sliced NY Sirloin with mixed greens, red peppers, onions, tomato, house dressing
Classic Steakhouse Wedge
iceberg lettuce wedge, tomatoes in a blue cheese dressing topped with crispy bacon
New York Sirloin Steak
Wonderful service. Delicious steak.
We went for my boyfriend’s bday. The customer service was impeccable and the food was to die for. I am definitely coming back.
Always incredible service, food and ambiance. Our top choice for steakhouse.
Amazing all around! Best Dirty Martini I ever had! Rib Eye and Veal Parm were fantastic! Service excellent! We loved it!
EXCELLENT WHITE TABLE CLOTH RESTAURANT....LOOKS LIKE IT WAS LEFT OVER FROM THE FIFTIES...WHAT A DELIGHT....STEAK WAS WONDERFUL AND PLENTIFUL....SERVICE WAS EXCELLENT...NOT OVERPOWERING BUT ATTENTIVE....A WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE IN OLD NEW YORK DINING...THEY ARE TO BE COMMENDED FOR KEEPING UP THE STANDARDS OF GOOD FOOD AND WINE...
My husband and I went here for the first time and int was such a great and heartwarming experience .We were treated kindly by the staff and the food was utterly amazing .
If I could I would give it a 5 +star .. Not only was the food amazing ,the service was above and beyond our expectations .It's hard to fine a place like this in heart of NYC .I would totally recommend this place .TUSCANY it's my favorite
This place was fantastic !I am extremely picky with my ratings,but this place wad off the chards!my filet was outstanding ,but my wife's chilean sea bass wad even better !The sides were awesome.When we come back to NYC this place will be the first to visit!
AMAZING STEAKHOUSE !!!I highly recommend this place .Loved the service
Great food ,amazing flavor and taste.Fast and friendly service .
Came here for a work lunch.great food and excellent service
Couldn't speak highly enough of Tuscany .five stars from my top to bottom .service was superb flawless
Excellent steak ,excellent service ,great wine list
Awesome steak house and great service .one of the best steak I ever had in my live
Yum yum !!! Very impressive about the quality of the steak.great service .
Ribeye steak was delicious and juicy .The lobster Mac and cheese was creamy -- excellent. The creamy spinach is always one of our favorites .The best service ever
Excellent service food,exellent service -top notch! Steaks were cooked to perfection .Worth every dollar.
Tuscany is my favorite .
Loved it!Order the Porterhouse steak aged was perfectly cooked !! excellent service
Atmosphere ,food and Service made for an excellent dinning experience .Thanks you Tuscany team for making my birthday very special .
The bone in filet was one of the best I have ever had ,but the truly amazing .Exellent ambiance ,service impeccable .I will come back
WOW!!! The atmosphere of the bar and the restaurant are exactly what makes me love NYC!!
The seafood tower are on point 5 stars
The steaks are superbly presented and prepared
Side dishes ,cream spinach, broccoli,mushrooms the best .....
Love this place! BEST STEAK EVER SURE I haven't try Pete Luger ,but this was definitely the best steak I ever had.it was my first time here and I 'll be coming back soon.I order my steak Mr and it was absolutely amazing ,like butter .Service was great and we got some mashed potato which was delicious .
Definitely deserves 5 star.
Excellent food and service. Love the bar. Great place to meet friends or have a nice family dinner.
The best steak and service highly recommended
Our visit here was amazing !All our Servers where so attentive to detail and ensuring we had a great time .Our server Jack recommended a great bottle wine
The food.... omg... on point ! I wanted every bite to last forever.
Will be back !!!
Very nicely appointed restaurant with a varied menu and good service. The lamb chops I had were excellent and my wife salmon cooked to exactly to her taste. The carrot cake afterwards was delicious. Would definitely return.
we have eaten at some extremely nice places....this is right up there w/ them.
food was outstanding.
Excellente cote de bœuf !
Our second time here and my desire to see if it was as good as the last time paid off.
Steak was excellent as good as any in NY, service was wonderful, and it’s a quiet cozy place.
I’ll be back for another dinner soon
An all-around enjoyable experience. It’s expensive, yes, but I don’t mind spending for excellent food and excellent service. The sautéed Chilean Seabass was the best I have had. My husband’s Filet Mignon was perfect. The special Burrata salad was heavenly. Everything was!
The atmosphere is Romantic and Nice. The owner is very attentive but not to all customers. The staff is mediocre our waiter could have been better. We had to get help from a bus boy or other waiter a couple of times. He never turned around when he was in our area.The food was very good but not exceptional. Especially for the price they were charging. We paid 25 dollars for one crab cake appetizer. It was good but very over priced. I had the special of an 8oz filet Mignon and a lobster tail, good but not worth 90 dollars. While it was nice to try we probably will not be back. There are many great restaurants in New York City we can get a exceptional dinner for over $300.00 for 2 people, which is what we paid with the tip. We only had two drinks.
Ok here it is Tuscany Steakhouse soars to the top of my list for Best Steakhouse. Location 2 minute walk from Central Park south NYC prime real estate. Upon walking into the restaurant we where warmly greeted by the hostess and taken into a lovely old world warm Tuscan style dining room. Our waiters name was Jack very polite and professional waiter. We ordered the beefy tomato and mozzarella salad. Then our entrees my wife ordered shrimp scampi sautéed with fresh garlic and white wine. I ordered the prime ribeye with the bone. The steak was cooked to absolute perfection I requested it be cooked well done they hit a homerun on the first pitch. We split both entrées so we both had a surf and turf. For our sides we had mashed potatoes, sautéed asparagus and an order of homemade onion rings. Mashed potatoes where as good as any other steakhouse mashed potatoes. The asparagus and onion rings where the best ever. Let's get back to the main event the steak was outstanding. The beauty of Tuscany Steakhouse is in its quaint and simple menu done really well. I was amazed at how many returning customers came back with in days of just dining at the restaurant. Oh yea I almost forgot the dessert. Ladies and gentlemen chocolate mousse is simple chocolate mousse with a graham cracker bottom what a treat. It had us floating back to Carnegie Hall just a block away.
1. Tuscany Steakhouse-NYC
2. Ruth Chris Steakhouse-Princeton NJ
3. Roots Steakhouse-Morristown NJ
4. Sweet Waters-Westfield NJ
5. Chars- Bridgewater NJ
WE LOVE THE TUSCANY STEAKHOUSE AND THANK YOU FOR MAKING OUR 24 WEDDING ANNIVERSARY SO SPECIAL
We always love dining at Tuscany Steakhouse and the steaks are always buttery soft and flavorful. Can’t wIt to go back,
It was a great selection for Valentine’s Day. Exceeded expectations.
The porterhouse for 2 was amazing and the sides were delicious.
Excelente quedamos encantados con las atenciones nuestro mesero Jj fue muy amable y atento la comida excelente lo recomiendo 100%
Excellent food in a fairly casual setting.
Tuscany Steakhouse is exceptional. There are so many steakhouses in NYC. This is a neighborhood gem, not to be confused with a tourist spot. Johnny R was our wait person. He is a pro and is entertaining. We had a very enjoyable evening.
One of the most appealing things to me in a restaurant are great servers! Ladies or Gentlemen that care about serving you well, with a smile, with care, timely, and making you feel good about being a patron. Tuscany has this, and congrats to them. Along with a pretty décor, a friendly greeting when you walk in, along with nice ambiance, the menu was chock full of great selections, our party of four had many of them and the food was delicious! A great NYC spot for a delicious dinner! You'll enjoy it.
Tuscany Steakhouse is rated 4.7 stars by 315 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.