Mermaid Inn Upper West Side

De reviews over Mermaid Inn Upper West Side van mensen die hier hebben gegeten. Gebaseerd op recente beoordeling.

1. A

   Alan vip

   New York City311 recensies

   5.0

   1 dag geleden gegeten

   1. Algeheel 5
   2. Eten 5
   3. Bediening 5
   4. Sfeer 5

   With the outdoors spaces opened up, it seems like a thousand diners are happily yakking and eating and drinking at once. It’s all quite well organized, and service is efficient. The food is excellent, standouts being steak (surprisingly), octopus and butterflied whole fish. Always order the tempura string beans as soon as you sit down—really nice for group nibbling while enjoying drinks and waiting for first course (but tell them to hold the salt, it’s not necessary and they use too much).
   

   Is dit nuttig?

2. L

   Lynn

   New York City1 recensie

   5.0

   1 dag geleden gegeten

   1. Algeheel 5
   2. Eten 5
   3. Bediening 5
   4. Sfeer 5

   Wonderful restaurant with delicious food, great service and outdoor seating!
   

   Is dit nuttig?

3. D

   David vip

   New York City21 recensies

   4.0

   1 dag geleden gegeten

   1. Algeheel 4
   2. Eten 4
   3. Bediening 4
   4. Sfeer 4

   we sat outside and it was. a beautiful night the food was very good and the service was friendly, it was very enjoyable and also would be good for a group
   

   Is dit nuttig?

4. N

   Natalie vip

   New York City14 recensies

   5.0

   4 dagen geleden gegeten

   1. Algeheel 5
   2. Eten 5
   3. Bediening 5
   4. Sfeer 5

   The restaurant was packed on a Wednesday night -- which just goes to show you how good it is. Mermaid Inn is a welcome addition to Columbus Ave in the 70s. The menu has a great selection. The food, as always, was delicious.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

5. M

   Michael vip

   New York City14 recensies

   5.0

   6 dagen geleden gegeten

   1. Algeheel 5
   2. Eten 5
   3. Bediening 5
   4. Sfeer 4

   For as busy as it is, service was incredible. Food is always good. The octopus special was on the cusp of being overdone, nearly tough to chew, but just steered clear of that. Oysters and the main dishes great as always. You really want a seafood place that is busy - worst thing is having seafood sitting for days - and Mermaid Inn is packed and doesn’t disappoint.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

6. J

   Jackie

   New York City25 recensies

   3.0

   6 dagen geleden gegeten

   1. Algeheel 3
   2. Eten 3
   3. Bediening 4
   4. Sfeer 4

   I love this place. The happy hour foods are well priced and mostly tasty. I didn't love the Tuna Crudo but not sure why. The shrimp cocktail had to be sent back as the shrimps were about 1 day too old. The linguini was good. Overall good meal- not outstanding. The little neck clams were good Lots of dogs at the outside tables which was great! Service was really good considering how busy they were!
   

   Is dit nuttig?

7. H

   Heather

   Unspecified1 recensie

   1.0

   7 dagen geleden gegeten

   1. Algeheel 1
   2. Eten 4
   3. Bediening 2
   4. Sfeer 2

   We made a reservation for 2:30pm. At 2:35 they said it was last call for food and drinks and we hadn’t even looked at the menu. If you close at 2:30 then don’t take a reservation at 2:30. We didn’t know. They rushed the food. Put the entrees out before the appetizers. I mean the burger came out before the oysters. What the actual?! Never again
   

   Is dit nuttig?

8. K

   Kevin vip

   New York City149 recensies

   4.0

   7 dagen geleden gegeten

   1. Algeheel 4
   2. Eten 5
   3. Bediening 5
   4. Sfeer 5

   All was great except: $10 for bread. Been a mermaid customer for years. They used to provide a free pot de crème at the end of dinner. Now that’s gone and you have to pay for bread. What happened? Doesn’t give a great feeling at the end.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

9. D

   Dan

   New York City3 recensies

   3.0

   Gegeten op 26 april 2025

   1. Algeheel 3
   2. Eten 3
   3. Bediening 3
   4. Sfeer 3

   Unfortunately the expensive lobster roll was fishy. The fries and the oysters were excellent. The pudding is delicious but shame on the restaurant for putting too much whipped cream. Sneaky.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

10. S

    Sandra vip

    New York City2 recensies

    5.0

    Gegeten op 25 april 2025

    1. Algeheel 5
    2. Eten 5
    3. Bediening 5
    4. Sfeer 5

    Overall a treat! Charles made our experience top notch and super enjoyable, give him a raise!
    

    Is dit nuttig?