Celebrate Mom the way she deserves with brunch specials from 11-2!
Regular Dinner Menu available from 11am-8pm
Sunday, May 13, 2018
Been there several times, wasn't disappointed. Our waiter Keith was a delight,professional and attentive to our table. Steak under cooked and charred. That was my only let down, overall Keith made the dinner worth the trip, everyone had a good time
Tellers is definitely our go to restaurant when we have a sitter! We always feel like we are treated as family, the food is always amazing and the servers are probably the best at any restaurant we have been at!!
Overpriced and rushed service while eating average food in a restored bank building...not my idea of fine dining...
Food had to be sent back, steaks weren't cooked enough. The waiter told us it would be 45 minutes to an hour until are steak would be done. Ordered are steak medium, and it came out purple ten minutes after ordering. Waiter didn't serve our sides onto our plates like we saw other waiters doing. Just not what we expected for the price. Service should have been better and more accommodating.
Once again we had another great experience at Tellers. We dined there this past Saturday evening. The service was outstanding, the food phenomenal and the atmosphere great.
I would highly recommend to go to Tellers if you want to enjoy a great meal and get treated like royalty.
An Amazing Experience. I have been wanting to try Tellers for quite the longest. I finally decided to take my girlfriend out to dinner. We generally go to upscale restaurants with the occasional average spot once and awhile. We were very impressed with the service, ambiance, and food. From start to finish - we had an extraordinary experience and here is why:
Hostess: Very friendly, organized, and sat us at a perfect table with ample room for the food we ordered.
Wait Staff: Professional, organized, and well communicated. I observed the waiter of ours communicate to certain wait staff individuals - everything was done timely and accurately.
Waiter: Friendly from start to finish. He spoke to us with an occasional joke here or there which brought us to smiles. The waiter explained to us any questions we had, but also recommended which sides to get and what entree.
Food: Appetizers were crab cakes and 3oz stone crab. Crab cakes were delicious and cooked to perfection. 3oz Stone crab was meaty and cracked accordingly. I prefer hot drawn butter next time, which Im sure they would have accommodated. Main dishes were Prime Rib Medium Rare and the Sole. Wow, Prime Rib was a 20oz cooked medium rare as requested with a delicious au jus gravy. Sole was cooked perfectly and gobbled up by the gf. Sides were Scalloped Parmesan Potatoes and Mac and Cheese. Absolutely one of the best mac and cheeses I have ever had and we go out every day for lunch and dinner. Potatoes were tasty as well. Lastly, the Brooklyn Cheesecake was good, not as good as my cheesecake sorry! Had a Red from California - great choice and the gf had a Sauvignon Blanc - great. Wine glasses were real crystal and to me and other wine connoisseurs this is a big deal.
Overall. This is the place to visit. Great food, great service, great ambiance, great experience! Thanks Tellers.
My salmon was over cooked but they made me a new dish and it was perfection
Food was great, service was awesome,, good place to celebrate an occasion, love this place.
The food and service at Teller's is always top notch. We always enjoy a wonderful meal there.
A delicious dinner. The Signature Rib Eye is a steak not to be missed. Lobster Thermidor another great choice. Service impeccable. Lisa was attentive and was knowledgeable concerning the menu. Chris at the bar was was professional and friendly. Thank you all for a great evening.
Went there for my Birthday dinner. Everything was amazing! Baked clams were so flavorful, the Filet Mignon Wellington was to die for! It was cooked perfectly as was my husband's Ribeye. We received excellent service from Steve, he was right on top of things and a pleasure to have serve us. I ordered the desert that was on special that night which consisted of strawberry mouse with a Meringue topping, it was like eating a cloud, so delicious! We were informed by our waiter that desert was on them for my Birthday! Not only that, they gave us a gift card for our next visit. We had an awesome meal and I'm SO glad that I chose Tellers to celebrate my special occasion.
Excellent food and service as usual, porterhouse for 2 was amazing the Irish Coffee may have been the best I ever had
It was my birthday and they treated me royally. I was totally surprised to receive a free dessert and a gift card - a wonderful experience
Our server Ray was knowledgeable, professional, and prompt. We never waited for anything. Great food, great service, great night.
The steak was fine as were the sides. The service was excellent. There were two disappoiintments: the french fries in duck fat were soft and limp rather than crispy. They must have been cooked much earlier. They had no Beefeater Gin for a martini. I was told by the waiter that everyone drinks vodka now. No, not everyone.
My husband and I dined for the first time on Sunday for dinner. The server was quick and very on top of anything we needed. The food was AMAZING! and I could believe how great the prices were. We will definetly be coming back!
Food was very good overall. My brother and I both ordered a 12 oz fillet cooked medium. His was medium. Mine was more medium-well, but still tasty. We ordered the bacon and the stuffed clam appetizers, both delicious.
The ambience was really cool, the restaurant is in an old bank, Hence the name “Tellers”. They even have a wine room located in the old vault.
Biggest complaint was stuffy service. Professional but not too friendly. I prefer a little friendliness, others may disagree. Overall good experience, I would recommend.
Great dinner and drinks!! We had such a great date night!!
Excellent as always.
My girlfriend had the Branzino which was great. Sweet, moist, not wet. Delicious. I had the NY Strip steak, medium. Seared on the outside and layered on the inside. Brown, pink then pinkish red. Side dishes were burnt broccoli and sweet potatoe bruelle. Wow. Which went well with the Pinot Noir from Oregon. Our waiter Bill, was attentive, personalible.
I've never been disappointed with a meal at Tellers.
Love coming here for special occasions! I wish I could eat here more often. Food has always been great, steaks are incredible, have never had a bad meal here.
We have dined here several times over the years and enjoy it every time. Great food, Great service! Highly Recommend!
Kevin was our captain. He truly made our dining experience wonderful. Lisa has been with Tellers for 19 years and for good reason. She wants all guests to be happy with there dining experience. I haven’t been going for awhile but I’m so happy I went back
Tellers never fails to deliver and deliver exceptionally, you can not go wrong here!
We had a wonderful meal. William L was a fantastic server and made sure we were well taken care of. He even gave us a complimentary dessert for my birthday. Overall a wonderful experience and we will be back!
What an excellent experience!!!
I always enjoy Tellers! Food was fantastic and service was great.
Celebrating friends 20th anniversary. Food was superb!
Jimmy has been an excellent host and I will miss him tremendously. I wish him well on his journey.
Husband & neighbor ate over discussing business. They left happy & full.
Three of our party had never been to Teller's before, and everyone was very impressed with the building, the service and the food. We had a lovely, relaxing dinner.
Disappointed in service- we waited 45 mins before even asked for apps, that would of been ok if we were all out of drinks as well!!!!!
Had to ask a server to get our waitress.
Noisy but delicious
We have been dinning at this restaurant for dinner several times. We average 15 to 20 visits a year each time is better than the last. Excellent steaks. Look forward to next visit.
Fine dining in a refined atmosphere. Excellent attractive service. Quite pricey but worth a splurge.
An outstanding steakhouse. Porterhouse for two is an excellent choice.
Mom and daughter lunch out! The service was fantastic as always I was especially grateful that the servers help ing my mom with her lobster dish
As always, our favorite go to steakhouse!
Excellent food and service. Music from the bar did not suit our top level dining experience.
This is one of my favourite places to eat and the food is great, my only problem on this day was my husband had taken me there for my birthday back in January and it was very nice of them to give me a gift card as a gift to use at another date the only thing is the limits they set on this card is crazy they really should just not give them out. We went for lunch thinking it would be a good time to use it but because a person in our group ordered from the price fixed menu they would not let me use it.
My favorite place in the islips