Great food friendly service. Willing to accommodate for food allergies.

Wonderful service. Excellent food and amazing ambiance. 100% recommended

Best Italian food we've ever had. Highly recommended

best Thanksgiving deal in the neighborhood. Repeat Customer

My turkey dinner was mediocre at best. The white meat of the turkey tasted like it had been frozen and then reheated and served to me. A manager approached me and asked how was dinner I said it was okay but my friend said that I didn’t care for it. The manager removed the price of my turkey dinner from the check. I think he was right to do it. My friend liked his. So we will return for another dinner. Thank you for your excellent customer service.

Amazing food and fantastic service! We look forward to returning on our next trip to the city.

The staff didn't seem up to the task of serving Thanksgiving prix fixe dinner. The waiter outlined courses (soup and salad, Turkey-Stuffing-Sweet potatoes-etc, and apple crisp for dessert). The soup came (delicious) then they started serving the turkey. What happened to the salad? After we requested it, they brought a big bowl of salad and placed it on the edge of the overcrowded table, which was really for two and not for the four of us, where we spooned (or rather forked it - no serving spoons were in evidence) on our plates next to our turkey, gravy, etc. Then dessert (for 3 out of 4 of us) was brought out in a goblet full of apple slices with cinnamon and a gob of ice cream on top for us to serve ourselves, again, no serving spoons. Gracious dining it was not. We've been going for years, but it really will make us think hard for next year. Not a good experience.

Thanksgiving dinner was better last year. Perhaps because it was less crowded due to covid restrictions. We sat upstairs in the Tavern which is more intimate and less crowded than the main dining room. However I got the impression that they were trying to rush people to turn over the table as the waiter brought both the soup and salad at the same time, explaining that was his instructions. He did remove the salad and brought it back after we finished the soup. The food was good except the soup wasn't hot enough and the gravy tasted like it came from a can. Otherwise lit was very good and we enjoyed our meal.

The Thanksgiving Turkey dinner was to Perfection! The Steak, exactly as ordered! The Veal Parm, super tender! And the Gluten Free Baked Ziti is one of the best in the city!!! The Wait Staff was very attentive and All Smiles! A very busy day for them, but they were "on it" Thank you Tony's!!!

Excellent food our server was Stefan always friendly and knowledgeable.

I've eaten here many times and always love the food and service here.

Consistently the best. Felt like old times before the pandemic. People, noise level and activity. A gem in the neighborhood.

娘の誕生日に利用しました。
Jamesの歌声が素晴らしく、とても思い出に残る誕生日になりました。ありがとうございました。

Very attentive and accommodating staff. Delicious food. Cozy ambiance for Thanksgiving dinner!

I was more than satisfied with our dinner experience. We asked to be seated in a private area since we were a family of 9 and celebrating 2 birthdays. We sat in a perfect space! The food was just delicious! Our waitress was amazing! She was professional and attended to all our needs.
I can’t thank you enough.
We were so happy.
We will definitely be back.

Everything was great! In NY for the holiday and this was a festive dinner.

Holy cow! Seriously good New York Italian, great service, prices, pretty restaurant. Loved it!

Fabulous as always!!

Wonderful always a treat ! Constantly good every time!

Lovely dining experience as usual. I’ve eaten here many times and have never been disappointed. I wish it were in my neighborhood.

Amazing , for check in to bartender to waiter! All top notch

Good food and service. Our go to place.

Fantastic Food and Service! Our server "Stefan" was excellent! The Lobster Ravioli special was wonderful! We will be back!

The best part of the meal was the fried mozzarella appetizer. The veal was super chewy and half the meat was either grizzle or sinew or something other than meat. The meats balls warm but the spaghetti crazy hot.

Been to both branches several times, primary choice with my guests. Always outstanding..

Everything good!

Very authentic Italian restaurant with amazing food and great service.

Wonderful food and waitress!

Always the best food and amazing service. Not a negative thing about this restaurant! Our go to for a delicious meal!

I get to Tony's 5 or 6 times a year. The food is aways great. This visit the food once again was excellent but all 4 meals that came to the table including the appetites came out cold and that was disappointing.

I absolutely love Tony Di Napoli and recommended to the people I traveled with that we eat here. Of the four of us that went out to dinner, two had never been. They were very impressed and can't wait to go back, as do I.

This is our go to Italian restaurant in NYC. This was the first time we took our family and they enjoyed it as much as we do every time we go. Food and service is outstanding.

Great food & large portions. Service was great. Limited washrooms and unisex which was not great. Staff also used the washroom. The washroom I used had a leaky toilet so there was a lot of water on the floor.

The penne alla vodka was hot and delicious. Service was outstanding. Excellent dining experience and definitely coming back.

Everything very good!!!

The waitress was outstanding and the food was delicious!

Honestly one of my favorite restaurants in the whole city. And i particularly have an affinity for this location. From service, quality of food, quantity of food, affordability, it’s all an amazing experience. In addition, whoever is over the music rotation typically does NOT miss. You can usually catch Al Green, Teddy Pendergrass, or The Spinners playing softly across the speakers. What a true gem!

I was expecting more from Tony's Di Napoli. When we entered, the hostess could have been little nicer. She basically demanded to see our ID and Vax card and didnt give us a warm welcome. Our waitress also did the minimum amount of work and carlessly poured our water glasses not caring if she spilled some on the table or got some on me. The food was super average, I've had better italian food/pasta. Also, i felt super rushed because i was still eating bread and they already brought out our meals like 15 mins later. However, the decor is great and you feel like youre in a little Italian cafe. Wouldn't go here again.

Was a great value and very tasty
Would definitely recommend

The drinks were large and moderately priced. The baked clams the best and the
servers excellent.