St. Paul Fish Company - Mequon
Enjoy our famous Lobster Roll, one of our five varieties of Fish Fry, or another of our wide selection of delicious seafood options. And after your meal, be sure to stop in our retail and deli area where you can find all the same amazing fish in our fresh fish display to prepare at home.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required
We both enjoyed the halibut. My husband had the grilled and I had the blackened. We had them with the butter sauce. Both of our dinners were fantastic.
The fish was prepared perfectly and served with a medley of vegetables and rice. Everything was delicious!
Just a very good seafood restaurant with a nice bar, very large selection of draft beers, and a larger selection is seafood both fish and shellfish. Cod fish fry is excellent.
Bar staff awesome! Our waiter was so pleasant and polite!!!
The food is good. We had the walleye fish fry and grilled shrimp. Both were served hot. It would be nice if they could turn up the temperature. It is cold on the dining room
Although I would normally rate it highly, this visit was disappointing. My lobster roll was served on dry, cool bread, although the lobster filling was good alone. I missed that warm, fluffy bread!
The food was great and as usual our waiter Robert was great too!
Although road noise from very busy Mequon Road makes conversation a challenge, we were able to enjoy our meal on Tuesday on the enclosed patio. Cocktails and wine were good, the food was very good as always, from lobster rolls to fish dishes. The menu offers a great selection, something for everyone, we have never been disappointed. The restaurant was very busy and kept our server hopping, but she remained friendly and apologetic for any delay. Not a problem as we enjoyed a leisurely dinner with friends.
We love the service , quality of everything & everyone that touched our table !!
Didier runs this place like a Swiss Army knife !
No loss ends - we were seated at our reservation time ! Promptly greeted at our table & everything was beyond “delish” !! Thanks for a great evening!
First table seated was terrible. In “patio” corner, next to wall with huge draft. Other side of table, large stand up propane heater. Too noisy and blasting heat. After talking to hostess, we were seated at great two top inside. That patio table should NOT be used.
Food excellent as always. Large portions and great value. Server very brusk, must have been busy night(it was)
Great food. Great service. Great value. Where else in Milwaukee can you get a 15 dollar lobster?
The food was awesome and the server was friendly and helpful.
Great ambience, great price, if you love seafood its the place to go !
We loved driving up to Mequon and the food at St.Paul's was great!
Anthony our waiter was fabulous!
He recommended the scallops appetizer, oysters Rockefeller, and the lobster
rolls were all tasty!
Cocktails were also very good and so were the oyster shooters!
We will be back for sure!
From the receptionist to the server and the food, everything was excellent. We will surely be back when we were in town. We are all the way from Romeoville, Illinois.
Great, safe, fun - Jade was a terrific server!
Very good experience and quality food. Guests were impressed.
Food and place was great! Restaurant did not receive or acknowledge my notes I entered into Open Table when rez was made. They made no fan fair of my moms big bday dinner. Boo.
Great seafood in Milwaukee at an affordable price. Love the grouper.
Always excellent food! Service was fast and efficient.
Everything was good, crab legs were good value and tasty. The shrimp cocktail was good value, I just prefer a different sauce. The bay scallop appetizer was good.
Food was excellent as always.
It was loud but what do you expect for a Friday night.
Waitress was not friendly or attentive. Food was excellent, service was terrible
Great night. Server was on point, and made good recommendations. Food was excellent and a good value.
The food is fantastic. I highly recommend the Calamari Steak appetizer and the Lobster Roll. I've been here many times and the food is always great. Service is excellent. Only complaint is that it is consistently COLD in the restaurant. Wear warm clothes and enjoy great food and service.
We had to wait a bit for our table as the greeter had seated a party before us that had arrived late. However, this was not a problem as some of our party was also late. The service was nonexistent to begin. Once we made staff notice us, service was excellent, and the restaurant even paid for our appetizers! All the fish (oysters, crab, catfish, shrimp, and cod) was very fresh and well prepared. The atmosphere is casual -- perfect for this type of menu. A great value!!!
Amazing happy hour and great food! They have a lot of covid protocols in place to feel extra safe. The margaritas were unbelievable and so was the lobster roll. Cannot wait to go back soon!!
Very good seafood in a nice clean atmosphere. Have enjoyed them since they were just downtown. Happy to have one out by us now!
The food came quickly and the service was great. Dinner was wonderful. The New England Lobster Boil took me back to growing up in Connecticut. The steamed clams were superb. We will be going back. Next time I want the Seafood Boil !!!
Very good service on a Friday night. Food and drink were delivered in a timely manner. Food was hot. The decor is fun "sea" themed. The menu is huge. Many choices for a Friday fish fry both grilled and deep fried options. Fresh seafood in the market as you enter. You can purchase and take home to cook.
I had the walleye and my wife had the cod. the food was good but I wish it would have been put on a plate instead of a basket and had some bread with it.
Wonderful as usual
Exceptional - swordfish w salsa; scallops v good. Nice service.
We had a great family night at St Paul!!! Great Fresh Fish and an amazing time
Great fish fry and appetizers. Good ambiance. Easy to make a reservation.
We had Friday fish fry, lobster roll, crab boil. Tuna melt, the best and most satisfying was crab boil, Tuna melt was great, perch fry was good. Lobster roll had too much celery and we prefer warm buttery roll. Overall. Go it was grest
Awesome seafood!!! Loved visiting them at the Public Market in Milwaukee and excited they now have a restaurant!
Best seafood and value anywhere. We always make a point to come here when in the area. Great selection and the prices are amazing for what you get.
The grouper sandwich was delicious, the gumbo very tasty. I asked for seating out of traffic due to hearing loss but was seated right in the middle of it. We ate late so as soon as 3-4 tables left, I could hear better. Ask for a booth or seating toward the back. Other than that, we will visit again.
St. Paul Fish Company - Mequon offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (262) 200-9909.
St. Paul Fish Company - Mequon is rated 4.6 stars by 231 OpenTable diners.
St. Paul Fish Company - Mequon does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.stpaulfish.com/gift-card/.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.