We were here a few years ago and had a great time. That wasn’t quite the experience this time. The waiter seemed annoyed we were in his section and wasn’t very attentive. Our steaks were brought out but it took a few minutes before we were provided steak knives. Which was only after we asked a different server. The potatoes came out cold and we had to say something...again to a different server since ours was not paying much attention. He took the plates back and when our server came back out it was clear he either just stuck the plates in the oven or a microwave and put down the plates with a comment.
We found out after we sat that it was restaurant week but we didn’t go there for that reason. Once the server realized we were not there for restaurant week and I threw down 2 $100 bills, he was suddenly trying to win us over. He wanted us to fill out an online survey but only if it was positive. It was much too late for us to change our mind about the place.
My wife's steak came out very undercooked. Waitress wasn't very attentive as my wife's drink was never refreshed. Server messed up my dessert. It means I go 2 desserts but one of them we didn't want. All in all good was mediocre compared to some of the other high end dmsteak houses in the very near area.
Our server TJ (Timonthy)did a outstanding job from start to finish on our dinner on Sunday night. He made sure all of our food came out correctly and also was very attentive to our needs. TJ had a great attitude that made the dining experience that much better. The food was fantastic and TJ made sure everything went seamless.
Celebrated a friend's birthday and we had a great time. Our server Rafael was amazing. He was very accommodating and helped to make our celebration that much more special.
Great food and service!
We were there for new years eve. the food as usual was excellent. we did think it was weird that they ran out of mashed potato but had baked potato (that wasnt even on the menu!!). our server was spot on - just enough time between courses and checking on us but man you could tell she didnt want to be there. this is unusual for sullivans to have a sullen server but she was. but food was good. it was odd that at almost midnight they passed out champagne and hats and noisemakers. f you used the noisemakers outside, you couldnt drink the champagne at midnight. woulda been nice to be able to come back in and get champagne and dessert but not sure how theyd do that.
Good steaks cooked well, although the dry-aged was too salty.
What a very nice time on New Years Eve! The prefixe menu was excellent with alot of choices.
Service was on point and the food was really good!
great meal..private room was nice but very cold as every time the door opened the cold air came in our room
Went for the NYE 5 course meal. Server TJ was the best service any of us had in a long while. He was extremely attentive and upbeat. For cocktails I had the French Fashioned which was delicious, my friends had Moscow mules, also delicious. Because of the set up of NYE we were able to try the cheesesteak rolls, shrimp cocktail, seafood sampler, wedge salad, shrimp & lobster bisque, filet mignon, and dry bone in rib eye. For dessert I had chocolate covered strawberries, others had cheesecake and banana fosters. Everything from start to end was great. Very tasty. With drinks and tip and extras it was pricey but everything being perfect from food to service it's hard to complain about anything and we paid the bill happily. Would definitely return.
Buy now and send it instantly by email, or print a card to give in person.Give a Gift
If you are celebrating a special occasion and are looking for a lively, intimate setting, Sullivan's offers a variety of semi/private dining and reception spaces perfectly suited for any occasion. Sullivan's provides a romantic atmosphere, custom menus, as well as personalized beverage service.View Private Dining Details