Supper Restaurant

Food was great and the service was fantastic! Best Italian in NYC

We loved every bite!

Always the best food and dining experience
This is my go to place for years

Went last nite for the truffles/limone pasta! Was perfect and will definitely be returning!

Really amazing once again at Supper. We want for Saturday brunch. Was also truffle week. We put truffle on top of our asparagus as crispy egg. Was insanely good. Always happy at supper. Will keep coming back. Service and food is just awesome !!!

I’ve been coming here since it opened. No matter where I live in NYC, Supper will always be my local. Frank Prisinzano is a genius. I love everyone who works there, hangs there and IS there. I’ve had some of my best life experiences at Supper. I do wish the bar section was still open. But compared to how great the food and all is- it’s ok.

It simply doesn’t get any better than Supper. Real food for pretty much anything you want. Meat, fish, veggie, GF... they cater to everyone and we had a blast.

High quality food. Casual and comfortable atmosphere. Very good and fresh vegetables. Limone pasta is in Hall of Fame.

Came for the white truffle specials. Did not disappoint!!

Delicious!

The Food is always Amazing especially on Sat nites when they offer osso buco!!!’

Food is always fresh and delicious. Make a reservation!

Very quaint and friendly people that runs the restaurant, they make it fun to be in the environment with friends

Best Italian in NYC!

Will definitely be back for the spaghetti al limone and the amazing affogato cafe dessert ❤️

delish chicken parm + spaghetti

a lovely foccai served with a warm mini white bean stews as a comp starter

prices r steep and the only cash is outdated and inconvenient - plan ahead for that ...

I booked a 7pm reservation on Sunday for my girlfriends birthday dinner (I noted the occasion in my reservation online). We arrived at 6:55, and had our reservation passively acknowledged. We then proceeded to wait 40 minutes to get a table with no apologies or sympathy shown by any staff member.

Upon finally being sat down, no one stopped by our table for 10 minutes to pour water / introduce themselves / apologize / etc. This is when we ditched the effort to go to another restaurant.

This was an awful experience not only because it soured the birthday dinner, but because of the lack of sympathy shown by the staff. To disregard reservations in this manner is unprofessional, and while there were a few tables available outside, the temperature was ~45-50 degrees, and basic human decency was not displayed at any point of the experience.

I cannot speak to the quality of the food as we never had the chance to eat any.

Very close intimate Italian eating

Best Italian food I’ve had in NYC! Also the noisiest restaurant I’ve been in! The excellent food made up for the noise!

Great Italian food in a quaint setting. The lemon pasta was simple but delicious. Wine selections were really good as well.

Always delicious

The food was excellent and the staff was great. I can’t wait to go back!

Very rude staff. Waited for service for 40 mins after being seated. When asked the manager i was told oh well nothing i can do! Also trying to hide “grade pending “ signs!!!

Beautiful old world setting. The chicken parm and The lemon pasta are very good. Lovely restaurant.

Brunch at supper is the best part of my week!!!

Good, fresh food. The restaurant was so hot though. I think it would have been 5 stars if it was not so warm in the restaurant.

This little place was a find. Delicious food, cozy, almost crowded environment, but somehow very fun. We chose simple things for dinner, but everything was wonderful. Recommended most highly. GH

Absolutely charming little neighborhood find! Food is delicious and wait staff is perfectly attentive.

Awesome!! Treat food and service!

Chicken Parm was fantastic

Best Italian restaurant in NYC. WOW. 💙

We managed to make a reservation for Saturday evening on OpenTable.
The place was too crowded and loudly as we hardly heard each other.
The quality of food was OK. As garlic lovers, this is the right place for you.
The Tiramisu was nice, I had better

Our Guests were so impressed with the food that was served but their favorite was Osso Bucco which everyone tried 7 I still had some to bring home

I brought my whole family and we enjoyed it! The restaurant was really very warm- almost uncomfortably hot. I never have seen lobster ravioli that were just cheese ravioli with a piece of lobster on top? But, the osso bucco was delicious. Also the gluten free options were not enticing at all:( Thank you

Took a friend here for dinner based on reviews we had seen. Fairly long wait line that we had to queue into despite having a reservation. Were seated in the back room where the large crowds were seated so the noise level got pretty high as the evening went on. There is little sound buffering materials so the noise reverberates. Started with some wines by the glass - I expect that these wines will not be top of the line but these were mid to low grade, bulk type wines. Caesar salad starters were fine but nothing spectacular. Pasta entrees were disappointing. Fresh truffle shaved onto the pasta were literally tasteless - hard to believe that a fresh truffle would taste like a piece of cardboard. Pasta was overcooked and drowned in sauces that had virtually no flavor. The menu reads great but none of the food we tried delivered. Could not recommend.

We paid $70 each and the food was terrible. Love the atmosphere though, and our server was lovely.

I always come to any Frank Prisinzano restaurant for the quality of the food. It never disappoints. I feel like we were all seated too close to each other, for our own waiter couldn’t physically get to us, but the food was outstanding.

Always a delicious meal. Get the spaghetti limone

Phenomenal food. Great vibe. The chef is the man.

Our waiter was outstanding! The food was good but not as great as in the past.