Join us for Easter! Celebrate with brunch specials from 12-3. Enjoy specials and our regular menu for Dinner!
Sunday, April 1, 2018
See availability for bonus point tables
Sat 5:00PM - 5:30PM 9:00PM - 11:00PM
Amazing sums it all up. Service and food is impecible. If i could eat there every day, i would.
Always a satisfying meal and professional service
Food was absolutely delicious. Drinks were exceptional. Staff was fantastic. We cannot wait to come back!
The food is always very good and they have a good wine list. The staff is pleasant and attentive but not overbearing.
The atmosphere is very good with a contrast between the warm wood paneled bar/ lounge area and the main dining room, a converted early 20th century bank building, which features high ceilings and long tall windows. The bar/lounge has some seating for dinner with the area by the gas fireplace being great for more intimate meals. The main dining room with its open architecture is better for dining with larger groups and for occasions where being out among your fellow diners is part of the attraction.
I have often taken family members and friends to Tellers for events and celebrations and they are suitably impressed.
The wait staff is top notch. We were greeted by the manager and he came over table to be sure we were well taken care of. The food was great, however, the appetizer choices need more non-fish selections on the pre-fixe menu. I only could choose the pepper bacon which really was more of a short rib than bacon.
Great food service and ambiance
The service here is unbelievable, food was good. Pricey, but you get what you pay for
The service was absolutely amazing! The food was great and the wine was also amazing. I would definitely recommend the fried calamari as an appetizer. Also the steaks were very well cooked and had such great flavor!!
We arrived 5 minutes late of our reservation so we had to wait for a table to open up. It was perfectly fine with us as we went to hang out at the bar and have a drink while we waited. The hostess actually walked in the bar to get me cause our table was ready. She remembered who I was which was very nice. Then while at the table the wait staff was great. Very attentive and helpful. The food was superb. The only thing we skipped out on was dessert and that even looked great as we kept seeing the other tables order dessert. Definitely would go back!!
This restaurant never disappoints. From the time you walk in to the time you leave all staff members are polite and on point. The food is always good and cooked as ordered. We will certainly be back !!
Always a great meal and excellent service. Great wine menu
Tellers is always a special treat! The service and food are amazing. Our go to is the Delmonico steak, it’s amazing. For sides, you can’t go wrong with the mashed potatoes or burnt broccoli.
The service at this restaurant is superb and the ambience is elegant. We shared a baked clams appetizer and a 20-oz prime rib with burnt broccoli (sounds awful but it's great) and mushrooms with carmelized onions (perfect for the meal) and it was more than sufficient. Steak was cooked precisely to our liking. Prices are high, but it's a good place to consider for a special occasion.
Great meal, excellent service only downfall was other patrons. Group of six came in highly intoxicated, loud and belligerent kept dropping F'bomb with families eating early dinner on Saturday night in second floor dining room. Our waiter did the best he could to intervene and quiet them down which we thanked him for repeatedly. Kind of a let down for nice evening out celebrating an anniversary.
Tellers - thank you for always making our food perfect, drinks perfect and most importantly our everyday take out dining or special occasions excellent. Always happy!
Steaks cooked to perfection. Large portions of duck fat fries (delicious house mustard and ketchup) and asparagus was perfectly grilled. Even the coffee was very good. Loved it!!!
Great table adjacent to fireplace. Food and service were excellent. Friendly and courteous staff from entrance to exit. Thank you John snd Tomas for your attentive and courteous service. And thank you Joseph For the incentive to return! Thank you for a memorable birthday dinner experience.
Great food, outstanding service , nice atmosphere, parking was a problem, I’ve been there before and there was a Valet service
Adam is a terrific waiter. He is one of the most attentive waiters Ive encountered. He is always on top of things.The main dining room was cool. The thermostat could have been turned up a notch. It was evident when you saw many women with coats around their shoulders. The steak I had was sent back as it was not medium well. It came back cooked more on the outside than on the inside but everything else with the meal was fine. Tellers is still my favorite steakhouse on Long Island.
Sunday prix fix menu is a great deal and totally worth it! Great service, great food.
Overall a good meal. Went with the Price Fixed course and all the food tasted great. Lobster bisque was lacking in lobster and was mostly just a soup but tastey otherwise. Food pretty pricey but a good experience if you want a fine night out.
Amazing service and food!
Very nice, hâd a very good time
As usual the service was excellent, Food was Fantastic and our waitress was great. Nothing but bravos about this place. Manager came over to table ( We took our daughter there for her Birthday) presented her with a Birthday gift card and wised us all well, Was our 55 th wedding anniversary same day as her birthday.Very good evening.
Great all around
Kept us waiting 40 minutes beyond our reservation time. Very cramped. Too many tables too close together. They raised the prices Side dishes way overpriced. Had to ask for water glasses to be refilled.
I am a long time patron of Tellers and have never had an experience like this. It was busy. I had 7 pm reservations and I arrived at 6:30 to have a cocktail. We were not seated until 7:45. We were left sitting at table with menus for half hour. We finally ordered and had been sitting over an hour before appetizers appeared. The lobby was crowded beyond the capacity.
The side of scalloped potatoes were so over powered by oregano I couldn’t eat it. The lobster Mac and cheese was not Tellers standards. The steak as usual was the best!
I love Tellers and will return it was just a disappointing evening. Wish someone would have asked how dinner was but the front of the house staff were just too busy.
Extrememy pricey, but great food and experience. Noise level was high since it was crowded for a weekend dinner time.
ANAZING AMAZING AMAZING! Our waiter Keith P went above and beyond and was so wonderful! The food was out of this world! Would def recommend and already told everyone they need to go eat here!
Excellent service from Chris. Overall wonderful evening!
As always a wonderful meal and time at Teller's, which makes this a favorite for us. Besides Teller's we have yet to find another restaurant on the island or around the world that can give us both excellent 5 star service while providing a delicious meal - a very difficult balance to strike. We will be back for more. <3
We had a lovely dinner at Tellers, as usual. We both had the Beef Wellington, which is our favorite dish on the menu. We had reserved a special table by the fireplace, but when we arrived we were told a private party was sitting in that area, so we couldn’t have the requested table. They were not due to arrive for 1-1/2 hours, so we said that we would be finished. The hostess said she had to ask her boss if they was ok. I said fine, we would be having a drink at the bar and to come and let us know. She never came to tell us, so we had dinner at the bar with a wonderful young man named Keith. He made us two great cocktails, and then we had as I said the Beef Wellington with a side of delicious grilled asparagus. We also had two great glasses of red wine with dinner. All was delicious. Tellers is a little on the pricey side. Luckily we had a 50 dollar gift card. Even with the gift card, with tip the meal was around 125 dollars. But it was still worth it. We will be returning soon.
Amazing dinner at Tellers as usual. Everything as expected, was perfect. Our waiter Steve was phenomenal. Certainly on the higher side for the price, but it’s worth it and never a disappointment. Can’t wait to return...
It was very upsetting that they made a big deal about us bring our own wine.
I wanted to dine at Teller's for a long time. Finally went last night for my birthday. I was disappointed! I didn't realize there were two levels and I'm very glad we were seated upstairs. The lower level was very crowded and noisy. Upper level was cozy.
I ordered a Grey Goose martini at the bar and for dinner I ordered the Kumamoto oysters, filet mignon with au poivre sauce (served on the side - they don't press the pepper on the steak), garlic mashed potatoes, onion rings, and french fries fried in duck fat for the table.
Here is my review:
- The martini didn't really taste like there was any vodka in it.
- The oysters were fabulous.
- The filet mignon was a little tough, even though it was medium rare, and the au poivre sauce was extremely bland.
- The fries tasted like frozen fries.
- The onion rings tasted like onion rings.
- The garlic mashed potatoes were good.
Not worth the money. There are many other steak houses far superior on Long Island.
Great service . Sat by the fireplace . The calamari and baked clams were delicious.
Wonderful evening. The service was wonderful as was the food. Had the prime rib of beef and beef Wellington. Beef Wellington was good as always however , the prime rib was the best I ever had. Flavorful, tender and cooked to perfection. Appetizers of Bacon and shrimp n lobster wontons delish as were the sides of sweet potato brûlée n onion rings
Great place! Service, food and surrounding were just perfect! Our waiter Eric was fantastic! A must go for anyone wanting a great meal and time.
Great as always
As always it was a great !! John our waiter is wonderful . He knows what he is talking about when it comes the food wine the whole dining experience . Will only sat at tables John waits on
Thanks again for a great night