What Insiders Are Saying
A cash only, no reservations, popular East Village Italian establishment.
LOVED everything about Supper. Will definitely make this a must whenever I’m in nyc!!!
Continued to meet high expectations! Fantastic place to eat.
Wonderful meal, wonderful staff. Unfortunately sat next to a table of awfully loud women. Otherwise great experience.
Overpriced for mediocre food
Amazing as always. Never disappointed. Risotto, Tagliatelle and Lasagna dishes are superb no matter how they’ve been specialized for the day.
This is an old-fashioned Italian place with good food and cozy ambiance in the East Village. Always good value and good food with nice service.
Delicious food. Great ambiance. Cash only. Look at menu ahead of time and plan to bring enough for what you want.
We went for brunch. The quality of the food was good, but the prices are now 35% higher than posted on the OpenTable menu. $13 items are now $18! And at these prices, I would have expected a bit more hollandaise sauce on my rather dry eggs benedict. Also note that this is a cash only restaurant.
Best meatballs ever! This place is a gem.
Really fun little place. Everything was good but the chicken parm was excellent, and their red sauce in general is where you get the best taste. Quiet enough to talk, noisy enough to know you were in a good place. RECOMMENDED.
The hostess is obnoxious. There are enough good Italian restaurants in the east village that I don’t need to return to this one.
We had a delicious birthday celebration for daughter! The pastas and veal scallopini were amazing! Would definitely recommend!!
Food was fantastic and our server was great. We had one issue where one of our dishes came out nearly when everyone else had finished eating. Additionally we had a member who’s birthday it was in our party and I requested for a dessert with candles to come out at the end. And while the party next to us got a big birthday shout out my friend did not, they completely forgot and it was disappointing. Overall the food is incredible and the vibe is great as well, just a couple glitches
Supper is the best Italian food I have had so far in NYC! They have a great menu and the gourmet Italian food it put together right infront of you! I took my valentine date there and it was a smash! Compliments to the chef! Also I would totally make a commerical for them if they gave me a free meal! ;)
It is a typical east village ambiance, cozy noisy and tight space.
Food is really good. Wine, Merlot was horrible ( no depth , fullness or flavor).
It has its charm and food wise you can not go wrong
Amazing! The risotto was incredible as was the cacio e pepe
We were seated in the back room with two other large groups celebrating birthdays, which was incredibly loud and rowdy. It was really unusual as I’ve been to Supper loads of times, and have never experienced this.
Food was on point as usual, but the ambience left a lot to be desired unfortunately.
Although the food is mostly good, the ambiance leaves much to be desired primarily because if you're seated in the back room and it's full with relatively loud diners, the cacophony is unbearable and you'll be hoarse from shouting at your dining companion. Also, the back room is so tight that the waiter kept banging into the back of my chair everytime he walked by. Very annoying. So, if you go sit in the front (where large groups aren't seated) and know they don't take credit cards (annoying in this day and age) so bring cash.
It was amazing as always!
Perfect date spot! Great vibe, delicious food, friendly staff
Beautiful historic building is the backdrop for this tiny, cozy, restaurant. Food will not disappoint!
went on a busy Friday, restaurant was filled but moving efficiently. fun ambiance, louder, energetic. food was great, and service was attentive. would go again.
Was going to a venue close by and found this restaurant. I arrived ahead of time and waited for another person. The staff was friendly and I was not rushed. The food was delicious and interesting. Loved the Black Kale Caesar Salad!
We had to wait 45 minutes to be seated and they were out of the food we wanted.
Great for a big group birthday! Pre fixe menu required for 12+ people!
Amazing food and ambience! Went there with the family for a birthday, service was great food was even better. A little crowded in a good way.
The service and food were incredible. My wife and I celebrated our anniversary here and the ambiance and staff couldn't be any better. Get the chicken parm, the vegetable platter and risotto. Servers were kind enough to bring a second helping of the white beans and bread. Low key the best bite of the evening!
Great time at Supper. I was there for my birthday and it was fun with great service! Food came out in a timely manner and service was friendly! I highly recommend it!
This is my favorite restaurant in NYC!
The worst dining experience we have had in a long time.
We order in regularly and the food is consistently good,
So we decided to eat in the restaurant this past Saturday night and will never go back. We were seated at 9:45 for a 9:30 reservation, and waited over an hour for our main course which never arrived. We finally left at 11:30 without eating.
Unbelievable! The best service and food!
Holy crap this place is AMAZING!! My friend recommended it because it was my dude's birthday, and everything was delicious. The prosciutto di parma was crazy good and the meat, cheese, and fresh pear paired great together. I got the spaghetti limone and it is the best I've ever tasted in my life. I should mention I'm 100% Italian and my grandparents are from Italy and this place is divine. Wasn't sure what wine to get, so they brought us out several kinds to sample before we picked one. They brought out free dessert and sang happy birthday and the whole night was fabulous.
We went there for a birthday and we loved it! My boyfriend got the lasagne, which he loved. I got the extraordinary platter of vegetables, and it was unfortunately not as extraordinary in my opinion. I would probably get a pasta next time I go there. The service was so nice and gave us a cake on the house to celebrate his birthday. Highly recommend their flourless chocolate cake!
Our server David was the best!
This cash only place has a feel of a family restaurant. Services are great. Foods are delicious and fresh. We especially loved lemon pasta. We added chicken on top making it even better dish.
Fantastic food - some of the best Italian I’ve had in NYC
Great food, reasonable prices, respectful service. Good floor show sitting at bar. What else is there?