Always a great place to kickoff our NY city trips. While the restaurant was not as busy with broadway going dark, the food was still top quality. Great service. We had the traditional chicken parm, linguine marinara and fettuccine Alfredo. There were only 3 of us but I wanted some extra food to send back to campus with my daughter as much of their food options are now limited. Great night.

A must visit when you’re anywhere in New York City

Love this place! The noise level downstairs was perfect—not too noisy at all. We shared the ricotta salad and the rigatoni with eggplant and mozzarella—so yummy. Nice bottle of Niro montepulciano—lovely!

Tony's NEVER ever disappoints....consistency is paramount @ this establishment..I'll be back soon!

Amazing food and excellent service. The waitress made great suggestions and explains the menu choices to help. Late night dining and the staff were still engaged and friendly.

Great meal. We cleared all of our plates. The manager even gave us complimentary dessert which was a nice treat!

Great find near Knickerbocker hotel. Fabulous attention from the waiter. Amazing cheesecake.

Can't go here without getting the rigatoni with vodka and mushrooms. Portions are incredibly generous for the price — one of the best dining options in the theatre district for sure.

We dine here quite often. The food is always great and the service is really great. They never rush us and they take great care of us. Our waiter Ken is just excellent. It is great for a special event , pre or post theater, friends get together and a special occasion. Highly recommended

My husband and I enjoyed a late meal of fried zucchini, mussels diavolo and wine, followed by Irish coffee. Tony’s is known for huge servings, so we polished off these appetizers and counted them as a meal. This is our standard practice whenever in NYC and a nice change of pace from other dining. Our waitress, Julia, was excellent, adding to our pleasant experience.

I bring my students every year (since 2012). Tony’s NEVER disappoints! Outstanding Italian food. My students look forward to it every year.