The Whitby Bar and Restaurant

Commentaires sur le restaurant The Whitby Bar and Restaurant de personnes qui y ont mangé. Selon des cotes récentes.

1. P

   Peri

   New York City3 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé il y a 5 jours

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   We had a great experience for high tea at the whitby hotel! Great service food and atmosphere for a birthday celebration
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

2. V

   Victoria

   Colombus2 commentaires

   4.0

   Y est allé il y a 7 jours

   1. Cote globale 4
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   We went for their afternoon tea which was delightful. The room and decor were also lovely. And the service staff were welcoming, pleasant and polite. The only downside is we booked our tea for the latest time slot in the afternoon, and the elegant dining room was right next to the bar area which was already heating up with loud music and chatter. This rather shattered the quiet ambience of the dining room. Unfortunately there was no sliding door to close off the room. So lesson learned, book your afternoon tea for earlier in the day before the after hours office crowd comes in!
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

3. R

   Richard VIP

   San Francisco51 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé le 20 avril 2025

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 2
   4. Ambiance 5

   excellent, excellent food and presentation. unfortunately did not see our server at all during our entire meal.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

4. H

   Helen VIP

   New York City57 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé le 17 avril 2025

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   Brought my colleagues here for dinner to celebrate a birthday. The Whitby has been a long time favorite of mine - everyone loved it. The food was delicious and the setting is just wonderful.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

5. J

   Jillian

   New York City22 commentaires

   1.0

   Y est allé le 13 avril 2025

   1. Cote globale 1
   2. Nourriture 1
   3. Service 4
   4. Ambiance 5

   Afternoon tea experience was extremely disappointing. $95/pp for tea, 4 bite sized pastries, 2 scones, and 3 sliver sized and mushy finger sandwiches, and 1 the size of two quarters. The waiter said they make the food in advance which is why the sandwiches are mushy. The moisture from the food seeps into the bread and it’s very unappetizing. This is the second time we went to tea here and this has been the case both times. So for tea and scones, you can just go to Harney and Sons and pay $15 for an equally pleasant experience and the same amount of food. $95 for tea and scones is just highway robbery. The decor is nice and the tea is good, but that’s about it. Their sister hotel, the Crosby, has even better decor and I recommend their tea over the Whitby. They also serve much more food so the price feels more so justified, and while the sandwiches are also mushy there because they’re premade, they are much bigger. If you really want to go here, just order a cup of tea off the menu because the rest of the experience is not worthwhile.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

6. V

   Virginia VIP

   New York City17 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé le 9 avril 2025

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   My favorite go to for breakfast, and drinks! Food is healthy, fresh, and delicious! The menu has a great variety. The service is excellent and decor is bright, sophisticated and uplifting but warm. And mostly pretty low noise factor!
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

7. T

   Tanya

   New York City6 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé le 6 avril 2025

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 4
   4. Ambiance 5

   We totally enjoyed the spring afternoon tea! The staff was friendly and the service was impeccable.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

8. P

   Patricia

   Orlando 2 commentaires

   3.0

   Y est allé le 1 avril 2025

   1. Cote globale 3
   2. Nourriture 3
   3. Service 3
   4. Ambiance 3

   The restaurant is trendy and fashionable. Obviously the place for local business people. The tea was $100 but website and my confirmation said $75. The sandwiches were a little moist but scones were very good. I thought the tea was overpriced. Lunch of hamburger and salmon for two others was very nicely done.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

9. C

   Christopher VIP

   New York City8 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé le 29 mars 2025

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   I love the Whitby so much! My go to place whenever I have something special to celebrate.
   

   • 

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

10. L

    Laurie

    Denver 1 commentaire

    3.0

    Y est allé le 28 mars 2025

    1. Cote globale 3
    2. Nourriture 2
    3. Service 2
    4. Ambiance 5

    We had afternoon tea with caviar and champagne addition. The caviar service was very good, the sandwiches and baked goods were just okay. The waitress kept the water glasses filled, but otherwise was not very present and made a significant error on the bill and needed to be shown the menu to remedy it. The tea was served first and sat while we were enjoying the champagne and caviar. By the time the tea stand was served, the tea was quite cold. The dining room was beautiful and set a wonderful atmosphere. Although, there were many empty tables, we were seated directly next to two other tables on the banquette and felt crowded unnecessarily. Can’t go too wrong having afternoon tea with people you enjoy, but it could have been much better. A bit disappointing.
    

    • 

    Ce commentaire est-il utile?