We have been on LBI since 2003 and have never tried Stefano’s till this summer, what a big mistake on our part. They have a great menu, we love BYOB, dishes have been good portions and tasty, and the service has been exceptional from ordering your meal, bringing it out, to cleaning up. Our last waitress ( Paige) was so helpful in our decision what to order and she was constantly checking on us to make sure everything was ok. A must try when on LBI.
Excellent food. I am gluten free and always love going to Stefanos. I never have to really think about what I am eating since items are labeled. I am always able to get an appetizer, meal and dessert. My favorite place to eat!
Stefanos is always delicious. Never disappointed. One of the few restaurants on LBI that is worth it.
Wonderful food and service
This was our first time at Stefanos and were only able to get an early reservation. The pistachio crusted salmon dinner had a very good size piece of fish. We were pleased with all 4 meals. Our only complaint was there was a very high noise level. We would definitely try it sgsin.
Very enjoyable and delicious food! Always a big hit!
Our number one go to place for dinner on LBI. Have never been disappointed with a meal or service.
Wonderful food and ambiance on LBI. Only complaint is the tables are too small for parties of 4 (maybe 32” if that). We couldn’t pick up our glasses of
Wine without catching the base on the dishes. It was very very cramped. The same size table fit the parties of two very nicely though and the larger parties had adequate table sizes. That said, Stefano’s consistently serves quality food in a lovely atmosphere
Food was good. The chowder was excellent. The chef was willing to accommodate changes. And the coconut cake was fabulous! I would suggest they offer more entrees without crabmeat.
Service and food was amazing as always. It’s a must for anyone coming to LBI !!
Sand in my scallops. Very gritty😩 my sons linguine and clam sauce had a funny taste, maybe Nutmeg? He couldn’t eat it. My husband enjoyed his steak and mashed garlic potatoes, though.
Terrific food nice night out on our vacation
Enjoyed all the food. New England chowder the best! Everyone very pleasant courteous. Will definitely come back.
Excellent seafood. Bisque best around. Lobster mash potatoes not to be missed. Professional server. Thanks.
Stefanos never disappoints! The food and the service is outstanding. Everyone who works there is very friendly.
Great food and service
We have been coming here for many years and I have to say they are one of my favorites!! The food is exceptional and the staff is very friendly! Awesome place!!
Every thing was Excellent! Paige was our server and did a Great job! We bought had Sea Food Fra Diablo over Linguiini and that was really good. My Husband had a bowl of New England clam chowder, and said it was one of the best. We will be back!!!!
Our food was mediocre at best. Bland sauce and tough chicken for chicken Parmesan for my husband and my tuna was ok quality. Salads were a non-event.
Always a good choice
One of the best restaurants on LBI. The pasta dishes are fresh and the desserts are delicious!
Great food and our waiter was excellent. Made great and accurate suggestions. Make your reservations at least 2 weeks ahead of time to get the time you want.
Food was excellent but we didn’t appreciate the “bums rush”. Felt we were on the clock for the entire dinner
The best restaurant on LBI. Food & service are always excellent. It’s a BYOB but do offer local wine by the bottle. Be respectful and make reservations!
Great food. Wonderful environment. Attentive staff.
This was a delightful meal. No wonder Stefano is rated as one of LBI's best restaurants. From the greeting at the door to the waitress to the quality of the food, all was exceptional
Could be the best restaurant ive been to. Consistently excellent food,service,ambiance. We come every summer. Large group, always 5 star.
Always wonderful service and great food The atmosphere is truly lively. We were there earlier so it was quiet but when it is packed it can get a bit loud.
My favorite restaurant to eat at when we are on vacation .Love the food & service. I can't get enough of the clam sauce or the mussels in the cheese sauce . I have enjoyed everything I had ordered..The service is outstanding.I have my eye on the chandelier...lol Just love it with the sea shells & crystal 's.
We could not have asked for a more delicious meal! The seafood was excellent. All staff were attentive and very pleasant.
Delicious food! Amazing portions with great amounts of fresh seafood in each dish. Service with Ed was impeccable... very detail oriented and friendly. We will continue coming back.
We really enjoyed ourselves.
Food was excellent as always and our server Paige was fantastic!
food was delicious, ample amounts of salad, dinner and desserts.
Excellent all around. Highly recommend to all visiting the island