rajun' Cajun seasoning then grilled over an open flame. Thinly carved and served atop our classic Caesar salad with fresh bacon and gorgonzolacheese

Sandwiches

At Goodfellows we're known for great sandwiches. All of our sandwiches and wraps are served with our house-brined garlic-dill pickle and a choice of our house-made macaroni salad, coleslaw or french fries or substitute for a choice below. Seasoned Fries $1.59, Sweet Potato Fries $1.79, Onion Rings $1.99. Add Ons: Applewood Smoked Bacon $1.50, Side Salad $2.99, Side Caesar $3.29

• Roasted Ribeye GrilleUSD 15.95

  Ribbons of carved slow roasted Ribeye seared with caramelized red onions and bell peppers. Stacked on warm crusty French bread. Topped with slices of melted Havarti Cheese and our creamy Horseradish Aioli

• Grilled Eggplant Flatbread SandwichUSD 11.95

  Warmed organic flatbread with lightly seasoned grilled eggplant stacked over house-made pesto and fresh arugula greens. Topped with melted fontina cheese, ripe tomato slices, red onion and a drizzle of balsamic vinaigrette

• Roast Turkey B.L.T. StackerUSD 12.50

  Locally baked, buttery Artisan Brioche Loaf is hand-sliced thick then stacked with and a generous layer of crisp applewood smoked bacon slices, thick carved turkey breast, fresh green leaf lettuce and sliced ripe tomato

• Pulled Pork B.B.QUSD 11.95

  Dry rubbed, slow-roasted, hand-pulled pork dripping with our homemade tangy sweet Carolina BBQ sauce. Piled on a fresh baked crusty loaf. Now that's some good eatin'!

• Crabcake SandwichUSD 13.95

  One of our original lump crab meat cakes broiled and served on a toasted brioche roll with green leaf, sliced tomato and house-made tarter sauce

• Crispy Chicken ClubUSD 12.95

  We start with our parmesan crusted chicken breast, topped with melted American cheese and smoked Applewood bacon slices. Stacked on fresh baked French loaf with lettuce and tomato

• California-Cajun ChickenUSD 11.95

  Flame broiled chicken breast seared with our Rajun-Cajun Seasoning. Topped with melted pepper-jack cheese, fresh sliced Avocado and tomato served on toasted ciabatta bread with habanero aioli

• Oven Toasted Meatball Parmesan MeltUSD 11.95

  Our large, house-made meatballs stuffed into a fresh baked Italian loaf. Topped with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Oven baked to a melted, toasty deliciousness

• French DipUSD 12.95

  Slow roasted choice top rounds, carved thin and warmed in our beef au jus. Piled on fresh crusty French loaf. Served with warm au jus for dippin'

• Authentic Cuban GrilleUSD 12.95

  Grilled and hot pressed until it's crisp and delicious! We take Cuban style bread slathered with yellow mustard, imported Swiss cheese, diced dill pickles, thinly sliced pork roast and cured ham

• Parmesan Crusted Chicken MeltUSD 11.95

  Boneless chicken breast coated with Italian seasoned parmesan bread crumbs. Lightly deep fried then topped with a layer of melted provolone cheese and marinara sauce on our toasted, artisan ciabatta bread

• Philly Cheese SteakUSD 11.95

  Thin, flat sliced grilled sirloin steak goes into our Philly Cheesesteak with fried onions and melted provolone cheese on a fresh baked loaf

• Grilled ReubenUSD 10.95

  Lean Corned Beef lightly grilled then stacked between grilled slices of locally baked, butter grilled Jewish rye bread with Russian Dressing, Imported Swiss cheese and fresh sauerkraut

Wraps

• Wrap & Salad or Wrap & SoupUSD 9.95

  Half of our Turkey Bacon Wrap with a cool crisp Side Salad or a cup of our house-made Soup du Jour. Wrap served with no side choice

• Turkey Bacon WrapUSD 10.95

  Fresh roasted turkey, crisp bacon, tomato and shredded lettuce. Rolled in a large tomato wrap and drizzled with our Habanero Ranch Dressing

• Buf-Fellow Chicken WrapUSD 10.95

  Boneless Buf-fellow strips stuffed in a large wrap with shredded lettuce, jack and cheddar cheeses and tomatoes. Drizzled with our Habanero Ranch Dressing

• Texas Cheesesteak WrapUSD 11.95

  hin sliced sirloin, smoked bacon strips, American Cheese, shredded lettuce and sliced tomato go into our Texas Cheese Steak Wrap. Served on a fresh sun-dried tomato wrap

Little-Fellows

Served to children under 10 only

• Hot DogUSD 4.50

  A grilled all-beef frank served on a grilled hot dog bun with french fries and a pickle

• Pasta & MeatballUSD 5.95

  Choose from penne or angel hair pasta with tomato sauce

• Chicken FingersUSD 6.95

  Boneless chicken tenders breaded and deep fried. Served with fries and pickle

• RavioliUSD 5.95

  Large cheese filled square ravioli with tomato sauce

• Lil' PizzaUSD 5.95

  A small pizza cut into six mini kid-size slices. Choice of cheese or pepperoni pizza

• HamburgerUSD 5.95

  A small sirloin burger on a soft burger roll with french fries and pickle

• Grilled CheeseUSD 4.95

  American cheese on grilled Texas bread with fries and a pickle

• Kiddie Ice CreamUSD 2.95

  A scoop of vanilla or chocolate

Kids Beverage Choices

No free refills on milk and juice choices. $2 each

• Fountain Soda

• Milk

• Chocolate Milk and Fruit

• Juices

Fajitas & Stir-Frys

All our fajitas are served with salsa, sour cream, cheddar and jack cheese, diced tomatoes, green onions, shredded lettuce and warm flour tortillas. Guacamole dressing. $1 extra

• Nacho MadnessUSD 10.95

  The ultimate nacho plate! Fried crispy warm tortilla chips layered with spiced beef, refried beans. Topped with a mound of shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, green onions, black olives, sliced jalapeno peppers and cheddar cheese sauce. Served with sour cream and salsa for your dipping frenzy

• QuesadillaUSD 9.95

  Two large flour tortillas individually stuffed with Jack and cheddar cheeses, green onions and diced plum tomatoes. Sliced into wedges and served with Goodfellows house rice and salsa

• Taco ConstructionUSD 12.95

  No special tools required to build these tacos. We give you all the stuff you'll need. We start with warm soft flour tortillas. Served with spiced beef, jack and cheddar cheeses, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes and green onions. Served with salsa

Sizzling Fajitas

We serve our Fajitas sizzling in a hot skillet with everything you need to build great fajitas!

• Chicken FajitasUSD 16.95

  Marinated,boneless strips of chicken grilled with red and green bell peppers and red onions

• Beef FajitasUSD 19.95

  Seasoned, marinated angus sirloin steak char-grilled with red and green bell peppers and red onions

• The Combo FajitasUSD 18.95

  A sizzling combination of chicken and beef with grilled red onions, red and green bell peppers

Asian Stir-Frys

Our Asian Stir-Frys are made with authentic ingredients tossed in our authentic house-made stir-fry sauce then served on a bed of Goodfellows yellow rice

• Chicken CashewUSD 18.95

  Great for the calorie conscious is our boneless chicken breast stirred up with broccoli, carrots, mushrooms, red peppers, zucchini and cashew nuts in our special stir-fry sauce

• Shrimp & BroccoliUSD 21.95

  We've made this dish as famous as the Far East itself. It's a medley of shrimp, broccoli florets, carrots, red peppers, zucchini and fresh mushrooms in our now world-famous stir-fry sauce

French Fried Lobster Tails

A Jersey Shore tradition we started back in 1964 at Chick's Restaurant, also known as "The Home of the French Fried Lobster Tails", located on the beach in Brigantine, NJ. We still prepare these cold water delicacies exactly the way our Founder and Father did!

• Twin French Fried Lobster Tails "Our Original Recipe Since 1964"USD 34.95

  These cold water lobster tails are freshly breaded in our secret seasoned bread crumbs. But first, we split them open and piggy back the succulent meat over the shell before we deep fry them. Our twin lobster tails are served with french fries and cole slaw, lemon wedge and drawn butter

• French Fried Lobster Tail & Shrimp ComboUSD 28.95

  We use our tender lobster tail and large shrimp. Both lightly breaded and deep fried until golden brown. Served with french fries and cole slaw, lemon wedge and drawn butter and cocktail sauce

• Jumbo Fried ShrimpUSD 18.95

  Jumbo gulf shrimp, butterfly cut, breaded and deep fried to a golden brown. Served with french fries and cole slaw, lemon wedge and cocktail sauce

Seafood Specialties

Most selections are served with a choice of two sides where noted

• Maryland Lump Crab CakesUSD 28.95

  At Goodfellows we load our crab cakes with lump crabmeat. Mix them with diced onions & bell peppers and a selection of seasonings and herbs to create these rich crab lover's favorite. Served with your choice of two sides, lemon wedge and tartar sauce

• Shrimp & Asparagus SummerstyleUSD 23.95

  One of our most popular signature dishes. Tender shrimp sautéed with asparagus in our summer style sauce of butter, garlic, diced plum tomatoes, scallions, mushrooms, bacon and spices. Finished with a shaving of parmesan cheese and dished over a bed of our house pasta

• Cajun Salmon SummerstyleUSD 18.95

  Coated in our Cajun spices then grilled. Topped with a sauté of fresh asparagus, zucchini, mushrooms and plum tomatoes in our five herb seasoned butter. Served with your choice of a side

• Sesame Crusted Ahi TunaUSD 21.95

  The best Yellow Fin Tuna you'll ever eat. Our Ahi Steak are sliced from sushi graded tuna loin. Prized for its crimson red color and exceptional flavor. Coated with sesame seeds and seared rare or well only. Served on an island of seasoned wilted garlic spinach greens with roasted garlic mashed potatoes

• Blackened Cajun Ahi TunaUSD 21.95

  Our sushi tuna is dredged in our Rajun Cajun seasoned and blackened in a hot skillet. Seared rare or well only. Served on an island of seasoned wilted garlic spinach greens with roasted garlic mashed potatoes

Fire Broiled Steaks

Goodfellows Fire Broiled Steaks, Ribs, Chicken and Chops are served with a choice of two sides

Goodfellows Featured Steak

• New York Strip SteakUSD 23.95

  We hand-cut each of these 12 ounce USDA Choice NY Strip Steaks. Grilled over an open flame to sear in the flavor

• Hand-Cut Grilled Rib Eye SteakUSD 31.95

  This tender and juicy steak is hand cut and trimmed. The marbling loads it with lots of flavor. Flame grilled, the best way to enjoy a great steak like this

• Angus Sirloin SteakUSD 17.95

  An 8 ounce cut of lean, certified Black Angus sirloin. Flame broiled locks in the juices

• Rajun' Cajun Grilled Rib Eye SteakUSD 31.95

  A Goodfellows Original. We take our Rib Eye, dredge it in our spicy Rajun' Cajun' seasoning and sear in the goodness

• Mignon Cut SirloinUSD 13.95

  A 5 ounce mignon cut sirloin. Flame broiled and served with two sides

Chicken - Ribs - Chops

• B.B.Q. Baby Back RibsUSD 24.95

  Basted in our own honey-glazed barbecue sauce, slow cooked until oh so tender and finger lickin' good. Finished with a basting of our Carolina BBQ Sauce

• 1/2 Rack Baby Back RibsUSD 18.95

• Chicken & BBQ RibsUSD 22.95

  A boneless chicken breast joined with a 1/2 rack of our slow-cooked baby back ribs in our honey-glazed barbecue sauce

• Grilled Pork ChopsUSD 18.95

  Twin 8ounce center cut boneless pork chops grilled over an open flame

• Cajun Pork ChopsUSD 18.95

  Twin 8 ounce center cut boneless pork chops coated with our Rajun' Cajun' seasoning and grilled over an open flame

• Roasted ChickenUSD 18.95

  Our Bone-in 1/2 of herb-seasoned chicken with breast, thigh and leg is slow roasted until tender, juicy & full of flavor

• Cajun' Roasted ChickenUSD 18.95

  Our Coated with our Rajun' Cajun Seasoning

Dinner Entrée

House Dinner Salad- $2.99 extra, House Caesar as a side- $3.29 extra. Side Choices: Choose Any two

• Steamed Broccoli

• French Fries

• House-Made Macaroni Salad

• Cole Slaw

• Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes

• Yellow House Rice

• Baked Potato

Add-On To any Dinner

One of Our Famous French

• Fried Lobster TailsUSD 12.95

  Served with lemon wedge & drawn butter

• Sautéed MushroomsUSD 3.95

  With Any Steak. Sautéed in butter

• Maryland CrabcakeUSD 9.95

  With lemon wedge & tartar sauce

Italian & Pasta

Made Fresh! We take great pride when preparing all of our Italian Specialties. Goodfellows Italian Sauces are made using only the finest and freshest ingredients available. Our delicious house-made and hand-rolled Italian meatballs. Add an order to any Italian or Pasta Selection $5 extra. House Dinner Salad $2 extra, House Caesar $3 extra. Pasta Choices: Penne, Angel Hair, Pappardelle $2 extra, Gnocchi $3 extra

• Baked LasagnaUSD 15.95

  Made from scratch, our lasagna is layer upon layer of wide ribbon noodles, creamy ricotta cheese, mozzarella cheese, seasoned sirloin, fresh herbs, spices and marinara sauce. A hearty portion served bubbly hot from our oven

• Shrimp ScampiUSD 17.95

  Tender gulf shrimp sautéed in our creamy mixture of butter, garlic, herbs, and fresh grated parmesan. Served on a bed of pasta or house rice

• Cajun' PastaUSD 16.95

  Penne pasta tossed with our Rajun'Cajun Seasoning, sweet roasted red peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh spinach, diced plum tomatoes, herbs andbutter

• Shrimp Pesto ParmigianoUSD 22.95

  Large gulf shrimp quickly sautéed then tossed in our Basil Pesto with cream, parmesan cheese and Italian Spices. Served over penne pasta

• Lobster RavioliUSD 22.95

  Whole milk ricotta cheese, minced lobster meat, Italian spices and seasonings stuffed into half-moon shaped tomato pasta pillows. Finished with our creamy Vodka Rosa sauce

• Chicken ParmigianaUSD 17.95

  Boneless chicken breasts coated in our crusty parmesan crumbs seasoned with a selection of Italian herbs and pan sautéed until tender. Finished with a layer of marinara sauce and cheese. Served with your pasta choice

• Gnocchi-Shrimp ScampiUSD 23.95

  Italian potato dumplings, large gulf shrimp, fresh plum tomatoes, spinach, roasted red peppers and seasonings. Tossed together in our creamy garlic butter sauce, dusted with shaved parmesan cheese

• Seafood Italiano'USD 27.95

  This collage of seafood includes tender lobster meat, chopped shucked clams and gulf shrimp sautéed in butter, herbs and garlic then simmered in our marinara sauce and served over a bed of pasta

• Chicken & Broccoli AlfredoUSD 17.95

  Fresh boneless chicken tenders sautéed with broccoli florets then tossed with house pasta in our made-to-order creamy parmesan Alfredo sauce

• Gluten-Free RavioliUSD 17.95

  These gluten-free pasta pockets are full of fresh ricotta cheese and Italian spices. Topped with our homemade marinara sauce

• Three Cheese Baked PenneUSD 15.95

  Penne pasta tossed with ricotta cheese, our San Marzano tomato sauce and Italian seasonings. Topped with a layer of three cheeses then baked en casserole

• Bolognese PappardelleUSD 17.95

  Originated in Bologna, Italy our hearty version of this classic meat sauce is made with fresh ground sirloin and lean pork, San Marzano Tomatoes and Italian Spices. Tossed with our fresh made Pappardelle Pasta. Finished with shaved parmesan

Classic Italian

Enjoy our freshly prepared Italian Classics. All selections are made-to-order

• Gnocchi Au GratinUSD 15.95

  Italian potato dumplings quickly sautéed with fresh minced garlic, cream and Italian herbs. Finished with a dusting of parmesan panko crumbs. Topped with a blend of three cheeses and baked en casserole

• Homemade RavioliUSD 15.95

  These Grande' pasta pillows are stuffed with a mixture of fresh ricotta cheese and Spices then topped with our homemade San Marzano sauce

• Baked MeatballsUSD 14.95

  A trio of our hand-rolled meatballs baked en casserole with our 3 cheese blend, marinara sauce and a dollop of seasoned ricotta cheese. Served with a side Caesar Salad and fresh baked bread

• Clams & Angel HairUSD 17.95

  Red or white! Tender chopped clams, butter, garlic, olive oil and a pinch of fresh Italian parsley

• Penne AlfredoUSD 15.95

  A hearty portion of penne pasta tossed in our creamy Alfredo sauce of fresh cream, butter and parmesan cheese

• Homemade Meatballs & PastaUSD 17.95

  Our jumbo, hand-rolled meatballs are so delicious they deserve first billing! These traditional favorites are made with fresh ground sirloin, veal, Romano cheese and spices. Simmered in sauce to soak up all that Italian goodness. Served with your pasta choice. Finished with our San Marzano Tomato Sauce

Cold & Bottled Beverages

• Perrier Water

  • SmallUSD 2.95

• San Pellegrino - Sparkling Water

  • SmallUSD 3.95
  • LargeUSD 6.95

• Panna Mineral Water

  • SmallUSD 3.95
  • LargeUSD 6.95

• San Pellegrino - Aranciata Sparkling OrangeUSD 2.75

• San Pellegrino - Limonata Sparkling LemonUSD 2.75

• Creamy MilkshakesUSD 5.95

  Vanilla, Banana, Chocolate, Strawberry, Wild Berry and Mango

• Arnold Palmer

  A blend of Iced Tea and Lemonade served Chilled

  • 16 OunceUSD 2.25
  • 23 OunceUSD 3.25
  • RegularUSD 2.25
  • LargeUSD 3.50

• Fruit Juices

  Chilled orange, pineapple or cranberry

  • SmallUSD 3.25
  • LargeUSD 4.25

• Tomato JuiceUSD 2.75

• Raspberry Iced Tea

  Unsweetened. With fresh fruit Puree. Served ice chilled

  • 16 OunceUSD 2.25
  • 23 OunceUSD 3.50

• Fresh Brewed Iced Tea

  Unsweetened served ice chilled. Fountain Sodas and Plain Iced Tea include 2 free refills when purchasing a meal

  • SmallUSD 2.95
  • Mason JarUSD 3.95

• Fountain Soda

  Coke, Diet Coke, Barq's Root Beer, Sprite, Dr. Pepper, Ginger Ale and Seltzer. Fountain Sodas and Plain Iced Tea include 2 free refills when purchasing a meal

  • 16 OunceUSD 2.95
  • 23 OunceUSD 4.50

• Juicy Juice Bottled JuiceUSD 2.50

  Apple or Fruit Punch

• Milk or Chocolate Milk

  We use real Hershey's syrup

  • 16 OunceUSD 2.95

• Homemade Lemonade

  "Pucker-up Baby"...It's real lemony sweetness

  • 16 OunceUSD 2.50
  • 23 OunceUSD 3.75

• Raspberry Lemonade

  Made with fresh fruit Puree

  • 16 OunceUSD 2.75
  • 23 OunceUSD 3.75

Pitcher of Fountain Soda

All Flavors $7.95; Regular or Diet $2.75

• Stewart's Original

• Bottled Rootbeer

Boylans Bottling Co.

Since 1891 Pure Cane Sugar; All Flavors $3.25

• Creme

• Black Cherry

• Grape

Hot Beverages

• TeaUSD 2.75

  Lipton's tender little leaves. Hot Coffee and Tea include 2 free refills when purchasing a meal

• Fresh CoffeeUSD 2.75

  Regular or decaf. Hot Coffee and Tea include 2 free refills when purchasing a meal

• Hot ChocolateUSD 2.95

  Creamy rich cocoa, perfect on a chilly day

• White Chocolate Caramel CappuccinoUSD 2.95

  Enjoy the flavor of delicate white chocolate and rich caramel

• Pumpkin Spice CappuccinoUSD 2.95

  Seasonal pumpkin flavor spiked with cinnamon and spices

Mojitos

All of our Mojitos are made with fresh mint and freshly squeezed limes

• Magnifico Mojito

  Flor de Cana 12 Year Slow-Aged Centenario Reserve Rum, mint leaves, sugar, fresh squeezed lime and club soda

• Pomegranate Mojito

  Pama Liqueur, fresh mint leaves, pure sugar, fresh squeezed limes, 10 Cane Rum and club soda. Cool and refreshing!

• Vanilla Mojito

  Cruzan Vanilla Rum, fresh mint leaves, sugar, fresh squeezed lime juice and club

• Primo Mojito

  A cooling effervescent libation made with Angostora 7 Year Old Rum, fresh mint, pure cane sugar, fresh squeezed lime juice and club soda

• Black Cherry Mojito

  Cruzan Black Cherry Rum, fresh mint, pure sugar, fresh squeezed lime juice

• Cojito Mojito

  Coconut Rum, fresh mint, sugar, fresh squeezed lime juice and club soda

Spirited Libations

• The Long Beach Tea

  Vodka, rum, gin, tequila and triple sec mixed with cranberry juice and 7-up

• Dr.'s Love Potion

  Vodka and peach schnapps mixed with orange, cranberry and pineapple juices with a splash of 7-up

• Original Mai Tai

  The original recipe! Angostura Rum & Meyers Dark Jamaican Rum with fruit juices to make this favorite of the tropics

• Italian Iced Tea

  Rum, amaretto, vodka, triple sec with cranberry and a splash of coke

• Rum Runner

  Angostura 7 Year Old Rum, Meyers Dark Jamaican Rum, Banana Liqueur and Blackberry brandy with fruit juices and a float of Bacardi 151

• The Hamptons

  The ultimate Long Island Iced Tea! Absolut Vodka, Bacardi Silver Rum, Beefeater Gin, Jose Cuervo Gold and Cointreau Liqueur mixed over ice with fruit juices and coke

• Grand Berry Rita'

  Jose Cuervo Gold Tequila blended and Cointreau Liqueur with cranberry, lemon and lime juices

Mason Jar Coolers

Giant 32 Ounce Mason Jar Coolers Filled With Our Refreshing Libations!

• Strawberry Margarita

  Jose Cuervo Silver Tequila, fresh strawberries and juices

• Very Cherry Lime Crush

  Sobieski Vodka, fresh crushed limes, maraschino cherries and fruit juices fill up this 32 ounce mason jar

• Island Berry Lemonade

  Sailor Jerry's Spiced Rum with fresh lemonade and wild berry fruit puree make this unusually refreshing