Sullivan's Steakhouse - Indianapolis
Book your next event with us
Prime New York Strip
Choice of Strip Steak or Garlic Shrimp, Mixed Greens, Avocado, Bacon, Deviled Eggs, Parmesan, Blue Cheese & Sweet Basil Vinaigrette
The quality of the food did not match cost. Great steak. Lamb was not as great.
Went out for thanksgiving due to we are moving in a week and things are packed up and a mess. 1st time we’ve done this in the 20yrs we’ve been married. The restaurant was not very busy. My wife and daughter ordered the thanksgiving dinner assuming they would get everything that the menu promised. That didn’t happen. They were out of cranberries which may not be a big deal to many, but it was to us. If the server had told them ahead of time that they’d been sold out for “hours”, her words, they probably would have ordered off the main menu. The server seemed disinterested in being there that night which I can understand. She was not attentive and just non-chalant in general. We likely won’t be back and we eat out often.
Service was medicore, food was average and very overpriced. Dissapointing as I have been there in the past and it has generally been very good. Maybe b/c holiday
Love going to Sullivans. Always enjoy the food and the service is always great! Its our favorite date night
Fantastic steak house. Great service and food. Bar is dark and warm. Highly recommend.
Our server was great
Told hostess at check in that we were celebrating our anniversary. When seated the table had rose petals and a card signed by the staff. Haylie, our server, was outstanding. Attentive and upbeat. Food was great. Steak cooked to perfection. Wonderful evening.
Sullivan's Steakhouse always does a phenomenal job making you and your party feel special. Whether your table is celebrating an anniversary, birthday, or just a date night without kids, the staff make you feel comfortable and valued.
My husband ordered a filet, 8oz butterflied. It was way too done & really not much flavor he reported. He loved the lettuce wedge though & the potatoes were good. I had the salmon & it was delicious. The asparagus left a lot to be desire though (mushy) & the sauce, whatever it was, on the plate didn't seem to compliment it at all. We got the special price Fixe & brought our dessert home. It was the cheesecake & tasted good. Our service was good although we did have to find our server to ask for salt & pepper. I had asked to be socially distanced & we certainly were. We were in the upper room with no one else the entire evening. There were 5 of us & we had a large round table which was perfect.
The food was great. The waitresses seemed to be in a rush to take our plates away when were were not finished with our items. The mac n cheese was not what we expected. It tasted very burnt.
The food and service was outstanding! Our server, Alex, recommended the lobster mashed potatoes. Amazing!!! Alex also recommended a fabulous chocolate dessert that was incredible. Wonderful evening; highly recommend it and ask for Alex!
Food and service was great as usual. It was nice to see some of the old standards back on the menu.
There was a bit of confusion on who our waiter/waitress was at first. They both were asking orders. Our glasses were cracked all the way through and they were replaced. Other than that, service was very good. The food was excellent.
I took my wife here for our anniversary. The staff went above and beyond to ensure it was a wonderful experience.
Our food was outstanding! We felt very comfortable with the social distance provided and all the attention to virus concerns. Teresa was our server and she was most helpful, warm and provided us with an wonderful experience! We can't wait for a return visit.
We order the Grand Prix fixed menu. My filet was medium, but overdone on the outside. Very good but I couldn’t eat parts being too dark......overdone.
Great meal, cowboy ribeye done perfectly.
Felt a little rushed. Done in under an hour of sitting, appetizers, salad/soup and main course. Steak was excellent. Perfectly cooked. Scallops were slightly undercooked. French onion soup was excellent, caesar salad was nothing to write home about. Overall, not terribly memorable. Ordered wine with dinner, had to ask for it after I was nearly done with my food only to find out they were out of what I ordered. Substitute was quickly brought. No harm, no foul. Would give them another try.
We were celebrating our 25th wedding anniversary with our kids. Sullivan’s made it extra special with flower petals on table, a card from the staff and a picture to cap off the evening. Made it a special evening!
Steak was delicious. Sullivan's has the best hot creamy garlic mashed potatoes. Next time will ask for dressing on the side on the wedge. A little too much for my liking.
Our table was decorated with rose pedals and a card to celebrate our 44th anniversary. A complimentary desert complimented a really tasty meal perfectly prepared. The staff took our picture and printed it for us as a memoir. A really enjoyable and relaxing time at Sulivan’s!!
Great service, Manager gave us a complimentary appetizer. Will return soon.
We have not been to Sullivan’s since before the pandemic and things sure have changed.
They did not have the bottle of wine we requested from the menu.
The plate was sparse, three stalks of asparagus with a 10 oz. steak?
The steak was extremely over seasoned.
We ordered off the price fixed list due to the cost of a steak being nearly $50.00.
Service was good, server seamed “extremely wired” and it was a little “over the top”.
Many other places to get a good steak in Indianapolis where the ambiance is better and you can get a better value for your money.
Wonderful quality steaks cooked to perfection. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure our steaks were cooked to order and we were satisfied. Pricey, but worth it for a special night out.
Our waiter September, was delightful and on top of our need to leave on time for an event. The steaks were great but the mashed potatoes are somewhat dry The sides are huge. Plenty to share with the table.
Aaron is the greatest manager!
We went for our anniversary. The staff recognized the event from the time we arrived. Our server (Evan) was pleasant patient and made the evening special.
Service was very good but the food not so much for the price.
Simply stated this was one of the worst food experiences I have had in a restaurant of this caliber.
Lobster Bisque was basically orange cream
Spinach was ok
Tomahawk ribeye âged steak was awful, had no flavor, no fat, was as tender as leather bag could taste like 💩
Their specialty - Scallops Oscar style 🤮. Imagine if you took frozen scallops, nuked them, then poured 1000 island sauce over Imitation crab meat, except scallops were not cooked all the way through and were chewy.
Finally for desert - key lime pie, I took a pic of this horrible creation, it was purple with arrangement of lime shavings, and what looked like sriracha sauce but was actually strawberry purée attempt. It smelled like dirty underwear. 🤮
Banana Bread pudding: imagine flavored warm banana bread. Except crunchy, because it was not Fresh.
The best thing that night was an ice cream scoop. And tonic water with lime.
Apparently their chef is a vegetarian.
I’ve lived in Indy 15 years ago, came back for a weekend, wanted to try a steak house - this is not the Sullivans I remembered.
Awful. Simply awful.
Ate in bar area. Food good
It was great!
Delicious as usual. I had the crab cakes and they were the best I have ever had, chunks of crab. My husband had the filet, cooked exactly right and delicious. We also had bread and garlic mashed potatoes. Everything was great! It is a little pricey, but high quality!
Awesome! Birthday celebration and food was delicious.
Food was really good. Service good.
Really average, maybe why I haven’t been there in a while. Could not manage keeping my water glass full. Food just ok. Nice place , nice decor, not very well done, used to be one of the best.
The food was great as always this is my favorite steakhouse.
The food was amazing and the price for our steak special was great
Great food. Good environment. Average service. Not a bad experience but not a great one.
Was good as usual. The manager and the lady that seats you were real good. Was our anniversary. They did a good job. Our waitress was good. She kept taking items off table and still needed some. But she was good.
Sullivan's Steakhouse - Indianapolis does offer delivery in partnership with Postmates and Uber Eats. Sullivan's Steakhouse - Indianapolis also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 580-1280.
Sullivan's Steakhouse - Indianapolis is rated 4.5 stars by 4173 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.