Our Signature Carbonara
Homemade spaghetti in a creamy egg sauce with pancetta & tossed in a wheel of Grana Padano cheese, set on fire
Tagliatelle Sicilia Mia
Homemade tagliatelle with mixed seafood infused with white wine & a touch of tomato sauce
Tris di Pasta
Gnocchi Quattro Formaggi Ravioli Burro e Salvia Tagliatelle al Tartufo
So many of our favorite restaurants seem to be struggling with servers and food quality right now (all understandable given the pandemic) so we went hesitatingly hoping one of our top favorites wouldn’t also disappoint. SO happy to have seen the slight remodel inside (love it!) and the service and food quality exceeded anything we’ve experienced recently. Kudos to the restaurant for not just weathering these hard times but also providing exceptional service and food. We can’t wait to come back.
The service alone is worth every penny. I’ll go back just for that.
Tableside Carbonara is *the* signature dish. Bruschetta is done as a pizza, great for a group.
If you want real authentic Italian food, with amazing service and genuine experience, you must eat here! Can’t wait to go back!
This was my first time eating here and I must say that it is one of the best meals I’ve ever eaten in my life!! Their carbonara is so delicious and i doubt it will ever disappoint. I highly recommend this restaurant!
True Italian fine dining at its best. The attention to detail and customer care is top notch as well. We left happy and sated.
The food was excellent. It was a unique experience as well. Overall we thoroughly enjoyed the food and service and we look forward to returning to try some other things on the menu.
The food was just awesome! Plan to go back shortly.
Our waiter Stine was very nice and provided excellent service. All of the staff were also very nice. All of the food was excellent and the presentation was very good. We will definitely be back on our next trip to SLC.
Had such a wonderful experience and the food was amazing. Our waiter had the coolest personality and was so welcoming. Love this place.
One of the best restaurant experiences of my life, honestly. We went for my husband’s birthday and I can’t wait to go back. The service was perfect, the food was INCREDIBLE, our server gave us such great recommendations (the wine she suggested made our already incredible food even better somehow!). My only regret is *not* getting the tiramisu so I’ll be getting it next time I go! I’ll recommend this place to everyone I know.
The staff goes out of their way to make this a comfortable friendly environment.
Carbonara is the best. Wonderful waitstaff. Could use a better location. Would love to see them somewhere with outdoor dining. Very noisy.
Server was knowledgeable and professional, food was amazing. As usual. This place is fantastic.
Tha carbonara did not disappoint! Our waitress was darling and the entire staff was charming. Can’t wait to make our next reservation!
The salad and pasta were delicious. My sweet daughter came into town with her husband and this is where she wanted to have dinner,
An Italian restaurant, run by Italians. Great food, slow pace, wonderful!
The staff was GREAT! My order was taking a little longer than expected, which I didn’t mind because I had a salad and there was bread to snack on, but 1 of the staff members broke out in song to make the time go faster. All in all it was a great experience. Food was good, staff was GREAT!!! Prices were a little for us, but we will go back in special occasions.
Waiter was very attentive and knowledgeable. He made it a very nice experience.
Marcus is an outstanding waiter. Very attentive and described anything on the menu and wine. He’s a winner
In my humble opinion this is the best Italian restaurant in Salt Lake City if not all of Utah. Markus was our server and he is Simply Amazing.
Our anniversary dinner was lovely!
Sicilia Mia has an incredible atmosphere of delicious food, great staff (our server was perfect with his recommendations), and pricing. We would recommend Sicilia Mia to anyone who enjoys authentic Italian food.
This is one of my favourite restaurants in Salt Lake. The food was excellent as usual. Arena was a delightful server, personable and interesting. Lingered over our lunch for two hours!
Very surprised this visit and not in a good way. Everyone was very friendly and we were seated immediately which was great. However, we were never offered fresh pepper or parmigiano reggiano on either salads or entrees. Our entire party ordered appetizers, salads, entrees and a dessert and left hungry. (In past visits this has never been the case, the portion sizes have definitely changed.) Also, couldn't believe for each bottle of wine there was a $20 corking fee. This use to be the place we come for special occasions with friends or family but this visit was definitely underwhelming and disappointing. If we do decide to give it another chance we won't bring our nice wine and expect to ask for Pepper and Parmesan.
I was pretty disappointed with this restaurant. We have heard good things about it, but did not see what others have mentioned. To start, when we got sat, it took about 10 min for our waitress to even come over to come get us started which was disappointing. Also, the food looked great online, and portions looked great, but when we got what we had seen online it was nowhere near how big it looked online, I could’ve eaten my entire portion in probably one bite, not to mention how expensive it was for that. To top it off they didn’t even have their pizza chef there so I couldn’t order any type of pizza which was shocking as well. I would think they’d have a pizza chef at every location. Overall not happy with the experience and won’t be going back.
The food was fabulous! Service was good. I would only discount it a little based on atmosphere. The food made up for it, for certain. 👍🏼👍🏼
Fantastic wait staff, incredible food. Great place to take a date
The best Italian food I’ve had since being in Italy. So good! Flavorful, fresh, and excellent wines for pairing. Truly an amazing experience.
The food was excellent, our Italian server enhanced our experience, and he suggested the double portion of Cesar salad which was enough for four of us. We celebrated two birthdays and though no recognition was given, that was fine.
Lovely dinner. Great service!!
Had a great experience. Had the special that had porcini mushrooms and truffle ravioli. It was out of this world. Kudos to the chef for an amazing dish
Good food - unfortunately the chef did not make it, somewhat constraining the selection! Nevertheless, I will be back.
Nos atendieron muy bien, Camila fue extraordinaria y la cómoda muy buena.
The food was delicious and the service was so personal. Plan on spending a while there but the food is worth the wait!
If you are looking for authentic, delicious Italian food this is the place!!
Their air conditioning was not working. Very warm in the restaurant. The bread was stale. And they have decreased their portion sizes and raised their prices. Overall disappointing.
The food was INCREDIBLE. We will be thinking about that meal for years. The special that night was the Gorgonzola, pear, and shrimp fettuccine in an amazing white sauce. The tableside carbonara was exceptional as well. We will be back, soon!!
We made a reservation almost 2 weeks in advance, and instead of being seated in the two main seating areas, were seated in front of the door by the bar. Service was excellent, food was incredible, but the seating was unjustified being their were 4 tops available in the dining area.
Excellent food and service!
Sicilia Mia is rated 4.8 stars by 882 OpenTable diners.
Sicilia Mia does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.siciliamiautah.com.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.