I am only writing text in this box so I can submit this review. OpenTable makes it annoying to submit reviews.

Toloache is a fantastic restaurant and a must go to. The manager is exceptional and his suggestions are spot on. Their guacomole was so good!!! The special blood orange margarita was to die for. The skirt steak was so tasty and delicious. I am so happy to find a place that makes a skirt steak this perfectly. This is one of my new favorite restaurants in the neighborhood.

Delicious food, strong margaritas and great service by Perla! The private outdoor cabins made us feel safe during covid. Highly recommend.

The wooden boxes were awesome and private. Perfect with the heater for a cold April night and the sliding window is genius! Awesome margaritas and guac. Now I can say I’ve been to all locations! #outdoorboxesarebest

Excellent food and attentive service- wonderful!

Had our own cabin outside. Food was tasty and well done. Service was good.

All the basics with a twist--fruit in the margaritas, nice texture to the guacamole, shrimp that are large and juicy. Service is friendly without being pushy. I love the place!

Toloache is always one of my “go to” Restaurants.

The food is consistently good, the staff is as friendly as you’ll find anywhere and both the outdoor and indoor dining are wonderful

Love the glazed miso cod.

The food was amazing - house made guac and chips so good we ordered a second round! Main courses (burro, seafood paella, quesadilla, cod) were all excellently cooked and had great flavor. House margaritas helped it all down nicely.

Always outstanding!

Server was amazing, food was mediocre. The outdoor seating was super warm.

Best Mexican in the city! Great service too!

Food is always fabulous. Yummy margaritas. Super seevice

Food was delicious! The server was so so sweet. The owner came by a few times and was wonderful!

Fantastic food. Best Mexican in New York for sure. We are from Mexico and have never tried such delicious plates in Manhattan before. The huitlacoche quesadilla is just wow. The meats are extremely tender and the pineapple mezcal cocktail was so great. We had dinner outdoors and felt so cozy, warm and comfortable inside the cabins they have constructed outside. Just GREAT.

They were not able to provide us with a safe seat after we had made a reservation. We needed to leave.

Phenomenal pandemic outdoor seating (private booths), delicious food, and good service.

Wonderful food as always and sitting in the outdoor heated tables was wonderful

What a fabulous spot!! From the incredibly knowledgeable and fun service to the unparalleled food it was perfection! Also, the music was super fun and the Covid guidelines were followed to a t. Highly recommend!!

It was our first time back from indoor dining and everything was excellent- food, service, COVID protocols. Excited to be able to dine indoors again so we will definitely be back!

Amazing set up out back with plenty of heaters! Wait staff was lovely and food was delicious.

We go every weekend for Sat brunch as well as during the week for dinner.
We love the outdoor dining facilities they have set up the service and the food are truly excellent!
We are fortunate to have this restaurant in our neighborhood!
Robert Friedman

Always a favorite!

Outdoor experience: We ate in Toloache 82’s outdoor cabins yesterday. Each cabin is 100% enclosed and there is no air flow between rooms, plus the doors slide shut (no cold curtain issues). We were TOASTY warm with the heater blasting and actually had to crack the window - and it was 31° out. As of 1/30/2021, the only dining options were in the cabins - so you don’t risk accidentally booking an outdoor table.

The meal itself: the food and drinks were outstanding! We went through several rounds of their margaritas, including the cucumber-jalapeño, roasted pineapple-jalapeño, and watermelon. All were delicious, if a bit pricey for the size. We loved the fruita guacamole, which was a totally unique take on a classic and will be what we judge guacamole against in the future.

The real winner of the meal was the Suadero tacos. They were mouthwatering and completely overshadowed the other fish tacos (which were also great by themselves... but cannot compare to the suadero). The moisture made the corn tortillas a little tricky to manage, but it was totally worth it. We finished with some fresh churros with chocolate and duche de leche sauce. A pricy meal, but 100% worth it. We will be back!

Outdoor dining on the back patio. Great heat lamps and rather quiet, as to be expected during this time. But overall a very good meal!

This is an easy outdoor dining evening...informal, food is delicious and doesn't crash when it goes cold in this weather. Staff super friendly

Absolutely amazing recommend 10/10

When we arrived, it appeared the manager or owner was hosting. They didn’t have our reservation, he went back inside to check came out asked me to pull mine up (not a big deal) then he said you know we are only open until 10pm and sort of gave us a look. I told him we knew (it was 8:30). I just kinda got the vibe he didn’t want to serve us. We did get a table the waiter was awesome, food was good , drinks were so great! I had the de la Calle. Just generally not welcoming with the mix up at the door. Two bigger groups in the back were very very loud and we left before they were done so I don’t really understand the we close at 10 comment.

Consistently excellent food. Extremely safe and warm environment. Lovely staff.

Excellent food, drinks, service

Great food! Great margheritas! And the staff is always so welcoming. One of my favorite meals in NYC when I visit from Paris.

Great place for some out of the ordinary Mexicali! Won't disappoint!

Best place in the neighborhood! Go give it s visit, order delivery or buy a gift certificate to support these great people!

Great Mexican food with creative twists. The drinks are delicious, too.

All was great!

I loved the food and the place i didnt like that they had a party literally so close to us when they were many empty tables but chose the one next to us and i couldnt even hear my self while im talking

birthday celebration. Awesome place

We've been here now three times, and each time we have ordered similar things, the "medium" spiced guacamole is wonderful and different, with pomegranate and mango. We usually order three different taco entrees (2 tacos per order for a total of 6 tacos to then be shared for the two of us--so each gets three tacos each). The short ribs tacos were amazing! All in all, good food, although wine prices seem excessively high, and limited choices.

Great place to hung out with friends. Good service and food.