Nearby points of interest
Nearby points of interest
About THE POOL
THE POOL is a seafood restaurant created by Major Food Group. It is an architectural treasure that will now present the treasures of the world's ocean to match. The greatest expressions of seafood prepared with an eye towards simplicity and a focus on fun. A celebratory experience for all of the senses that incorporates art, architecture, food, and drink. Seafood in all of it's forms raw, cooked, and whole.
New York, NY 10022
Seafood, American, Mediterranean
Hours of Operation:
Monday - Saturday: 6pm - 11pm
between Lexington & Park Ave
$50 and over
AMEX, MasterCard, Visa
E, M to Lexington Ave
6 to 51st Street
Bar/Lounge, Beer, Cocktails, Corkage Fee, Full Bar, Gluten-free Menu, Private Room, Wheelchair Access, Wine
THE POOL Ratings and Reviews
I was very impressed with The Pool! The service, the food, the ambiance was absolutely perfection! I enjoyed every single menu choice and I am definitely recommending this gem to friends and family. Come to this establishment to be treated like a King and Queen and eat like one.
We didn't know what to expect at our first visit to the Four Seasons replacement. Music was a little strange but quieted down a bit as the tables filled up. Pool area is pretty without the former trees. Tables spaced out nicely. Easy to converse.
First class service, friendly and knowledgable about the menu and preparations.
Started with Tuna with eggplant (skin and smiled purée), grilled octopus (grilled to perfection) and Dungeness crab rice (killer dish, almost ordered it agin for dessert). Main course - shared a large branzino, filleted and grilled perfectly. Sides were terrific- potatoes in duck fat and sesame spinach. Finished with chocolate custard and late harvest tokaj. Sommelier was very helpful and well versed in the extensive wine list. Picked out a great (& reasonable) white Rhone (terrebrune bandol). She was a great asset.
Only hiccup- waiter disappeared after dessert and we had to ask for the check from his assistant/bus boy after waiting 20' for him to return.
Fabulous. I can’t find a single fault other than my empty wallet. They were great. I read all sorts of very picky reviews. Forget that. The Pool isn’t the Grill. They are really doing a great job. The knit pick about the interior design is a distraction from the fundamental well oiled shoppe being run here. And no it’s not the same as the old pool room. Try it you’ll like it.
Had a great experience with a few friends on Saturday night. Service was excellent, atmosphere perfect much quiter than the grill, food was very good. Just be ready for a big bill at the end of the night. But worth going to at least once... btw the cocktails are fantastic....
I was very much looking forward to dining at the pool. When we arrived we were immediately shown to our table. Seating at many of the tables is side by side which is a bit interesting but gives a nice view of the Pool. The space is cavernous which makes it very hard to create the right ambiance. I ordered a bottle of wine and the wine service was first rate. List was very pricey and takes some time to find something reasonable. My guest and I ordered a starter and than we split the Branzino. Her Beet Salad was amazing. Warm Beets in an amazing glaze of spice and sweetness. I had the Gazpacho, nice but needed more soup/sauce for it to work. Fish was amazing along with the spinach side.
The Pool is trying to be a top end restaurant and I just think that they have a ways to go on the experience. While the waite staff was nice there was no excitement or anticipation for what was going to come next. At this level I expect a really cool/amazing experience and the Pool did not deliver.
BTW the Pool bar is super cool and I will definitely go back for a cocktail. Really creative drinks.
We eat out several nights a week and decided to try Pool for my wife’s birthday. Service does not match the decor or the $ 1100 check for 4. First myDover sole was served before other entrees allowing it to cool and dinner style check was delivered while we were eating our deserts diner style saying we can pay when we are ready. 1 of 3 deserts were good. Most of meal ok but not up to top nyc standards. My sole was soupy not firm and not same league as vaucluse for example. Best dish was the raviolis.
I was looking forward to my visit to the Pool. I must admit I was mildly disappointed.
The staff was curt, on the verge of condescending. Food was at best, a B. Wine List was ridiculously over priced. The setting is still special, however, all things considered, I would spend the money at other tried and true favorites in this City.
Very cool vibe, felt like we were in a Tom Ford movie. Bread and salted salmon roe butter were amazing! Our drinks were beautiful and really delicious! (Raspberry cocktail and lemon drop martini). The appetizers were good (beet salad and octopus). Our main entrees were “good” not great (Dover sole and steak) the spinach with sesame seed and the purée sides were really good. I had a princess cake (to share) which was fabulous, felt like something that Marie Antionette would have at her table. We’ll definitely go back but will order different entrees, the rest we will repeat!
Service....made this experience. As a huge fan of Torrisi downtown....I have to say I found the food here a LITTLE disappointing? For example, don’t describe a tuna tartare on a menu without mentioning a raw egg yoke sauce? It made no sense flavor wise and I never would have ordered it. ....Don’t have a “salad” category when none of the choices have anything to do with it?
That said, the experience, thanks to the staff delivered. Beautiful room, great night.
It's just opened recently. So I'll cut them a little slack. Our meal was mixed. The high points were high. The lows, very low. (Had to send back turbot for being criminally over cooked...which seems almost inconceivable for a restaurant based on serving fish). But the pastas were fantastic. Sublime, even. As were the cocktails, wine, and ambiance. Service was excellent as well. And the space, elegant and memorable as always.
I'll be back. But not for a while.
The atmosphere is snobbish, and staff is cold. The food was good, but not worth the price. We had a very wonderful server, Jamison, but the rest of the staff left much to be desired. The prior restaurant "The Four Seasons", was much classier and welcoming. What they have done to the pool is sad. The reeds almost hide the pool, and break up the open floor plan of this beautiful room. I called in advance as I was running late. Although grace period is 15 minutes, I thought I would be 5 minutes past that, and they told me that was fine but they needed the table back by a certain time. When on got there I was again told they needed the table back at a certain time, and were rude. It was not necessary to repeat this and not the way to win me over. I will not be back.
Excellent cuisine but the portion size was a bit small for the price. 42 dollars for 1/2 of a very small lobster seemed a bit much. It was expertly prepared but I couldn’t stop thinking where was the rest of it?
Beautiful space, great waiter, attentive staff.
Pretty good food but service was awful. Our table was not ready for 40 minutes past our reservation time. The hostess directed us towards a side table by The Grill bar but no one greeted us with a menu for over 5 minutes. After we ordered our drinks, the two glasses of wine arrived quickly however the two cocktails did not come until our table was ready (approximately 30 minutes later). We were asked to close out the tab at the bar before we even had our cocktails. And then we were asked if we wanted our change, a polite way to ask if we were going to leave a tip for practically non existent service. Wouldn't it be better to offer to get change and allow the guest decide if they want to leave a tip? At no point did anyone ask to check our coats or offer to carry our drinks from the bar to our table so we were left to navigate a crowded bar with our jackets and full drinks. When we reached our table I noticed that the table next to us also had coats piled up on an empty chair. Our server was very friendly but it was clear that his knowledge of the menu was lacking. Which I can excuse considering the place is still fairly new and it takes time for the FOH staff to learn menus. It took quite some time for the somm to come over and check on the table to see if we wanted any wine. Then when he did come over it took him an awkwardly long time paging through the wine list to find a suitable bottle. Again this is something that I can kinda over look based on the fact that the restaurant is still fairly new and he is still learning the list.
Food was good. Everything was seasoned and cooked nicely. The choice to not list sides on the menu was odd. Also large format dishes meant to be shared really should come with a side. $250 for a cote with no sides is pretty steep. Throwing in some potatoes or vegetables is not going to hurt your food cost very much I promise.
Overall the experience was pretty poor and considering the price, $1200 for 4 people, I won't be back.
when my husband ordered fish they guided him towards the Branzino, which ended up being a $98 entrée for one person.
In addition they charge per person for water so you pay nine dollars plus tax plus tip per person at the table whether or not they drink bottled water.... It is not it's not a lot of money but it's very annoying!!
Perhaps my review is unfair, but I expected a meal in a place like the Four Seasons. What my wife and I received was a meal where the food did not measure up to our expectations. Worse was the hushed dining atmosphere of the Four Seasons has been replaced with pounding-base music that is totally inappropriate for the space. We were disappointed in the food, atmosphere and the high cost of dining.
Food at The Pool is delicious and thoughtfully, skillfully prepared. Every bite is perfect and sometimes surprising. Service is fantastic. Merely look around and someone comes to see what you need, that is, if they have not already anticipated your desire. Our "guide" through the menu and the night was just the right balance of friendly and professional. One sour note. In front of the iconic and beautiful rippling metal "shades" were hanging pots of what looked to be dead plants. I am sure it was intended as a seasonal artsy decoration, but they struck an unpleasant note for me and hid one of the most beautiful elements of the room. Also, our group missed the trees around the pool but we love the Calder mobile there.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.