Excellent value. Food is wonderful. Prices are very modest!!
Thank You service teams Love you guys what a wonderful service specially Manager Mr Emir how he taking care every single guest see you soon
Excellent, tasty and friendly - and really as welcoming as always!
We ate outside in their sidewalk shelter and felt adequately separated from other diners. Service was excellent although dessert was a little slow in arriving but the banana bread pudding was worth the wait. Food was excellent!
The food was fantastic and the restaurant is quite lovely. We were not rushed nor did we feel the slightest bit uncomfortable as all the tables were socially distanced . The wait staff was very attentive. I would go back there in a heartbeat!
Service and food at Siena was excellent - as usual!
In June of 2021, I brought and treated my wife and myself for dinner at the Siena Cafe.
We were warmly welcomed by the restaurant’s staff and wonderfully treated by our waitress.
Both my wife and I very much enjoyed our meals and we definitely appreciated the COVID safety protocols carried out by the restaurant’s staff, such as the social distancing of guests and the wearing of masks by the restaurant’s staff.
Both my wife and I highly recommend for everyone to visit this wonderful cuisine!!!
Overall it was a good experience but the service was very uneven. Only half of our appetizer plates had been cleared when our entrees were served. A busboy reached across the plate of someone who was eating to take away a dish. It took a very long time for dessert and coffee to be served as well.
That being said, the food was delicious. The portions were generous and we all enjoyed our meals. The only miss were the cannolis - they were dry and half-filled.
Siena Cafe is a great spot! The decor is super cute and the outdoor space is lovely! The service is great and attentive. Food is delicious and there are a lot of great options to try. I can't wait to go back!
New job and promotion
One of the best place for Dinner Drinks and hangout
Good neighborhood Italian restaurant.
Service was horrible. They did not write our order down and got everything wrong. The waitress was pushy and very rude. Stay away from this place. The guys in the kitchen were smoking pot and the place reeked.
We found Siena Cafe to be as wonderful as always, and as always it lived up to its quality over time. One of us often buys an entree or two to take home for the week!
We ordered 2 starters and 2 entrees with wine.
Caesar-Kale salad- Average; needed more dressing and vinegar, as it needed a balance of tartness.
Salmon tartare- came on a bed of mushed-up guacamole; did not look or taste fresh (we came on Labor Day weekend)
Pasta with Mushrooms-best dish of our dinner, but needed more seasoning. Pasta appeared home-made and was properly served al dents.
Salmon- ordered Med-rare; came out well-done. They kindly RE-did the order; it also was overdone and tasteless..
Wine- the super Tuscan...not so good!
The restaurant did a very nice job of the new outdoor area, complete with living plants and dividers. Really liked this!
Stick to their home-made pastas and you’ll be happy!
The food is delicious, service was good however half of our meals arrived and then there was a delay for the others to arrive.
Service was terrible - had to wait forever to order, one order didn’t come and they didn’t go check on it for a long time even though we told them. The lox was very poor. Avocado toast wasn’t toasted.
Service was slow but everything was good for the most part! The sangria tasted like straight wine rather than sangria- but for the bottomless brunch not a bad price/ deal at all!!! Nice atmosphere as well.
I think the waitress forgot to put our order in. After over an hour without food we were not happy. Our waitress would walk by the table and not look at us.
So very disappointed!
Always have an amazing experience at Siena. Great food, amazing staff and a really nice environment. The outdoor setup was perfect even on a rainy day.
Entrees took Tom long to come. They came after 3 other tables seated after us.
Then the food was cold.
We just to left without eating but they did comp us
Draft beers taste so much better here for some reason! Food was good , I didn't realize the shrimp scampi did not come with pasta, it was just okay. The black fettuccine was very good. I will definitely be back to try other dishes.
the outdoor space is perfect for an afternoon brunch. the avocado toast came to the table cold and had the poached eggs i asked to hold. other than that, i enjoyed my leisurely brunch with a friendly staff.
Terrible service Clam appetizer got cold. Crowded outside and very noisy to which they added loud music
Horrible horrible service
Food was good
Always great - dependable, and lovely. I feel at home here!
Delicious food and excellent service!
The manager was amazing. The staff was attentive and it was an overall great experience.
Excellent outdoor dining with great food and drinks! Perfect for weekend brunch with friends.
Service and food both excellent. Every plate was distinctly tasty and the service was very attentive. We ate outside and their set up on the street is very nice. A good time all around. Thanks, Siena!
2 dishes were good and 2 were not good at all.
There was confusion around my reservation. We wanted to be outdoors. The restaurant accommodated our request during a very busy Friday night. The service and food were amazing. We had a great time.
The food was very, very good. The maitre d was very accommodating. It was lively, very well priced. I look forward to returning.
One of our favorite places on the Upper East Side! Great drinks and try the banana bread pudding.
Fabulous Food, STAFF and everything is just great!
A gem of a neighborhood restaurant. I would recommend it.
Siena is always great - and I recommend it whole heartedly!
We had a delicious birthday dinner! Excellent service.
We have been to Siena Cafe three weeks in a row now and it’s quickly becoming our go-to for Sunday brunch. Their bottomless brunch is the best deal in the city. It is very family friendly. And the food is great. We plan to go back many more times
Siena is always great - and Jimmy is a great host - saving our favorite table without my asking!
Siena Cafe does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Siena Cafe also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 410-5588.
Siena Cafe is rated 4.4 stars by 270 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.