Excellent service from our server Virginia. The disappointments were mainly two of our friends ordered the veal parmigiana and found it tough and over cooked. The other main dishes were outstanding. We also shared the calamari and only received a thimble size cup of sauce to eat with it and had to wait for more. Felt rushed because helpers were clearing plates before everyone was finished eating. I understand there’s the turnover time but let us enjoy our meals. Still a favorite restaurant of ours and will be back but probably in September.
We have been to Stephano’s before love going there every year food is great and will continue to go
Amazing food and service...highly recommended! Will come back on our next vsisit!
Been coming to the island for 9 years ate at many places ... Stefano’s is by far the place I have eaten at!!!... and I love the byob!!!!.... highly recommend this place to everyone!!!!..a must try!!!!
We don't get down to Beach Haven very often but when we do we always make it our business to have dinner at Stefano's. This time we took with our friends since they have never been there. They couldn't believe how good the food was...better than they had expected. They love fish and usually have it wherever they go so they were really impressed.
All the items seemed fresh and properly prepared and cooked. We had clam chowder, flounder and egg plant
Wonderful dinner. Looking forward to going back
As always we had a great experience at Stefano’s. Awesome food and service.
Great food. Excellent service. Best place on the island
I believe Stefanos is the best restaurant on the island! I have never had a bad meal in all my years going there. Always a delight & the staff always has a smile! Highly recommend. The only downside is trying to get a reservation on short notice. But always worth the wait!
Stefanos is the best restaurant on LBI. It never disappoints.
Food and Service fantastic, the best place to try something you normally wouldn't eat. Everything is delicious!!
We have dined here many times and the food and service are always top notch. Ambiance is the same maybe it’s time to spruce up the decor. Noice level a bit high. The staff works very well together and tables are cleared and reset before the customers are out the door. You always need a reservation here even during the week.
Food was wonderful and service professional. We sat on their patio and it was a lovely dinner.
This was my third meal at Stefano’s over 5 years. I ordered Flounder Francaise which was prepared and cooked well but too lemony and tart for me. It also was not hot. The side salad was not fresh with a few old slimy pieces of lettuce as well as brown edged pieces. My sons Tuna shashimi style was good, my niece’s sea bass was great. Another son had ravioli which he said was good. If I go again I’ll try my luck with a pasta with seafood dish.
Excellent service ! Our waitress was friendly and helpful! Food was amazing!
Wonderful food and service. Only issue was we didn’t get seated until 30 minutes after our reservation.
Enjoyed our meal and the service was good. Upgraded our salads for $7- it was not worth the additional cost so would not recommend it.
We have been dining at STEFANO'S for 15 years.... our friends from New Hampshire come every year just for the lamp chops.... We have always had a wonderful meal...in a pretty setting. The service is always good and the clientele are very nice. It is casual but most people like to dress up a notch! We love the BYOB...
The food is always excellent - from appetizers to dessert.....definitely a go to place - we just love it and HIGHLY RECOMMEND it!!! LBI is lucky to have this gem!
Delicious as usual. Brought friends from out-of-town who were visiting the island for 1st time. They loved it!
Very good. Have definitely upped their game over the years. A little rushed but overall very good and will return.
I’ve been there previously. Excellent atmosphere and decor. Server was excellent. Burrata platter and eggplant Napoleon perfect. Chilean sea bass Tuscany is phenomenal. Definitely a must go on the Island.
Great food. Great service. Favorite restaurant on the island.
Everyone enjoyed their meal
All good. Very pricey though.
Loved this place wish I had been before now. Food was fantastic! Our Server was wonderful, knowledgable and helpful as well as very pleasant. I loved the decor, Clean, Light, modern. Overall just loved this place. Will be back again soon.
One of the appetizers oysters Stefano would not recommend [ had shells in oysters ]
The entries crab cakes and tuna were very good
Always perfect. Some loud groups but service and food the best
I fine this the best place to eat on the island. Service and food is great. Never had a bad meal there. I go 2 or 3 times a season. They are professionals. They care that their customers have a good experience.
Food was excellent. Service even more. Steven, sin of owners, is awesome and attentive.
Always a delicious dinner at Stefano’s’s!!! ❤️
Always an LBI favorite!
Perfect evening, great service from Ed, good food and lively setting. We dined outside
Reservations are a must. The food and service were top notch. Reasonable value for such a fine meal.
We visited Stefanos while celebrating our 1 year wedding anniversary in LBI. The food and service were perfect. Everything we ordered was delicious, the only issue was deciding when everything on the menu looks so good! We will be back soon!
Very nice restaurant on LBI. Excellent food across a varied menu and the pricing is appropriate. Our party of four asks that wait staff be reminded to not stretch across table to serve. When ever possible, staff should move around the table and place items at diner's position. Looking forward to going back later this season.
As always, an amazing meal! Always consistently excellent food and service!
Stefanos is simply The Best Dining experience on Long Beach Island. Our server Troy was a knowledgeable and consummate professional. The food is a culinary and sumptuous event!
Beautiful and memorable evening
Very nice menu is what attracted us to try Stefano’s. We were not disappointed at all, good service, did not rush us or bring food out to quickly, and both our dishes were excellent. Will go back!!!