See availability for bonus point tables
Mon 11:00AM - 11:45AM 12:00PM - 1:00PM 1:15PM - 3:45PM 4:00PM - 11:00PM
Tue - Sat 5:00PM - 6:30PM 8:00PM - 9:45PM
I have eaten at the Storico several times before; it seemed like the menu may have changed somewhat but the food was as good as before! The service seemed a bit slow though.
We brought friends here because the restaurant is so pretty and near the museum we visited. Sadly, we were disappointed. There was a hair in my salad and my guest found a hair in his French fries. We brought this to the attention of the staff. Overall the food quality and kitchen standards need improvement.
Very very salty food and a bit heavy handed. The waiter was solicitous is a good way.
Fabulous dinner Tuesday evening after the lecture. The chicken, beef, cod all outstanding.
Service was friendly and considerate- always keeping us informed of the progress of our dinner.
Lucky was our server - simply spectacular, such a pleasure!
We, of course , will return.
Convenient location in Museum. We toured exhibit, had lunch and returned afterwards for the afternoon exhibits.
The lobster tagliatelle and the sea bass were both delicious. Very friendly service. The room is very pretty. Convenient for this museum or for American Museum of Natural history. Nice for latte and dessert as well. I wish they had more vegetarian options and pastas
Service was great. Wine options were good its opportunity to taste before ordering. Interesting small plates. Menu options change
Amazing! And server Ricardo was very kind
Our anniversary was acknowledged by chef in grand style.
Lucky was great at the bar. Very knowledgeable about the story of the restaurant and the menu. Food is outstanding!
Great service. Small portions but delicious.
Right next to the museum. I would go back again.
Excellent food and atmosphere! Highly recommended.
Perhaps some Open Table reviewers or New Yorkers have a different expectation of what a good cafe should be as some reviews left an impression of general decline in food quality, menu offerings and service. However, there was nothing of the sort. On the contrary, we were rather pleased with what we encountered at Caffe Storico. The interesting menu had sufficient variety and the food was simply very good in tasting and presentation. Main dish pastas are perfect sizes and not obscenely large as at so many other American places and done to near perfection. Sensible portions, excellent food preparation, a nice variety to choose from, priced at reasonable (for Manhattan) prices plus good service. What more is there to ask for in a non pretentious lunch or dinner.
Excellent well-prepares food at an interesting Museum..... !!
Nice casual restaurant inside the New York Historical Museum.
The hostess and our waiter were very friendly and relaxed on a very hectic day - Wed Dec 27. I appreciated their good nature.
We used to love this restaurant -- food was amazing, incredible service and beautiful space and location--we have taken many friends and family. The last 3 times (2 dinner and one brunch) it was horrible for the food and service. The menus were limited, but if limited should be delicious and special-- just was lackluster and couldn't decide if it was heavy or light. Service was atrocious on all fronts.
The hostess was rude and saved the best table, despite making a reservation, for the museum curator. Total disregard for customer service and desires.
Everything is great except the acoustics. Maybe the plates stacked up on the walls magnify sound.