St. Paul Fish Company - Mequon

Service was excellent and food was good, too. I will go again.

From competent staff to excellent food, St. Paul Fish Company is the place to go for seafood.

We had dinner there. The food was delicious and the service was very friendly and efficient. We will definitely dine there, again.

Best social distancing place we've been to. Many thanks to wait staff!!!

The only complaint is that I wanted the lobster bisque and was told it had been removed from the menu. Guess I will need to go to the restaurant in Milwaukee for the lobster bisque.

One of the better seafood restaurants in the Milwaukee area. An odd location in terms of the population or otherwise a very safe bet.

I highly suggest St. Paul's to any seafood lover. The food is always amazing and the location is perfect for any event from a romantic evening to a celebration of achievement! I so love this place!

We sat outside and it was a perfect temperature. The food was outstanding and reasonable.

We had crab cake sandwich and cod fish fry. The cod was the best fish fry we’ve ever had. Light, crispy coating, a pile of thin perfect fries at a price less than other places we’ve been. The crab cake sandwich was tasty but thought it could have been more crisp and a little more crab chunks. Service was fast and friendly. Love the decor and the food is always good.

The best surf clams, grouper cheeks and po-boys around. Service was excellent and would recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants great seafood.

Food was fresh and delicious.
Had the sea bass and ahi tune dinners.

Noise at 530 from traffic a bit annoying.

Will go back again.

Love this place. Can't wait to go back.
Will bring friends next time.

Robert our waiter was great and the food was excellent. We will be back. The new dining plan was was well arranged.

Very good food quality and low prices for seafood.

The food was very tasty, served quickly, and presented in a pleasant way. Our server was very friendly and attentive. Love the atmosphere and seating options. Would definitely recommend it!

Excellent restaurant! Fabulous seafood and for a good price! We had the lobster dinner and everything on the plate including the fries and coleslaw were perfect!

Nice to get back to dining in a restaurant again! The dining room was set up well for social distancing and the waitstaff was pleasant and following rules. Food was great, as always!

Have dined at St Paul Fish Company several times and have NEVER been disappointed or have a bad word to say about it. The food is outstanding and the service is great. I look forward to going back again real soon. Under the current circumstances (restrictions) they have done an excellent job in there seating arrangement and there food service. If you have never had the Calamari steak (appetizer) you don't know what your missing.

The business was very careful after everything with the virus. Our silverware was brought to us sealed. Our waitress had a mask on and made sure not to touch the sides of the plates. I was impressed by how much work they were doing to make sure the guests were well taken care of and safe.

Two of us had the clam chowder and it was a bit soupy and not many clams

Delicious beyond oceans !

Service excusably slow due to first day opening since Covid

But waiter super understanding and kept us flowing with humor and food credit

Love this place!

St Paul Fish Market is a definite must go to restaurant!! Everything on the menu is awesome. I love the lobster roll. The staff is great and knowledgeable. 5 star restaurant.

This was our first in person dining experience post-COVID. We sat outside. The waiter was great and the food was fabulous, as always. Can’t wait to go back.

We had never had the fish fry so decided to do the schiltz battered cod......battered way to heavy for our liking.

Beckys bday lunch

Consistently good food and service! Nice atmosphere conducive to dinner conversation even with large group.

First time at this location; food was delicious, shark bite appetizer great

Food was fabulous! Eunice was attentive and friendly! Thank you!!

We really enjoyed our meal at St. Paul. It’s a great place!

No one would believe a seafood restaurant could be so popular and so excellent from the kitchen. The decor and architecture of the place is interesting, but the NOISE LEVEL IS DEAFINING! It undermined the enjoyment of the evening—however—the food was truly excellent and the kitchen staff and general manager deserve a lot of credit for making such a busy place work so well. Please hire an acoustic engineer!!

This is one of our favorite places!

The King Crab Legs (a special on Wednesdays for $20) was excellent. They give you a shell cracker and a scissors (which worked for me) but my son wished they had split the legs before serving.

My SPECIAL favorite is the Calamari Steak. It's listed as an appetizer but I like to order it as an entree. It's coated in crunchy Parmesan and is deliciously tender with a fabulous flavor. Before St Paul Fish Co you could only get this dish at the River Lane Inn in Brown Deer (before it closed) or at Timmer's Resort.

Next time I'm going to order the fried clams. I heard they are as good as the clams they used to serve at Howard Johnson's in the old days.

SO glad I am now able to make reservations using Open Table. When they first opened you had to stand in line for an hour to get a table.

One thing though - it is REALLY loud. Don't go there if you want to have an intimate conversation with your table mates.

Already told my friends(and enemies) to frequent this place. I did enjoy my experience there . I shall return.

It was very good food and a good place eat all types of seafood. I would go there again. If going on a Friday I would make a Reservation because of Lent. It was a little loud in the restaurant but it was also very busy due to being a Friday for Lent and my Wife and I expected that. The Mako Shark was very good and so was the King crab legs.

Enjoyed the fresh fish in a great environment. Mequon has become much more lively and its refreshing to have restaurants like St Paul Fish Company be a part of the community. The only suggestion is that they upgrade from plastic plates to real china and perhaps upgrade the flatware as well. On the other hand, maybe that was intentionally a part of the decor?

My husband and I love this restaurant. We moved here from Boston @ 5 years ago and were in search of great seafood. Since discovering St. Paul's, we eat here a couple of times a month. We love it!

Excellent - Brien our host was very efficient and attentive and made our visit anxious to repeat!

Reservations are a good move on a Friday night during the Lenten Season! We had a drink at the bar. The bartender was very friendly and knowledgeable. Our dinner was delicious and the service was great. (I had the mahi mahi.) I will certainly go back.

The food has been good each time we have been there (many times) but we would like something other than rice or french fries. i.e. potato wedges, baked potato, etc.

2 of 4 meals were excellent and the other 2 were good, need to keep the fries crispy and make sure the shrimp don't clump together. It was busy, service was ok. Going on slower nights ALWAYS recommend.

(...) good time ! I really recommend for everyday dining. 😋