Restaurants you may also like
(Gluten-Free Menu) (Vegetarian Dishes) (Great for Diet Restrictions)
**Private Dinning Available for parties of 10-15ppl max
Tacos were OK. Nothing wrong with them, but nothing to write home about either. For the price, I would expect something better. Drinks were OK too. Very small ice cubes they use don't leave much room for the drink itself. I would expect more from $12 drink too. Overall we didn't regret going there, but there are many places in the area with better food and higher value. I wish them well, but unlikely they possibly can survive for long.
We had a great casual but delicious dinner! The food was fresh and flavorful. The drinks were all fresh squeezed juices and were wonderful. The service was friendly, prompt and attentive. We love this place!
I have been to Taco Shack a few times and have never been disappointed. It is consistently good.
Been there before. Food is very good. Service was extremely slow on this occasion. However, the waitress was polite about it.
Absolutely love this place. Came here with a colleague for a quick drink and some chips & guacamole. The tacos looked so good I said I will return. The staff was beyond friendly. The drinks here are made from scratch and you can tell the flavor. I ordered a margarita and my friend got a mojito. The tacos at the shack are bomb! They are flavorful and fresh, not greasy like most places where u walk out smelling like tacos. The guac is the best we ever had with real chunks of avocado and the I really like the selection of beer. By wife likes to get the non alcoholic drinks she’s a huge fan of the pineapple crush. Last time I came they had tres leches cake and that hit the spot.
Went to Taco Shack a with low expectations. The food was excellent, service very good. The Margaritas were great. Will definitely go frequently
Guacamole delicious - nice and limey!! Loved our tacos and enchiladas, not to mention margaritas (although they were small). Yummmy!!
We love Taco Shack and bring friends here whenever in the area. The margaritas are wonderful and every bite is simply delicious. We are never disappointed. The staff is friendly and the restauant is very clean. I highly recommend Taco Shack.
Excellent tacos. Great flavor.
Great fresh food at reasonable prices. The fresh juice drinks are great
Server did not get our order correct as it did not come out at the same time. There were only 2 tables there so was surprised she didn’t get the order right. Food was good. Margarita’s were just ok.
Reviews are accurate. The food is great but the service is lacking terribly. A table that came in after us and ordered after us got their meal, ate, paid their check and left all before our meal arrived. The waitress also mislead us on the sausage quesadilla, we asked if spicy she said no but it was so spicy my daughter couldn’t eat it. The food is good and the margaritas are great but expect to have very poor service.
OMG This place is great. Everything was so fresh and tasty. The margarita's are made with fresh squeezed limes. All of the ingredients are fresh. It was just a wonderful experience.
The food was terrific and the margaritas were good!! I Really liked it, but the service is terrible. I saw this in prior reviews, but not better. If you go, order early and often.
I will be getting take out ad having a drink when picking up.
As big fan of Halstead ave taqueria, I was very excited to try this sister restaurant. The food did not disappoint! However, the service left much to be desired. We had a 7:30 reservation and there was no hostess to be found for at least 15 mins. When I asked the bartender about our reservation, she looked very confused as if she didn’t even know what a reservation was and said she’d check. She didn’t. We asked her for margaritas while we waited. Those took 20 mins. They brought one of my friends dinners and the rest of ours took 10 more mins so hers got cold as she waited. I hope the service improves because the food is truly great and I want this restaurant to stay around! I hope they invest in some training and iron out the kinks. I would certainly try it again.
Very friendly, the restaurant has potential, but seems to be enduring some growing pains. Staff seemed to be unprepared for pre-show crush, a number of people walked out after a long wait...
Enchiladas were OK Tacos good, margaritas were unbalanced, too much triple sec & not much tequila.
2nd time dining here. Food has declined since previously. Chicken taco was so dry and hard, inedible. Service was slow! Food took nearly 40 mins for a few tacos.
The tacos had so much flavor. Their homemade sauces were excellent. I loved the fresh squeezed juices and beverages.
The food was decent (aside from the fact that the chorizo taco had a strangely grainy consistency - and I know I got the last one because they told me), but the service (barring the bartender) was abysmal. The waitress took a while to take our order (there were only a couple other tables occupied, so I am not sure what was going on). When our food came out, one person's order was correct, one was incorrect, and one didn't come at all. It took a long time for them to sort it out. When they finally did, it ended up that one of the items had run out (it was 7:50 PM). We ordered a different taco instead, which was quite slow to arrive. When the bill came, it was wrong. When it came time to pay, they ran my card twice. I asked if it was going to go through twice, and was assured it would not. At one point I was saying 'excuse me', to one of the waitresses, trying to get a question answered, and she was completely ignoring me. I checked my card later - it went through twice.
Food was decent, drinks were excellent, but with the variety of Mexican restaurants in the area, I won't be returning to this one due to the service. This was the slowest taco place I've ever visited, and now I have an unwanted credit card dispute.
Service was painfully slow- we were told it would take 20 mins to get our drinks but we were among only 16 other
We visited Taco Shack before going to the Capital Theater, what a great surprise. The Margaritas and tacos were wonderful. We will be back!!
Went for a quick bite and was pleasantly surprised! All fresh ingredients.
Food was finely prepared and delicious, but there is a limited menu and no liquor license.
We thought the photos looked decent here on OpenTable. It's not terrible, it's just nothing special. My guacamole at home is way better.. Theirs is sour and lacks any spice. Their service is just kind of off, fast casual but really nothing unique. My tacos were ok, but Bar Taco down the block crushes them to oblivion. Their steak had no seasoning and texture was off--it was like eating styrofoam. Ordered a side of salsa to go with the guac and it was a tiny portion and also mediocre. Their tortilla soup was a zero. I predict they won't be around long. You could do a lot worse for sure. The place next door is also average/below average Mexican. Battle to the bottom.
The food was extremely fresh, delicious, authentic and there were healthy options. I would definitely go again. The prices were very fair and our waitress was friendly, courteous and helpful.
Food was fresh and prepared to order. Really great find for authentic tacos. Tey the chicken and brisket tacos--terrific. Great quac also.
Great new find in Portchester. Good guacamole, excellent salsa, very tasty corn tacos (GF) with generous fillings, and even enchiladas are in corn tortillas (GF)! No liquor license yet so bring your own wine! And all at reasonable prices.
Will definitely return.
Mole enchiladas were phenomenal. There may be off-the-menu meats available.
Would be nice to have larger portions and more menu options.
Excellent vegetarian options.
Great new place. Fresh food and good choices. Would recommend fish tacos and shrimp tacos on regular menu instead of specials and should be no more than $5.00/taco. All others reasonable.
They should also offer a 3 taco platter with rice & beans. Wouid be good to mix and match. Side salad instead of full salads too. Plantain side as well.
Has a lot of potential.
Excellent tacos!! Great for lunch or dinner! Mole enchiladas are fantastic. Byob right now pending liquor license but they do a great job making drinks with anything you bring. Looking forward to going back when the license comes in. Been in twice in a week for delicious mexican food that was fresh and healthy!
Taco Shack does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Taco Shack also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (914) 481-5551.
Taco Shack is rated 4.2 stars by 32 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.