The Butcher and Barrel
Book your next event with us
Valentine's Prix Fixe Menu Dinner for Two$99.00 per person
Feb 11 - Feb 14, 2022$99 Valentine's Dinner for Two! Optional Prix Fixe Dinner Friday, 2/11-Monday, 2/14 First Course – Choose One to Share Burrata Bruschetta Lump Crab Cakes Second Course – Choose One Each Grilled Caesar Criolla Chopped Salad Clam and Chorizo Chowder Third Course – Choose One Each Filet Mignon Horseradish and Mustard Smashed Redskin Potatoes, Chimichurri Grilled Salmon Warm Heirloom Tomato and Fennel Salad, Lemon-Tarragon Aioli Choice of Three Empanadas Chicken Salsa Verde, Buffalo Chicken, Korean BBQ, Ground Beef, Spinach and Mozzarella Served with Bacon-Brussels Sprouts
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Homemade gnocchi with spinach in a creamy truffle sauce
Our take on an Argentine classic with braised short rib, crispy bacon, fried egg, caramelized onions, tomato confit, roma crunch lettuce, and chimi mayo on homemade ciabatta bread
Food was delicious and well priced. Service was excellent! We got a bottle of champagne and never had to fill our own glasses. The only thing missed was I put in my reservation that it was our anniversary and they didn’t mention it. Would have been nice to have a little congratulations. No big deal though!
Food was awesome! Great flavoring on the steak. We both enjoyed our date night and were very happy with Ethan our server and the food was amazing. We ordered the steak dinner for two. Ribeye was good but I think next time we’ll get the porterhouse. Definitely recommend!
Great dinner and service. It was definitely not what we expected. It is not an ordinary steakhouse. We loved the Argentinian style flavors and didn’t realize the Italian influences on that style. We are looking forward to returning.
Has a great time at the Butcher and Barrel. Nikki’ was our server and she was attentive and provided excellent service. Food was excellent and ambience great for our group
Absolutely Wonderful! When we visit Cincinnati again, we will definitely eat here. The service was spectacular too. .ask for Crystal!
New Years menu was delicious and a great value. Our server, Ethan, was fantastic.
Great experience - the barrel-aged cocktails were delicious. Korean bbq empanada was our favorite. We had the parillada for 2 - a ton of delicious grilled food.
Server was awesome and the food was delicious!!
Went for my daughters 18th bday. It was wonderful! Keep in mind it is almost better to order and share. Empanadas are amazing. Brussels sprouts superb. Gnocchi delish, spare ribs yum! 6 of us split 1/2 salad!
Best skirt steak in Cincinnati. Would recommend it to everyone.
Good experience, considering covid has changed dining out entirely. Great server.
The food and service were absolutely fantastic! We enjoyed great food and wine and simply had an amazing evening. I would definitely recommend The Butcher and Barrel!
Food and service (waitress and even trainee) was great. Would recommend - a nice change of pace. Short rib gnocchi, empanadas, and pirogi were all great. Ambiance was fun and relaxed; noise level low enough to be able to talk. Swivel chairs were cool but a little awkward when sitting at the table. Bar tender was just ok.
Great dinner date. Able to have conversation while waiting. Food was really good. Get the strip!
We had a great time, enjoyed the food and atmosphere! I would recommend it!
Very quiet and nice restaurant. Service by our waiter Tanner was amazing! Very attentive and the salad was amazing!
needed meal quickly to attend movie. served and finished on time
Given the circumstances our server was very professional and attempting to make the best of the situation. The chef walked out which you might imagine caused quite the disruption.
Probably will be some time before we try this venue out again.
We loved the environment. Delicious food superior service.
This place is great. The food is phenomenal. We decided to eat dinner here before going to The Arnoff. Our waiter Jeremy was amazing. He knew the menu and had great recommendations for us. My friend and I shard the experience for 2. The amount of food you get is enough for 3. The meat is so flavorful and just delicious. The brussel sprouts are a must try. And the Gnocchi, oh my goodness best I have ever had. We also tried the Korean Beef and Spinach and Mozzarella Empanadas, so good. Great food and a Great experience! I will definitely be going back!
Very accommodating for my food allergies, great night!
Great place! Loved the ambiance. Service was impeccable. The bruschetta was delicious. Steaks were a little undercooked but still all the food was good. We all walked away full and happy.
Food generally ok but steak fries were had what tasted like way to much cayenne pepper on them and the breaded chicken dish was burnt.
Attentive wait staff. Salmon was excellent
Terrific food Terrific service.
Our friends recommended us to go here for a double date and did not disappoint! We had the bruschetta, mozzarella cheese deep, steak fries and a trio meat dish that I do not recall and a side of mac and cheese and their gnocchi. To say we were full afterwards is an understatement. Everything was amazing, the gnocchi and bruschetta were my favorite but the mac n cheese was high up there. The meats were cooked exactly how we told our waitress, Dee, to which she took very good care of us! Thank you for an amazing experience!
Food was average and wait time for salads and dinner was a bit longer than hoped.
A birthday celebration. The service was slow . We have to ask for plates, utensils, napkins, the steak was tough. The value was not worth the money
The food was okay we had a very long wait…
Steak was extremely tough and not seasoned. They were out out majority of empanadas by 6:30 pm. First time, last time visit.
We had a great experience double dating prior to the USA V Mexico game. I love that it is casual enough for a pregame spot while still feeling like a nice date night dinner.
Empanadas were amazing!
Good was amazing and service was great! Would absolutely recommend.
Our group thought the service was great and the ambiance was perfect for talking and comfortable. Food was good and not too overpriced
Food was amazing! Our waiter was attentive, friendly and fast. Staff very welcoming and friendly.
Per usual we had a very pleasant dinner at the Butcher & Barrel. Both the food and the service were outstanding. Highly recommend!
Short ribs were delightful!
The service was exceptional. Our waiter was great and the food delicious.
Delicious food and perfect service. We will be back again. We explained to our waiter that we needed to be at the Aronoff in time for our show and he made certain that everything ran on schedule. We had a delicious meal, thank you!
Birthday celebration. Our waitress, Dee, was excellent. Made out meal truly special!
The Butcher and Barrel offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (513) 954-8974.
The Butcher and Barrel is rated 4.5 stars by 751 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.