Great authentic Mexican cuisine with friendly, welcoming service. The outdoor dining was comfortable and felt safe in our new COVID world.

Lobster tacos. Need I say more???

What a great find! The service was attentive and the food was fabulous. We started with Queso Fundido with chorizo, which was so creamy and delicious. My son enjoyed the cod which was made with a black truffle chipotle butter that he raved about, and I did the same with my Camerones Toloache. Both dishes were a delightful definition of spicy - bursting with flavor! We had an absolutely delightful meal and will visit again

The pasta and bean soup was not equal to most that I have had elsewhere. Most of those others had a bean broth and had more beans than pasta in it. This restaurant's version has more pasta and a light tomato broth. The restaurant's special of the day Bronzino was fully covered with lemon sauce, but the Bronzino had no fish flavor, perhaps due to overcooking the Bronzino.

Amazing food. Funny waiter. Can’t wait to go back!

Service was excellent and the food was flavorful and nicely balanced.

This place is amazing! The good taste absolutely incredible and the service is great! The music could be a tad bit louder, only suggestion.

Dined with my 11 year old niece. Our waiter was sweet and attentive. The food was amazing. Get the guacamole trio.

Birthday brunch

fantastic service and the food always so tasty--the trio of guac is fantastic, all the tacos (fish, beef, lobster, pork) have been delicious, the quesadilla tasty and the margaritas are amazing. Fantastic and personal service from Bartolo! Thanks, will cont to come back for more

Had a nice late lunch, still w COVID safeguards, restaurant was pretty empty. Food was great, our server was amazing. We a frequent visitors of Toloache midtown.

The waiters were friendly, food was delicious and social distancing made the night a little more enjoyable

Amazing place

Great service, good prices. Will for sure be coming again!

Great time!

Margaritas were delicious, the guac and tuna ceviche were so flavorful and tasty. My cousin who has never eaten a piece of 'raw' fish ate the slices of cured tuna like nothing. the tacos were so light and tasty. Service was personal and great

A fantastic cozy restaurant with fantastic food in MidTown, the service is quick so not a long wait if you are trying to grab something before a show.

In February 2021, they have indoor and outdoor seating so may be worth calling ahead to make sure they have a table for your preference

We had a double V Day dates! Amazing dinner experience, we felt safe with all COVID 19 safety measures adopted by the restaurant. We should be back soon!

Come here all the time. Been trying to support restaurants we really like due to covid, but 3 strikes and I am out. First time they said they didn’t take reservations because of covid, even though I had one. Waited 20 min. Second time no reservation and when we arrived they couldn’t seat us because we didn’t have a reservation and last night waited 30 min with a reservation. Food is good but there are too many restaurants in nyc to bother with the haphazard service of this place again.

Perfection. Such a treat, especially in today's dining world. Best staff, delicious food, warm, enjoyable atmosphere.
Thank you!!!

Really good food! And nice place overall. Had the enchiladas and guac which were really good!

Love this restaurant!! Never had a bad experience. Would recommend to everyone!

If you’re looking for great fold, great service, and great environment with some music i the background then this is the place to be.

They were a little short staffed, we waited awhile for drinks and such. But the food is what has kept us coming back! Nice size portions, quality ingredients. Will always go back when I’m in town.

Always amazing! Highly recommend to everyone for any occasion

Visiting the city for sisters night out! Dinner was fabulous short rib tacos were wonderful!

The tables have the proper distance. The staff was attentive. The food was great.

If you are yearning for México City or TexMex, Toloache is delicious but is neither of these. And the prices aren’t either! Then again, we want our restaurants to be able to stay in business! And please bugntio fir fabulous wait staff! Huitlacoche quesadilla had so much going on that the eponymous flavor was overshadowed. But “it” did taste very good. You still don’t know what huitlacoche is but maybe later when we travel again. Terrific guacamole (real thing con chile) grilled chicken and meat and ask for “normal” enchiladas. Not on menu but clearly in the chef’s talented hands and heart.

Toloache never fails to impress. Out of countless dining experiences, our expectations have been exceeded every time. You’d do yourself a disservice to not put one of Chef Medina’s restaurants on your list of must tries.

Love the food here. Best Quac and the meals were definitely delicious

Customer service was excellent and food delicious. Highly recommend.

lively place and nice people but food was overpriced still yummy tho !

Great good and drinks! Also amazing customer service!!!

Below average food. Ambience was meh. The staff was helpful though

Outstanding service and great food.

as a new yorker, its the not the best Mexican place to go because of the small portions and outrages prices.

Excellent food and service!

I read about the restaurant, and I decided to visit while in NYC. I made a booking. When I arrived, I was near the host stand. They two waiters came and sat a woman right away, then they ignored me for more than 10 mins, and I was about to leave. When finally someone arrived to help me, he just told me to go and find a table upstairs. I ordered a cocktail, and they brought the wrong drink, I´ve got my appetiser, minutes later the drink and in almost 20 minutes my main course. I was waiting for the wine which arrived when I was finishing my meal. The whole problem was because the woman who arrived after I was one of the waiter´s visit and was getting the whole attention of the crew and the few tables around were in the same situation. The food was just ok but pricey, and the place was noisy. I don´t think there was a manager that night, but the service was awful.

I want to thank the staff who treated us decently and politely. Nothing special but respect. We found very bad attitude and no hospitality at all in most of the places we dined in on our trip to nyc.

On our way to laguardia we stopped by for a bite at toloache. We sat on the second floor, had truffle quesadilla which was delicious and small, also mild guacamole, and veggie tacos. All these three dishes were great.

Greeting from miami!!!

This restaurant was everything and more, we found parking right in front and sat inside. Food was delicious and came out so quick, the portions seemed small but it was actually perfect. We had dessert too which was phenomenal. Our waiter was funny and made us feel very welcome. Overall definitely coming back here