Our Signature Carbonara
Homemade spaghetti in a creamy egg sauce with pancetta & tossed in a wheel of Grana Padano cheese, set on fire
Tagliatelle Sicilia Mia
Homemade tagliatelle with mixed seafood infused with white wine & a touch of tomato sauce
Sicilia Mia Antipasto Caldo
Fried calamari, shrimp & sardines, fried mozzarella panelle, croquette, arancini salmone & arancini tradizionali
New Year's Eve Special Menus & Offers
we will be ready to serve you with a big smile and a lot of good food come see us
Great food. Great atmosphere. Excellent service.
Love Sicilia mia! My favorite Authentic Italian food
All around amazing! Already planning my next visit.
Sicilia Mia is hands-down the best Italian food in the Salt Lake Valley!
A consistently great experience at this restaurant. Fast, efficient service and high quality food is a winner. We had the lasagna and the Taliatelle Ragu Della Nonna; both were excellent. But, I think their signature Carbonara is their best entree.
Everything was great but I think their wine is over priced. I am not a wine expert so my complaint may not be valid.
Excellent food, service and ambiance. Our first time - we'll be back.
The food is outstanding, delicious and well presented. Our server was personable and the interaction was great. It’s our go to place in Salt Lake City.
Excellent and authentic Italian, reasonably priced, fabulous desserts
Our dog died and it was good comfort food
Servers and chef was amazing. Food was fresh perfect quality.. and all the staff members were polite. We loved it and will definitely come back!
The Spaghetti A'Matriciana was excellent, made with panchetta. No carved tips of pig cheeks, as in Rome. (Stanley Tucci) I don't think I missed out.
We love this place!!! The food is always fantastic! My only two complaints this last visit - rather picky - the waiter didn't know the name of one of the specials and did not really describe it well either, and the Calamari & Gamberi was, well, the shrimp was excellent, the tentacles were great, but the calamari rings were bland and rubbery. Everything else was 6 star outstanding!
Ashley was my hostess/server and she was very attentive.
This is the best Italian food I've found in Utah, but the service was so slow that I spent the second half of dinner with an empty water glass and no attention. It also took over 20 minutes to get the check and get it paid.
Maybe they're just understaffed at the moment, or understaffed on Mondays, but don't go if you need to be anywhere within an hour of when you would expect to leave, and bring a couple bottles of water so you can refill your own glass when they don't.
Excellent food and service!
Always an amazing experience! Thanks Jesse for the great service!
Service and food always amazing.
We had a great experience and will return in the near future.
Best Italian food I have had in Utah. Being from NY where there are plenty of great Italian Restaurants Sicilia MIa compare to the best of them.
We had a great meal, consistent attention from the wait staff, and a really pleasant evening.
Took my fiancé here for her birthday and it was literally the coolest place ever. Great service, even better food, and amazing singing by the GM. Felt like we were transported to another country. Will go again.
2nd time coming here. 22nd wedding anniversary celebration. From the hostess to our incredible server everything was about what we were expecting. His kindness, attention to the smallest detail was above and beyond. I would recommend anything and everything with this place to anyone. I actually felt like I offended them by finishing my meal so quickly. I/we will be back over and over again and again. Love it here!
One of our favorite places. Have never been disappointed in anything we’ve ordered. The bruschetta appetizer is a must.
The best past I have ever had, will be back to try more options
Food and service was excellent. Calamari, Carbonara, and Della Nonne pasta were fresh and simply fantastic. One of our new favorite places now.
We had a reservation for four people and earlier in the day two other friends wanted to join us. I called and they didn’t have a reservation for six but assured me they could make it work. I know a lot of places would just say no and I really appreciated that they went out of their way to make it work for us.
Stein was our server and he was very attentive, thorough and efficient. It was my wife’s birthday and she hates when restaurants sing to her (doesn’t like the attention). Stein was awesome and discreetly brought a single candle with her dessert and wished her a happy birthday. It was really cool.
The food is always good here. I highly recommend Sicilia Mia
The food is delicious and the service is the best.
Excellent Italian food, we have been there many times and it is always the same quality.
Don’t let the location fool you as you drive up to the Maceys parking lot, this restaurant is wonderful!! We took a chance after seeing some compelling food photos and didn’t regret one bite of it! The service was impeccable, Francesco makes your time there feel special as if you’re dining with an old friend. The carbonara is not to be missed, although the rest of the menu looks phenomenal as well. My husband got a rib eye special with a creamy pesto sauce and I was blown away with how delicious it was. We finished the meal with a fabulous tiramisu. Overall, highly recommend for a casual date or a fun night with friends
Amazing food and amazing service. Will be going again and again
We were so impressed with this place! The food was amazing and we’ll definitely be back!!
We had the best time! Went for my mom’s birthday and Markus was the sweetest and so knowledgeable! The food was so delicious and I cannot wait to go back!
Got overwhelmed with the waiting staff suggestions.
My new favorite restaurant!! The food is absolutely delicious.
Great atmosphere and good food. Only complaint was the corking fee was $20. Excessive.
Food was unreal and the staff was great! Dang happy birthday in Italian
The food is always very delicious, the music is a loud when you are trying to carry on a conversation. I feel some of the portions are not equal to the price you pay.
We have been there several times for special occasions
This place was absolutely lovely. The atmosphere and service was amazing and the food was even better!
Great food and great service. Will definitely be coming back very soon.
The service alone is worth every penny. I’ll go back just for that.
Sicilia Mia is rated 4.8 stars by 922 OpenTable diners.
Sicilia Mia does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.siciliamiautah.com.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.