The Exchange Pub + Kitchen
teres major, herbed balsamic butter, frites, red pepper aioli
garlic, parmesan, red pepper aioli
3d valley beef, fresh herbs, local egg, capriole goat cheese, arugula, brioche roll
10/10, will visit again. The Nashville hot chicken looked amazing (that's what I am ordering next time). Pretzel bread app was really good too.
DJ was our server; she was very nice and helpful when it came to the menu. The pimento Mac and cheese was amazing
Great atmosphere and cocktails. Nice, laid back place to catch up with friends. Food was 50/50—I and another friend enjoyed our meal, the others in our party, not so much. I would definitely recommend.
Great atmosphere. We started with Goat Cheese Fritters, always a winner. Steak was prepared correctly and service was prompt. Special thanks to staff for lighting the firepit. Coffee and dessert to finish.
Disappointed that the steak was tough (so was my chop). It was my son’s first “steak experience” so I hated that it was barely edible. Had my husband tried a bite earlier on, it would have gone back. Oh well.
Food, drinks, and atmosphere were on point! The Salmon dish was amaizing!
Creme Brulee needs work.
We have been twice now to Exchange Pub. Service is wonderful. Ambiance is nice. They have outdoor seating but we opted for inside. Food was really good. We will return.
Birthday for son. Wedge salads arrived at the same time as our food. They changed the iceberg lettuce in the wedge salad to romaine lettuce. Not a true wedge salad. The cauliflower carrot soup looked and tasted like baby food. Very disappointed.
Great place to eat. My wife has a burger which she said was fantastic. I got the wedge salad and fish and chips. Everything was perfect.
Normally, we absolutely love The Exchange, however, there were three negative strikes on this visit. I love the wedge salad and order it on most visits. This time, they seemed to have swapped out the normal bacon bits with the type of bacon you would get on a jar...like Bacos. It was crunchy and fake tasting. Next, my entree arrived and while the fish was hot, the chips were, at best, room temperature and tasted as if they had been sitting for quite some time. Before we left, I made a visit to the women’s restroom. I’ve never seen the restroom this dirty! There was a ring inside the toilet bowl indicating it had not been cleaned in quite some time. The sink area was dirty and there were no paper towels. Honestly, these three things made me wonder if it was under new management as all three were new bad experiences. Our waitress was nice and offered to bring us a dessert when we mentioned the negative experience. We declined. The price point is too expensive to have a sub par restaurant.
Consistently great food for the $. Friendly, mature, no-nonsense servers. Our go to New Albany restaurant.
My water was never refreshed and that’s the only drink I had. Other than that, it was an “okay” experience at the Exchange. Food was tasty.
In an effort to get our food prepared properly, the kitchen head, by her request, sent my order back several times which created a long delay. Food was superb when we were served, and compensation given for our time. I can't wait to go back; food wonderful, service as good as it gets in spite of problem.
This was our “go to restaurant because of their Covid procedures but now Indiana has relaxed their standards and we were packed into the Tavern side.We brought good friends in their ‘80s and realized too late we were not social distancing.Sure hope we got lucky .
Excellent location. Good food. Friendly staff. Very cool old building. Lot's of seating. Lots of drink choices.
service was excellent. nice setting, very relaxed. server was attentive. food was good, but needs to vary menu.
We always love this place. Great atmosphere .. great changing menu. I love the ramen bowel (but would have loved the Brussels sprout / jalapeño / cilantro that is normally in there .. was still great but those extras make it amazing)
We will be back
The Exchange is my favorite restaurant in town. Food is always delicious, fresh and unique, ambience is perfect, and the servers are always awesome.
The Exchange Pub + Kitchen is absolutely one of the best restaurants in New Albany. The service is always top notch. The food is amazing. The atmosphere is always great no matter what day or time.
I like the outside
We are not from Batesville. I found the restaurant on Open Table. It looked interesting so we ate there. The food was excellent...get the pretzel baguette and it was fantastic. The restaurant is in an old stable. It’s very rustic. Our food was excellent. I highly recommend going there.
Great for date night. Not gear toward children. Little pricey but always delicious!
We come almost every other week at least to the exchange. We were running way late tonight because of an over size load truck slowing down traffic the whole way there, but the hosts and manager were super nice about moving our reservation even on a Friday night. The server was fun, let us take our time ordering enjoying a couple drinks. The grocery is ALWAYS my go to, it’s the best mixed drink hands down. The food was great as always. We love the exchange and appreciate their flexibility and kindness as always!
Great local spot. The current summer menu isn’t as good as their normal menu. Looking forward to getting back to that
We sat on the patio. They had live music and it was a gorgeous night. Perfect ambience! We loved the experience. The food was good but nothing to write home about. We had the scallops, brisket, and fish and chips. They were all ok, just not amazing. We did get a wedge salad and pretzel for an appetizer though and they were both outstanding. Our server was amazing and the restaurant is beautiful. We'd definitely go again but get one of the more simple items on the menu, like a sandwich or burger.
Food was delicious and the service was great!
Girl get together
Wasn't thrilled about sitting outside because we were just on the sidewalk not on the patio and we weren't told when we made the reservation that it would be outside. Food was good but not outstanding but it was very reasonably priced. Our server was very sweet but nothing came to the table too quickly.
Great place ! Will be back !
Love the food. The burger is the best around.
My apologies for not remembering my waitresses name but she was friendly and efficient. Nice place, greet vibe, terrific food.
This place is my favorite! Always a great atmosphere
Great experience same as past experiences. Highly recommend making a reservation. First visit back since Covid and the restaurant seems to be taking good precautions.
Great food, table ready when we arrived. Great atmosphere!
Out first time here and it was awesome! Excellent service, excellent food, and excellent atmosphere! The truffle fries were delicious. I had the blended burger and my husband had the po' boy- both excellent! We will definitely be back when we're in the area.
Birthday dinner! It was amazing!
Great food, service, and atmosphere! Highly recommend! Salmon bowl, fish and chips, and cheeseburgers are fantastic.
Consistently one of our favorite places to eat. The Steak Frites are fantastic. They have the best mixed drinks around. The Grocery is one of my favorites. Great wait staff too. Large outdoor seating area and open bar too.
You can order delivery directly from The Exchange Pub + Kitchen using the Order Online button. The Exchange Pub + Kitchen also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (812) 948-6501.
The Exchange Pub + Kitchen is rated 4.8 stars by 677 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.