Terrible service. We waited for 5 minutes to be seated without anyone ever greeting us. Waiting 20 minutes to order. And had to walk my card up to pay because we waited 15 min between anyone coming to our table. Super disappointed. the food was really good but service was not worth it.
Love the neighborhood feel. The food is very good. Would recommend it.
The food was superb! We started with the Arancine, and wished we’d ordered two, not because there weren’t enough but because they were so delicious!!! For entrees we had the Carbonara and the Gnocchi and couldn’t decide which was better! Watching them toss the Carbonara in a wheel of cheese was a unique and fun addition to the experience. Our food was hot, the portions were large and the service was wonderful. It was the perfect way to spend Valentine’s Day and we will definitely be going back!
The service was excellent, great sever, excellent prepared meal and reasonably priced.
We arrived for our reservation on Valentine’s Day only to be told the chef had not shown up for work and they weren’t opening the doors. Nor did they have any idea when the chef may or may not show. Luckily, we stuck around in our car and they opened 10 minutes later. If only the greeting had been as great as our server, this rating would be higher.
Sicilia Mia Holladay has been our go to special occasion spot since we moved back to Salt Lake City in 2015. It was like visiting my friend's home when I was growing up and his Nonna was cooking in the kitchen. The staff is attentive and always have excellent advice for those unfamiliar with real Italian food. The presentation is always superb and the Carbonara made table side is a real show. Love coming here and will continue to do so and recommend to all of my friends, family and acquaintances. The Savas family.
Food was the best part. Server seemed preoccupied and disinterested. Even with a reservation and half of the restaurant empty, we was seated right by the door.
Low score was due to a 5- minute wait in spite of a reservation. Otherwise, I would give it. A 41/2.
good food, but a little pricey. wait staff was terrific. easy parking
Was such an amazing time! The. Atmosphere Was wonderful and our sereve was a doll! We will be going back again!!
My husband and I have been a few times and have usually had a great experience but this time I took my mother in law for a little girls night and it was her first time. We both ordered carbonara and our meals were prepared with the table behind us and no one bothered to tell us as it was lit on fire etc. So instead of experiencing the table side service, our meals were delivered without us knowing they had been prepared. It would have been fine if someone had mentioned it to us and we would have turned around to watch, not as great as being at our table but at least we would have been able to experience it. It just kind of ruined the entire experience. Of course the food was still phenomenal!
Excellent food, great service - love, love, love this place
Amazing food and reasonably priced lunch menu. You need to call ahead for a reservation but the little extra effort is worth it. I've not had better Italian in Utah.
Amazing. Loved the warm cozy atmosphere and beyond delicious authentic food.
This place is absolutely amazing! I can’t eat any other kind of Italian food. This food has spoiled me.
Great food! Our server, Alex, was very attentive. It was very busy, but with our reservation the wait for our table was less than 10 minutes. I found our table a little small, but good food & service definitely ruled the evening.
Excellent food, great service, overall great experience! Will return again for sure!
Great service and good. Would recommend it to anyone who loves Italian food.
We were running late for our reservation because we locked our keys in the car. It was my boyfriend's birthday and he had been looking forward to trying this place for a long time. We were so glad we that they were accommodating and kind even though we were late. The whole waitstaff took great care of us. Plus, all the food was delicious!
Always delicious and the Mia crew make you feel like family.
Great service staff. Thank you.
I always love going to Sicilia Mia. Best Italian food outside of Italy!
We love love love this place!! We drive all the way from American fork to go.
This is one of my favorite places to go! I love the pasta and pizza. Desserts are heavenly!
Love the food, love the staff. Great management, keep up the great work!!
Eduardo, Andréa, and crew were absolutely amazing, as always! Our “little sister” was visiting for her birthday and we brought her in for her first Sicilia Mia experience. They made it such a special one for her❤️
Colette and I love you so much!!
We always have a great experience at Sicilia Mia! The food is amazing and the staff is great!
Fantastic. Authentic. We just got back from vacation in Italy and the Carbonara at Sicilia Mia was better than while on vacation!
Cousin was in n town...
Sicilia Mia is amazing! Our favorite place for special occasions. The staff makes you feel like family. Eduardo and Giuseppe are fantastic.
Worst service I’ve ever had, for how much we spent. We waited several minutes to be served water, then waited several minutes longer to have our drink order taken. The first thing our server says to us is, “I have a big table to help so I’m just going to take your orders real quick. Do you know what you want?” Haha.
The food was spectacular, yes, but the young server we had couldn’t have been less interested in waiting on us. Be prepared for larger groups to take priority over a two top.
Always wonderful! The hot spinach salad is always, always wonderful. The fried calamari and shrimp appetizer are light, flavorful, and cooked beautifully; tender, NOT rubber, served with wonderful warm marinara sauce. Pastas are tender and NOT over cooked. Dessert - fabulous!
Always dependable food. Never eaten a bad meal Lunch or dinner is delicious.
Family run business, very authentic Italian atmosphere. Don't let the strip mall location fool you their signature dish, spaghetti carbonara is excellent. Prepared fresh right in front of you, very authentic, very cheesey. The waitstaffs attention to your needs is excellent, very warm and friendly. They have excellent pizza!
We especially enjoyed visiting with the lady assigned to our table.
I brought a few of my girlfriends here to experience the food as I’ve been here several times and consider this place a favorite. We had a great time there. Never once felt rushed to eat and leave. We were able to eat the most delicious food and visit as long as we desired. The service was great too. Never felt neglected by our servers or rushed to hurry and leave. Now all my friends want to bring their spouses too!