We made a reservation for our anniversary and they took us right to our table. Food came quick. Drinks were great! Highly recommend the short rib taco with bone marrow and the carnitas tacos! Mango Mojito was great too!! Cozy romantic ambiance.
Good food, professional service. Too loud and boisterous to fully enjoy ourselves.
Great staff! Amazing service and cocktails. The manager was so nice... we forgot our printed show tickets at hotel and he printed them for us which they didn’t have to do. The food was amazing!! Will definitely be back!
Excellent food, service, and atmosphere. Great location if attending a show.
Toloache is my go to place for pre-theater dinner. The food is so delicious and the margaritas are too! The service is attentive, friendly and makes the experience so enjoyable. We always order to share and eat family style here. The menu is really well suited to that and you'll want to have as much of the menu as you can. But don't eat too many chips and guacamole because you'll want to save room for the awesome desserts.
Great service! Lively place, definitely need a reservation because it’s in the theater district . Guacamole was fresh and creamy , the white Sangria was deliciously refreshing. The carne asada was a bit tough but the desserts /dulce de leche and churros - made up for thatl
Excellent! We had wonder margaritas and entrees. The grasshoppers were authentic and great! The servers told us how they had them at home. Loved it
Very nice experience
Although the food is not authentic Mexican, it is good and tasty. My grandson said his taco was the best he'd ever had. The noise level at lunch was very very loud, but the service was good and it was close to the theater we were going to for a matinee.
Fresh ingredients and exceptional service
Other than it being quite noisy...like almost everywhere these days...the service, cocktails and food were all simply excellent! I perfect choice if you are going to a theatre and need a tasty, early dinner.
Occasion was trip to New York with 7 year old grandson. Close to our hotel, weather was bad, and the food was reasonable and very good especially the Branzino which was a special I think that night. We would go back with our without grand children.
Very good food. Would recommend for pre-show dinner.
Girls day in NY for Escape to Margaritaville. This was the perfect pre-show meal and of course Margaritas. The Margaritas were very good and the food was terrific too. I will definitely return and tell friends about it.
Needed something close to the theater.
Service was excellent and the food was, too.
Great margaritas, guacamole and the entrees, too.
Had the braised short ribs and marrow tacos and the chicken tacos, both excellent as were the sides. We thoroughly enjoyed our Experience!
The food was decent but the service needs to be a lot better. Even though we had reservations, we had to wait for another 25minutes to be seated which defeats the purpose of having reservations. On top of that, the lady wasn’t telling us the truth and originally told us the table was available. Once we seated, the waitress was nice, but we told her we were there for a BD and we wanted to get a dessert, and she said sure, but we had to remind her a couple of times and then had to seak her out to make the request because she never brought us the dessert menu. On top of that, when it was time for her to leave, she just left without telling us that her shift was over and didn’t even ask if we needed anything. So, we had to wait another 20 minutes for the check. I have been here in the past and had such bad service
Worth the wait to sit down, this place is bustling, and with good reason, the food is probably the best Mexican in midtown. Unexpected flavor combinations, exquisite home made tortillas, and great courteous service. The ladies at the front desk are lovely, just give them time to find your table, this place is always really busy, be patient, it will be worth it.
A friend recommended we eat here. It did not disappoint. Margaritas were awesome! Three out of 4 entrees were great. I did not love the paella. The seafood was over cooked, and overall the dish was very dry. I will not order it the next time I visit.
I felt I was being rushed
Great place- one of my favorite spots in Midtown.
We LOVED Toloache! It was intimate and the bartender and waitstaff were professional and very attentive, even though it was a busy Friday night. We arrived 15 minutes earlier than our reservation, but they were able to seat us very soon after we got there. The food was very authentic and delicious. I'll just add that our table in the beautifully decorated upstairs area reminded me of the scene in Love Actually when Colin Firth's character proposes to Aurelia:)
Terrific food and convenient to Broadway theaters.
OK Mexican food - found it over-priced and the drinks/guac meh. Had to call 3x to update our booking because it was never properly updated either.
I like Rosa Mexicana/Dos Caminos better.
Our server was lovely, and the food was delicious! Highly recommend any of the shrimp, lobster or brisket tacos. If also recommend the Toloache margarita!
Low quality food that has no resemblance to Mexican food. Chicken breast was pieces of grizzle. Salsa is like cream of red sauce. Tables.are.tight together with deafening noise. Hard to get waiters attention. Very expensive eespecially for Mex food even if the food were good. Our 16 year old grandson could.not eat the horrible.skirt steal. Do not go here.
New favorite before a show
The paella was delicious. Guacamole was good, but mild is REALLY mild. Pollo tolache was delish too. Desserts look great but we were to full to partake.
Great service too.
Don’t go before a show without reservations.
Always reliably good, with attentive knowledgeable servers who get you in and out if needed and fresh well prepared food.
We enjoyed a lunch at Toloache with a large party of 12 guests. The restaurant seated half of the guests and was patient in waiting for the remaining guests to arrive. Meal was excellent and service was great. Staff was courteous and helpful. They related well with adults and children.
Welcoming and friendly,the service was exceptional. We had all ages in the group and the menu held something for all. The service was quick. The waiters even remembered where each dish went in our large group. We'd certainly visit again.
We started with the guacamole trio. One was better than the other. Could not stop eating those chips! I had the carne asada. It was cooked perfectly. I did not like the sauce on the cheese enchilada, however. Red sangria paired nicely, yum!
Food was amazing ❤️
Excellent food especially the tacos!! Excellent service. Miguel the bartender was awesome
The food was fabulous and great value. Service was excellent.
Arrived 30 min early for 6:00 reservation for 2 said we would be happy to get seated early but was told to go to the bar-had a great margarita. At 6 we checked with hostess and was told they would come get us in a few min. Crowd was increasing. At 6:10 went back to hostess and was told just a few more minutes. At 6:20 we checked back and told they gave our table away! But they would find one. Another 10 minutes later...They stuck a table at top of stairs for us - and crowded the table of 12 next to us into smaller space. Asked to speak to manager to express dissatisfaction but he never came to talk to us. Just felt they treated us very poorly. We were going to a show so we couldn’t leave to find another restaurant and just ordered a few apps so we wouldn’t miss curtain. VERY SORRY WE SELECTED TOLOACHE.
Great except for the noise
Really lovely restaurant. This one had been recommended to us and we weren't disappointed. From the friendly staff to the exceptional food, this was a lovely restaurant that we would definitely consider coming back to when we next come back to NYC.
Food is great and is the service for a pre-theater reservation.
Good food, very crowded and cramped, not very accommodating for picky children, no kids menu. But it is in time square area near theatres so I guess all this is understandable.
What a great restaurant. We were recommended by a friend, and have gone here 3x already. Great food, service and ambiance. Fresh ingredients, perfectly prepared. The skirt steak is delicious as well as the guacamole.
What a great place !
Good people the food was very good and great atmosphere
We will be going back