Sugar River Pizza Company - Sun Prairie

I had pizza here before which was great.
Today I tried the lasagna, didn’t care for it. I didn’t like how they burn it on top and not much red sauce.

This was not our first time at Sugar River and the second time we weren't pleased. We were disappointed in how long it took to get our food. We knew something was off when other parties, seated after us, got their food before us. The wait person said the kitchen got slammed - which means nothing to us since we were there before that happened. It's also not our problem and should not be used as an excuse for poor service. There are lots of great pizza places to go to and most with better service. We're all done with Sugar River.

Wait staff and pizza was great. We went to bar while waiting. Bartender was terrible.

Amazing food Huge portions. Great service what more could you want

The pizza was ok and the server was nice enough but the food took way too long to get to our table. The Bruschetta appetizer that we ordered was cold by the time it hit our table. It had cold hardened melted cheese on it which indicates that it sat for a long while before they brought it out to our table. The ambience was ok. Not sure if it’s Covid safety related at all or not but it was very basic. If they are striving for the minimalistic look by creating no ambience by way of decor and just having tables and chairs then they definitely hit their mark, but it wasn’t very inspiring. In the end it was just “Ok” but nothing to write home about.

Great guest service. It was quick but still offered great, fresh and tasty food.

First time there. Got the Goat Cheese Alfredo with asparagus- outstanding! So much food! Can’t wait to try the pizza next time

Convenient on line reservation, great job of social distancing tables, masks worn correctly by staff, outstanding pizza, cheese curds and salads.

Great happy hour . Large tap beer selection. Nice view and roomy eating area !

Great customer service. Food tasted as if it was soaking in vegetable oil before it was cooked. We ordered sandwiches andaybe should have stuck to the pizza. I would not order the sandwiches ever again. Drinks were decent.

Always great pizzaand the beignets for dessert were oh so good!

Pizza was amazing. The pretzel bites were a little bland, and not soft and chewy, and the beer cheese was tasteless. But overall it was a great dining experience and will definitely eat here again.

Bring your smartphone because it’s the only way to view the menu. It’s a little difficult this way.

The bruschetta was the best I have ever had. The food and service was outstanding. It is on the top of my list of places to dine out.

Was hard for my husband to read menu off phones. Would be helpful th have a paper menu.

The restaurant is not even open yet! Quite shocking!

It was our first trip and it was overall a great experience. The waiter was attentive and the food was good. It looked liked they were still getting signage and deco on the walls. We will definitely be back.

I had heard wonderful things about the food in Verona, so we decided to go here for my birthday. I was disappointed because it took forever to get our drinks and the restaurant wasn’t busy. The ranch dressing is way too think and I’m not sure what the black stuff is in their beer cheese, but it made it very unappealing. My chicken Alfredo and my son’s shrimp Alfredo were very good and my daughter and husband both loved their wings!

We didn’t order pizza, however other tables did and that looked appealing as well. If they could spend time on correcting their homemade dips and the bar service, this place will get 5 stars!

If you want a pasta or pizza meal Sugar River Pizza Company is an excellent choice. Food and staff are both wonderful. You don't go away hungry because you get a lot of food.

Love this place for the pizza, tonight I tried the pasta with goat cheese Alfredo sauce. Omg soooo good!

The food took very long time, as kids started to get bored and then they don’t want to it. No doubt food was nice and warm when came. Will give it another try for sure

The restaurant looked busy from the parking lot but was very quiet inside. Not sure if this is because they have only been open for a few days or just people's general aversion to eating indoors. These poor restaurants are only allowed 25% capacity and yet so frequently don't even appear close to having that many people in them. Thankfully it looked like their carryout business was hopping! Anyway!
The menu was extensive. We tried the spinach artichoke dip, chicken wings with dry rub and a calzone (with spinach and chicken) The food took a little while to come but our waitress was very nice and explained that the kitchen was busy and still finding their rhythm (they had only been open 4 days). We each ordered a beer from their very extensive tap list while we waited. Food came out hot and everything was delicious. Portions are generous. Even though we were sharing we still brought 4 chicken wings and 1/3 of the calzone home. We absolutely will return.

Had a friend in town and we had to bring her. As expected she loved it! This place has such amazing pizza, but don’t forget the cheese bread!