About That Meetball Place - Farmingdale
That Meetball Place is a place to "Meet" and have a "Ball!!" We capture the essence of a family gathering while serving many different varieties of delicious meatballs. We also offer vegetarian and gluten free "meatball" options as well as weekly specials.
We have something for everyone along with Vegan and Gluten Free options!
Looking for brunch Sunday, we have it!!! Serving amazing dishes along with $3 Bloody Marys and Mimosas.....how can you go wrong?
MEETBALL Mondays!! Every Monday we offer "All You Can Eat Meatballs" for $19.95 ....comes with pasta and a TMP side salad!
That Meetball Place has the BEST HAPPY HOUR deals in Farmingdale with
1/2 price craft taps, 1/2 price select wines and 1/2 price well drinks!
We have long Islands hottest bands and D.J's every weekend rocking out with our guests.... GET DOWN HERE and party with us and have a "Ball"
Farmingdale, NY 11735
Hours of Operation:
Monday-Thursday 11:00am-11:00pm (Bar open until 12:00am)
Friday and Saturday 11:00am-1:00am (Bar open until .....)
Sunday 10:00am-11pm (Bar open until 12:00am)
S. Front St.
$30 and under
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Live entertainment scheduled weekly featuring Long Island's hottest acoustic acts and biggest bands. Check our calendar on our website: thatmeetballplaceli.com to see what great bands will be performing here weekly!
Follow us on Facebook "That Meetball Place Farmingdale" to stay up to date with all our exciting events and parties we host.
We have options for all events on or off premises.
Please call for details.
Want a different look for your event?
Ask about hosting your event on our outdoor patio!
Street parking and parking in the rear of the restaurant . Please feel free to use our back door entrance.
Short walk to long Island Rail Road
Private Party Facilities:
Let us cater your event big or cozy, call Melissa for information.
TMP Underground is a modern day speakeasy. A private room below the hustle and bustle of That Meetball Place where you and your VIP guests can meet and have a ball.
Your party will be treated to a special chef's menu offered exclusively at TMP Underground. Step back in time and enjoy the private, intimate atmosphere in our vintage-inspired lower-level dining room complete with a peep-hole entry door and seating for up to 18 people around an oversized communal table. You can customize your experience with access to our entertainment center including large screen TV and state-of-the-art sound system.
Private Party Contact:
Melissa Zuniga: (516) 586-8880
Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Beer Garden, Cocktails, Dancing, Entertainment, Full Bar, Gluten-free Menu, Happy Hour, Late Night, Non-Smoking, Outdoor dining, Private Room, Weekend Brunch, Wheelchair Access, Wine
That Meetball Place - Farmingdale Ratings and Reviews
The service was very slow. The waiter announced the wrong dishes which caused a mix up. The food came out at different times leaving some dishes cold as we waited for the entire table to be served. The toddler dish was served last. It took 20 minutes to receive desert after it was ordered and when it was received the gelato was melted. There was not compensation offered for any issues.
The food was pretty good, nothing special but good. Everything else was pretty much bad. I have been to their Patchogue location and was pretty happy. That location has a large bar area, and a more secluded dining room. This location also has a large bar area, and a dining loft upstairs. However, the dining room is not separated enough from the bar, making the noise level way too loud for dinner. I could not talk to my wife sitting across from me (note, I'm in my 20s and not hard of hearing). Throughout the dinner, the bus boy hovered and lurked over tables to remove dirty dishes and silverware. At one point, he took my wife's plate off the table while she was taking a bite of her meatball slider. He reached for my plate and silverware as I was taking my last bite of my meal as well. Then, while we were waiting for the check, they turned on flashing colored lights that shone directly on our table and were obnoxious and headache inducing. Won't be back.
Way too loud. We made dinner reservations and arrived at the kind of scene I’d expect at a rowdy nightclub, not a gastro pub. They even IDed us and made us get stamped on our hands before letting us in for our reserved table. I honestly thought we had arrived at the wrong place. The hostess was extremely nice and seated us quickly, but the tables were tiny and cramped, and the noise level was unbearable (not to mention the seriously outdated music playing on volume 99 over the speakers) We wound up getting a drink and then leaving to go have dinner elsewhere.
Came here as a group for brunch. The service was wonderful, our waitress was great.
The French toast skillet, flatbread, and pretzel were all really good. The chicken waffle meatballs and my eggs and hash were bland.
Overall, although the service was great, I don't think we'll be eating here again.
We were here for an early dinner on Saturday night. We sat in the bar area, which was a bit loud, but not crazy-loud. We enjoyed our meatballs and zucchini noodles. We each got a different meatball so we were able to share. The chicken parmesan meatballs were really good. Looking forward to returning.
This was my first time at That Meetball Place. I was very pleasantly surprised. The food was out of this world. Italian, but better than most "neighborhood" Italian restaurants. The choices were new and fresh and attractively plated. The salad we had was "picture perfect". The red red tomato pieces on the very fresh romaine and the rest of the ingredients were not only fresh but very colorful. Dressing was just right. Not too vinegary. I had meatballs served over ravioli served on a board with a skillet. Different. The sauce was outrageous. Loved it! The meatballs were seasoned to perfection. My friend had a huge plate of chicken meatballs over penne. Yum! Our waitress was delightful and the service was outstanding. We definitely will be back. We have touted the restaurant to our friends because we were so impressed. Maybe because we are "seniors" it was a bit noisy for us and difficult to have a conversation, but we plan on coming back regardless. The food was too good to miss!
Overall oit first visit was very good. The Brooklyn Barrata was good as were the meetballs in my sampler. Classic, Buffalo Chicken and Lobster Risotto. We also has the Spicy Risotto side.
We sat upstairs where the noise level was tolerable, still pretty loud. Our server Tami was great !! I expect to return
The food was great and the price was reasonable. We went on a Friday evening when they had live music. The music was so loud that you couldn't hear people at your table. We also felt the service was lacking. My party was seated for a long time before a server came and acknowledged our table. Once our food came we never saw them again. We would definitely go back to try the place again but probably would be selective of the night we went.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.