Tally's Silver Spoon
Tally's Silver Spoon is a family-friendly eatery, open for breakfast, lunch and dinner, that offers globally inspired cuisine made from fresh, local products and ingredients. Located in Rapid City, South Dakota, Tally's Silver Spoon is a family owned and operated establishment that offers happy hour specials, a wine list and live entertainment.
On the menu at Tally's Silver Spoon, customers can find a wide variety of breakfast, lunch and dinner choices. Breakfast consists of pancakes, French toast, waffles, egg dishes and French omelets. Lunch offers gluten free options and features grilled choices of chicken breast, Buffalo steak and Black Hills Buffalo burger. Other menu items include pasta, chicken fried steak, autumn oak pheasant and pumpkin porcini chicken.
Bison Maytag Marsala Mushroom
Curried Mussels Rouille
Roasted rep pepper, saffron, coconut, curry broth, crostini rouille
Butter Bathed Halibut
Apple salad, potato risotto, beet tartare, apple cider reduction
The menu is interesting, with lots of options. Our waiter Daniel was excellent, with great recommendations and honest feedback. I only wish we had discovered this place before the last night of our vacation. Loved it!
Bad service. Took a long to be acknowledged while waiting at the front. Table rarely got cleared despite them dropping off the next meal. Pastas were bland. Just bad experience.
Excellent food and excellent service!
We loved Tally’s! The service was amazing, food was good, and my husband and I had a great date night.
A wonderful dinner and surprise. I have not visited Rapid in quite some time and was impressed with this unique menu with great flavor combinations. Not just meat and potatoes. The mushroom-of-the day appetizer was sublime (and huge), but could have been dinner for this mushroom lover. The pork tacos were everything you would expect in a good taco! My husband loved the Donald and Porky, but couldn't finish it due to the generous portion sizes. Great wine list and we ordered the special pinot of the night. Outstanding service from our server, Jeff, who was knowledgable and professional. Our only disappointment was that Pork and Pinot was sold out. But, we made our own!
First Time at Tally. Bison Burger outstanding.
My husband had mushroom soup and large hamburger which he praised repeatedly. I tried the spicy vegetable linguini, loved it and was able to take half of it home as the portion was so generous. The chef really knows how to flavor the food- so good! Such a varied menu. I would recommend Tally's Silver Spoon to everyone.
Visiting from Tennessee for a few days and read about this place. Don’t be afraid to try the Indecision Menu. Our party of four did and it was fabulous. Well worth it. We did the four course and it was plenty of delicious food. A great experience overall.
The Kale salad was outstanding! Great food and excellent service!
Terrific food. Wonderful service.
The food was on point….everything from the black bean soup, mushroom crostini’s , melon and arugula salad and the rueben were as close to perfect as we could have imagined! A real gem right downtown!
Good food. Very slow service and not that busy.
Servers were respectful and on top of it! Food was absolutely amazing as always! Highly recommend
Every dish we ordered featured unique flavors and imaginative touches. We raved about each one. Service was excellent...attentive and knowledgeable. The only downside is this is a beer and wine only place, so our guests were not able to enjoy the cocktail they had hoped to have with dinner. Oh well. Food more than made up for that minor disappointment.
Tally’s is the best New American fare in RC and perhaps all of SD. The only thing I was disappointed about was that I couldn’t decide between so many good options! Do not miss this gem!!
We were on a trip from chicago. Based on a recommendation we visited this establishment. It has a cafe vibe to it but the waitstaff is top notch. The dishes were okay but definitely overpriced. Quality of the food was there but the taste was lacking something. The highlight of the visit was the happy hour which was buy one wine the second one was free, regardless.
We wouldn’t go back.
Food and service is always fantastic at Talley's. When I booked the reservations I requested a window seat. Granted I am aware that always can't be accommodated. My frustration was when we arrived we were seat in front of the entrance in an inner table. Shortly after we arrived a window seat became available so I asked to be relocated. The hostess said no because he already moved someone seated at the table we were at to a window seat. I reminded the hosted that I requested a window seat and he said he couldn't move us to a window seat. I appreciate his honesty but rather had not known he already move someone from the table we were at to a window seat but not willing to move us. Fair is fair. The young hostess perhaps needs more customer service training. Again service and food is always excellent and we will go again.
We made our reservation, and noted that we were both celiac. Waiter was very knowledgeable on what was gluten free. Service was great, food tasted good. Very sick (gluten side effects) the next day. On the day we ate there, we made breakfest and lunch with ingredients we had both eaten before with no ill effects.
I need to start by saying service anywhere is not good these days. Just have to be very patient with short staffing. Our waitress was stressed and hurried and definitely not friendly until the last few minutes when the restaurant had cleared out. But, we understood. Food was good and there were plenty of choices. Ambiance was very nice. Great wine selection.
awesome service. great food! very attentive to food allergies
We had the indecision menu -4 course and it was amazing. Also finished with peach dessert with port/Prosecco
Food & service were excellent. The decor needs an update. We sat outside which was our preference but there were lots of flies. Don’t know how to solve that. I’d go back if I were in Rapid City again.
Had a nice, 3-course “Indecision Menu” (chef’s tasting menu) with friends. Service was friendly and prompt, the food was nicely presented and delicious, and the red wine pairings were very good but IMO served too warm.
Mussels were Outstanding!!! And HUGE!!! My Bison steak was perfect.
My wife’s experience was not as good. Kampachi main course. The fish was tough!!!
Homemade ice cream was good.
This is such an iconic Rapid City spot. Heart of Downtown with fantastic and unique gourmet food. Server was terrific.
Service was great. Ordered the deer and bison entree. Great mix of flavors and presentation. Deer is not for me at all but everything was on point. Clam chowder dip was very different but good.
The restaurant admitted to being under staffed so we were fine with the long evening. The food and our waiter were great. I can’t imagine any better restaurant in Rapid City. Recommend going!
Was a very good meal. I request an alteration on my plate and they did it. No complaints and had good service
I had the ribeye steak and my wife had the seafood pasta. Both dishes were very good. The service was excellent and the restaurant was very clean. My steak was expensive compared to steak in other restaurants I have frequented, But all things considered it was great food and great service.
A great local favorite with big city feel. Food is amazing and very unique. Don't shy away from ordering the Buffalo. It's delicious and they know how to prepare it! A must stop when in Rapid City
Really enjoyed the Donald and Porky sandwich and sweet potato waffle fries with the yummy sauce. I recommend highly.
Always excellent food and service. Really well trained servers who know the menu and wine offerings. We love Tally’s. The best in Rapid City. Casual fine dining, inventive menu with everything from great burgers to over the top chef created entrees.
Excellent bison and seafood. Service was really great! Ambience was just ok but I would definitely eat her again!
Fantastic food. However we sat for 15 minutes before a server ever came and greeted us. She was great once she arrived! Also we were there 1.5 hours before we received our entrees.
Bison burger was tasty but way too salty. Sweet potato fries were cold and had no flavor. It was a bit overpriced for me for the quality.
Waited too long for out food…when it came it was delicious
Fantastic! We ordered the 4 course tasting menu with wine, which was wonderful. The restaurant was full, but the servers were great.
There are chef indecision course menu, we were excited of what they were.
Those were so delicious , creative and healthy menu.
My husband and I very enjoyed.
We ate there a couple of days ago and loved it. However, last night we waited snd hour and a half for our food, but left before getting it. We were so tired and hungry.
We asked to be reseated outside and they accommodated us. Had excellent waiter. Homemade pasta dish was fantastic. Kale salad was not so great with small portion and bland dressing.
Tally's Silver Spoon is rated 4.6 stars by 182 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.