The Still Whiskey Steaks

Our waiter was fantastic. It was son's 21st birthday and he treated him wonderfully!!

This is the second time we have eaten here when visiting my daughter, as we are all steak lovers. Unfortunately, we gave them a second try, and the $30 rib eye was predominately gristle. Almost inedible. The baked potato was remarkable, but I can cook a lot of them for $30. Will not return for steak again.

Service was great. Food was delish. Prices were decent, not bad at all. Atmosphere was cozy and inviting. Had the prime rib and mashed potatoes, both were wonderful.

Awesome food and service!

We had a great non-traditional Thanksgiving here and it was great!! Bartender made some pretty amazing pies, all the staff were so really engaged with all patrons - really a positive experience! I'm anxious to check this place out when it's non-holiday.

Outstanding and comfortable atmosphere. The food was amazing while the service was perfect.

Another great meal! This is a cant miss spot when we visit Fort Collins. Our Waiter was excellent. Can’t remember his name but he had and awesome mustache 😊

We were seated in a timely manner and staff was exceptional.

Steaks cooked incorrectly, ordered items missed and the main course was delivered before we had a chance to get halfway through our salads.

Over, a disappointing experience.

Steaks overcooked

Always good food and wine selection.
Only issue was my wife had asked that her salmon be cooked through and it came out raw. But they tried again and it came out perfect

The waiter was good - when ordering steaks at this price - i expect them to come out on a warm plate. The waiter was correct when he said it wasn’t spicy!! It should just be called regular Mac and cheese . Since we were there in late afternoon - i am interested to see what the night aervings are

Steaks were actually not cooked to order, we had to send back and they were only slightly better when we got them back. The burger and chicken sandwich were actually fantastic, it’s just too bad the namesake of the restaurant was below average.

We love our meal and time spent there. The staff was awesome.

One of our favorite places to eat in Old Town! The servers are always great and the food is excellent. Excellent appetizers, tender steaks, and diverse side dishes. Casual atmosphere and always quiet enough for a conversation.

We loved this place for a family dinner. Personally, I eat very clean and it was hard to find something that complied with my diet, but the server made accommodations for me as best he could which I appreciated! Will definitely return. Great vibe!

Great food at every price range. Super friendly staff in a very comfortable setting. Highly recommended!

Great place, fantastic drinks. A tad bit pricey But definitely would go back.

This place was absolutely wonderful. I wanted to treat my dad to a special night out for his 70th birthday and this place 100% delivered. Our table was ready right at 6, our server was so nice and the food was fantastic. We left very full and incredibly impressed.

Second time here for dinner and it was perfect. Can’t wait till next time !

Awesome food. Great service. Not cheap but good value. The Bison Rib eye was the absolute best I have ever had. The sides were great. Definitely would do it again.

Came to visit our college son. Wanted to take him out for a good steak. This was THE place to do it. Had an amazing waiter by the name of Pete. Food was excellent. Best Brussels sprouts we ever tasted. My son and husband’s rib eyes came out hot, perfect tenderness, a man’s dream steak. lol. I had prime rib which was delicious. Loved the crusted herbs and seasoning. The loaded baked potato was the bomb! Simply delicious. Ask for Pete. He made our night. Great service.

Fabulous top shelf manhattan. Great food as always.

The food was very good+ The drinks also very good,kinda like women 1 just wright,2 is two myant and 3 is not enough,

I always enjoy the food here, the steaks and sides are delicious. I was however a little disappointed with my request for a nice boot or table for a special celebration. I have been to the restaurant many times and I am aware of the layout and upon request of a special table we were placed at the front of the restaurant, near a noisy bar showing cartoons and not at what I would have considered a table fit for a “special occasion”. I did appreciate the card left on the table indicating we were celebrating something but was let down at being shoved at the front of a loud bar on a special night.

Amazing food, great ambiance, good service! Had the crab cakes, loaded baked potato and Bone-in Buffalo Ribeye medium rare and it was cooked perfect and melted in your mouth. The flavor was AWESOME! Definitely going back! You won't be disappointed!

We loved the appetizers and our steaks were great! The Mac & Cheese did not have enough sauce or flavor, so that was a disappointment. Also, the dessert menu could be expanded, they had run out of Apple Crisp and the other 2 options didn't appeal, otherwise we would have ordered dessert, especially since we were celebrating a birthday. They did provide a lovely Birthday coupon with great options...so that was a great surprise and we appreciated that!

Food was delicious, cocktails were perfect and service was outstanding. Definitely will be back.

Appetizers were average. The bacon wrapped shrimp were just dusted with bacon bits. The $21 steak tips were not remotely worth the price. Were once $12 app, now a full priced entree.
Our entrees were still solid. Service was slow and forgetful. Mixed drinks have gone downhill.

Anniversary dinner and greeted at the door with a special anniversary card with choices of 10% discount, champagne or dessert and we thought that was a very nice touch. The food was perfect from the French onion soup to the steak and the burger, not one single complaint. The Blood Orange cocktail is to die for ! Only complaints we did have was that service was a little slow but we think it was just an understaffing issue, our waiter was lovely but seemed to be working tables from one end of restaurant to the other. The evening would have been 100% perfect if the music had not been so loud. We will definitely go back to this restaurant.

Great service and great food, got what I expected for the price

Love the steaks. So much flavor

My son goes to school at CSU and we were visiting. I heard good things about this restaurant but we were non-plussed. The chicken wasn’t so tasty, little dry, my ribs were good, my husband said the salmon was sweet. The place is cool, maybe we had an off night service was great. Amelia was our server.

Little pricey, however everything they serve is top shelf. Service was wonderful and the food was tasty. If you make it for happy hour, it is really Good!

Service was great, there were only a few customers at 5:00 p.m. on a Sunday evening. I had a steak wedge entree salad and the steak was lukewarm. My husband had a NY strip that was cooked perfectly but was nothing special just a steak. Good location in the heart of old town Fort Collins.

We were celebrating our 21st anniversary with my in-laws and decided to check out a new restaurant:) very happy with the service, our food was delicious but my husbands steak was overdone. Jordan (waitress) was awesome & had them make a new steak which was cooked perfectly. Bummer it came out as the rest of us were finishing up our food, but she did remove it from the bill. Really great service! Thanks for the happy anniversary wishes & the delicious dessert. We will definitely be back & will refer friends!

My food was cold. And cold air blew on our table from the HVAC system. Plus they kept the front door open even when it was in the fifties outside. We sat upstairs and the cold came through the front door right up to our table.

Casual local steak house with great value

I have been eating ribeye steaks my entire life. I am The a second-generation rancher. Charco Broiler still has the best steak in town. Yours was okay, but it was pretty chewy and pretty grissley. Seemed like it should be a bit better for the money.

Best steakhouse in Fort Collins. Always good service. Will be back soon.