Food is good, ambience is fine but real obnoxious attitude. Had a 7:30 reservation and showed up at 7:15. Plenty of empty tables but they wanted to make a point of not seating us until the reservation time...... until my girlfriend made a big stink. The hostess just relished in her power saying, "WE'LL SEAT YOU AT YOUR RESERVATION TIME." Good thing for them they're the only restaurant in Manhattan....... Oh wait, there are a million other restaurants in Manhattan.
Very bland food. Very. See Mexican good elsewhere. Service just ok.
Never a bad meal at this place. So convenient to the theater district and TiMes Swuare
We’ve been here a few times before shows and are never disappointed. The food is always great and love the margaritas of course! We were very politely asked to switch tables before our food arrived which of course was no problem at ALL, only mentioning it because afterward the manager was nice enough to send over TWO desserts and a round of tequila shots for the table which was just above and beyond. Our server Armando was also awesome and gave great service!
We eat here whenever we are in NYC! The food is amazing and there is always a new menu!!
The food was delicious! The lobster tacos were so good, tender and buttery. Tried the sampler guacamole and couldn’t decide which I liked better. Great food for the price. Would definitely go back.
Excellent food! Very attentive wait staff!
The food was high quality and delicious. Definitely get a reservation as the place stays quite busy. This one is worth the wait - try it!
Best Mexican in NYC. It’s also a great choice when going to a show on Broadway.
Fabulous food. Great service.
I love this restaurant and have been here many times with my family but was treated poorly tonight because I was dining alone
Poor service and the food was shockingly cold was told due to them putting tomato and onions on top that’s why it was cold not a great excuse, was looking forward to trying something different but a shame
Overall, the food is yummy here and they got us in and out quickly before our show. It is pricey, though, for what you get— and everything is extra, including rice and beans with your meal! So it is a good— but not great—option before or after a show, if you want to get out quickly.
Everything was delicious! From the margaritas to the chips and guacamole to the entrees and desserts....awesome!!!
Good Staff, Amazing food, Wonderful evening
This is a great find for really good authentic yet innovative Mexican food. Aside from the delicious food, the drink menu was interesting, and the bartenders very personable. The whole experience was great, and I would definitely go back.
Everything was delicious and the service was excellent. Everyone was extremely friendly and provided a great atmosphere. I would recommend this restaurant to everyone.
I am a senior woman was taking granddaughter to show. It has a pleasant warm environmen. Lovely decor.
My children had been there before..when I arrived after 11 & before they opened at 11:30 to change our reservation from 3 to 4 they were nice to let me use the rest room Next time I will try some of their specials as I never eat Mexican food.
Great. Food was very good. Servers did a great job. We come here on every trip to NYC.
Fun place to eat, friendly servers.
Excellent meal at Toloache. Food was amazing with incredibly friendly staff. Highly recommend
be sure and get reservations... it's noisy, but not too loud....great food, close to theater...if you want a quieter meal, ask to sit upstairs..
Excellent food! Best Mexican food in NYC! Very authentic and the service is very good!
We loved the food and atmosphere. Very convenient to the Gershwin theater
Everything was very nice except the tables are on top of each other. My wife and i were at a table for two which was squeezed in a line of two top tables. We were on top of each other. We were uncomfortable just trying to have a conversation. In order to even get up to go to the restroom the tables next to ours, and ours, had to be moved.
Great food...good selection for my young pre-teen nieces (one is a vegetarian). Great portions, friendly and helpful staff. Nice little gem in the heart of the theatre district. Would definitely recommend!
Awesome. They got us to our show on time.
We typically come to Toloache every time we come to NYC. The food and service were good as always but this time it was super crowded and loud making dinner conversation difficult.
Love this restaurant. Have had dinner there many times. Food is great and staff very nice. Highly recommended it. Make sure you make a reservation as they get very busy!
Very attentive service fast and efficient
Food was delicious
One of our favorite restaurants to go to when we are in New York. Great food, service and ambience! And we love their margaritas! We'll be back!
Very crowded and felt chaotic- food was being rushed out of kitchen and some came cold. Staff seemed very stressed
Excellent food and service. Inventive, different, but still authentic. Saw the table next to us order then re-order desert, so it must have been excellent.
Birthday brunch for wife and daughter. Wonderful restaurant in theater district on 50th St.
Authentic Mexican food prepared to perfection.
Great drinks too!
Tacos are outstanding, I would recommend making an entire meal out of them. Entrees were good, fried brussels sprouts side was delicious, but the tacos are the star. The bathroom was disappointing. Drinks are excellent, as was the service.
I love this place! All of them staff have great personalities and work very well together.
Amazing dining experience with delicious Mexican food. Perfect for dinner before a show!!
Food could have been better given the traffic. But the service was good and the food was out quick with a full house.
Very noisy and crowded.
I have been a patron of Tolache for many years and it never disappoints. Food is fantastic, service is always great. My go to restaurant to take first time meetings as it is always a memorable experience.