Stella 34 Trattoria
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Wonderful food, great view of the city, and just quiet, pleasant, really, the whole NYC dining experience. When things open back up, I will be back.
nice and relaxing atmosphere. good service, good food
Happy to get out during the Holiday Season and have some great food with friends. Maintained all COVID-19 safety standards - very clean.
Wonderful food and extra friendly service.
Excellent food and service. They are following all NY City and State health guidelines.
Always a great experience at Patina restaurants and Stella 34 was no exception. Wonderful hospitality imaginative menu and beautiful ambience combined with attentive service made for one memorable meal. Great for place to mangia.
Great food and drinks
Perfect break from shopping
Early birthday celebration- really enjoyed lunch. Always came here when attending events at Madison square garden- staff always accommodating. Thanks for being opened.
Great food and service as always. Meatball appetizer and calamari amazing. Pasta dishes and pizza always on point
I was looking for a spot to grab drinks and some appetizers before going to another event with my boyfriend and this was the perfect spot! We were seated right near the window with a perfect view of the Empire State Building! The food was incredible and the drinks were great as well! You would never expect to find that at Macy’s! I loved it and will definitely be back!
I have visited many times, I am a huge fan of the food and views here, but this last time was awful! I ordered the QUATTRO STAGIONI TOMATO pizza. A $22 pizza that was cut poorly (uneven 4 slices that made it hard to share) the prosciutto was forgotten and when I sent it back for it to be added it was literally thrown on top. The pizza was sectioned so if shared only one person only gets mushrooms, one got all the artichokes..etc. poor presentation for an expensive pizza. Don’t get me wrong, it was good.. but not worth the money. Hope they bring back the original menu again and the way they use to make pizza!
Excellent service by all the staff.Amazing selection of food from appetizers to desert. The calamari was cooked to perfection as was the burrata and vegetable dish. I had a devine Branzini and ended the meal with tiriamasu. I highly recommend Stella34 if you want a wonderful dining experience.The drink menu was also very impressive.
what a great experience as always at stella-- but especially now during covid. It was a very socially distant and very safe.
Food and service was amazing
I come here often for lunch either for a business meetings or with friends. The food is always good with great service. Great space. I recommend.
Amazing apps and great pasta dishes. Amazing selection of gelatos for dessert.
Very convenient if you’re shopping in Macy’s. Nice food.
I love love this place. The food is delicious. I recommend this to anyone that loves good food and the desert was a dream come true.
Best hidden secret in NYC!😍
Can’t wait to go again!
This was one of the best Ugly Produce dinners since they began about 4 years ago. It's something we look forward to each year, and this one was fantastic!
From an amuse bouche of artichoke/taleggio profiterole, to butternut squash truffle soup that was different from the butternut squash soup I make at home - but wonderful and flavorful, even considering that I am not (sorry if this is heresy!) a truffle fan, through creative, delicious, beautifully composed, dishes for entree, to an upside-down citrus cake with lemon-thyme sorbet for dessert, this was a superb meal. The beet-infused pasta dish was fantastic; the potato/veggie terrine (or maybe lasagna?!) was amazingly delish.
We didn't take the optional wine pairing, but the glass of Chardonnay I had was super dry my husband enjoyed his glass of Montepulciano.
Four of us participated in the “Ugly Produce is Beautiful” dinner. It was fabulous. We absolutely loved the 4-course dinner with wine pairings. Each course was delicious. We can’t wait for next year to see how the chef will top this year’s event.
This was a truly great meal. We went to the Ugly produce night. Bought into the wine pairings. What a well thought out and innovative menu. Each course was explained, elegant and delicious. So Manhattan, so chic and so beneficial to a good cause.
I have dined at Stella 34 a couple of times. On Wednesday I went to the special Ugly Produce is Beautiful dinner. The menu was delicious. I loved the butternut squash soup and beet pasta. I als enjoyed the wine pairings!
Thank you. Hope to return during Macy’s Flower show.
Very good food and a bright and open atmosphere. Definitely a midtown gem
Restaurant is great and although it is inside Macy's it doesnt feel part of a department store.
Views of the Empire State Building are great and staff superb.
Ordered the lasagna to share and had to play hunt the meat so definitely not worth the $58!!!
Birthday dinner for my aunt. Food was excellent but there wasn’t a lot to chose from.
Perfect on all accounts. We will visit again. Lovely menu choices. Also good for our grandsons, ages 5 and 9. Especially nice was its being close to Penn Station.
Service was excellent. A little pricy for such a limited menu, the food was ok. Won’t be going back. Not worth it.
I had the Branzino and Pane Al Forno. Both were delicious! I have been here many times and will be back. Food is consistently good!
Came to Stella 34 for Saturday prix fixe brunch, which was an excellent deal. 2 almost full size courses followed by dessert. The food is fresh and tasted very good. We were stuffed. It's not crowded there on Saturdays so we had an attentive waitstaff, plus a nice quiet leisurely time to catch up. My friend who hadn't been there before was impressed and said she thought it was a return location!
Greg place to go when at MSG event. Re meal, potatoes and mushrooms for tenderloin steak meal were over cooked.
Otherwise all was VG.
The food was excellent with a wonderful, innovative selection.
Best servers, hot food & an amazing view of the Empire State Building.
The food was great. The service was wonderful and quick too. Very close to our theatre. Would definitely recommend
It pains me to say this, but Stella 34 has gone massively downhill in the past year. I have to preface my review by saying I've been going to Stella for at least a decade and I've always loved it, and so have all of my guests. Something has gone terribly wrong in this establishment. Our server couldn't be bothered, never checked on us, and left our drinks sitting on the bar for 20 mins in our line of sight. I damn near got up and got them myself! She also never brought our change back. However, all of that pales in comparison to how bad the food was. It was inedible. The arancini was ice cold, my eggplant parm was a sloppy, sticky, gloppy, gummy mess, and my friend's chicken was gray in color. I know Patina Group has been having some issues lately overall but the corner cutting at Stella is going to lose them a lot of customers. Additionally, the bread they used to bring you for free now costs $8 if you want it with your meal. My friend and I aren't big complainers, but the quality of the food was so atrocious that we pulled a manager aside. I didn't catch this manager's name, but she was very sweet and comped our bill, so I have nothing but good things to say about her. However, I cannot in good conscience ever return to Stella knowing how bad the food was. What a shame.
Service was slow. Our reservations was for 6:00 pm. They were already out of several things. What we got was more like you would expect at an old Woolworth’s dining counter, and extremely slow in coming. We had to swallow things whole to make an 8:00 concert at Madison Square Garden.
Never would I go back. Don’t waste your time with this place. Worst meal I have ever had in NYC. A Subrette’s and a Coke from the corner stand would have been soooo much better.
I booked this restaurant because of it’s proximity to MSG. What a great find! The atmosphere is modern, light, clean and comfortable. The personnel are friendly and helpful. Our waiter, Tereck, was terrific... busy but attentive and helpful with recommendations. The cocktails and food were outstanding! This will be a go-to restaurant for us!
Always a pleasant meal at Stella’s. We come here often when we come into the city
My favorite place in NYC ,love it. Recommend of course
Good food and good service good view too
Happy with our choice for valentines
Stella 34 Trattoria offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 967-9251.
Stella 34 Trattoria is rated 4.5 stars by 2673 OpenTable diners.
Stella 34 Trattoria does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.patinagroup.com/gift-cards.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.