I love the Starlight...I've been countless times with both large groups and small and the service and food has always been outstanding.
The pricing on the menu is great, esp for such a nice atmosphere and the food is always fresh and locally sourced. The cocktails are really excellent too...and I love that the cocktail menu changes with the season. They also have a great patio in the back that's nice for summer dining.
And since it's 21 and over only, we never have to sit by any screaming kids! Added bonus!
Foodwise I recommend the fries with aioli (YUM...thin, crispy, salty...), the burger and the Jidori Chicken. They've become my standbys even though I've enjoyed a lot of other items on the menu.