Permanently Closed - Sicilia Mia - Cottonwood
Restaurants you may also like
Primo Restaurant - Salt Lake City
I had not been to this restaurant in a while. I had a great evening. The decor is charming , warm and inviting. Our waiter was fun and efficient. The food was just delicious. I had the salmon with olives capers etc. Can't remember the name but it was the nicest salmon I've had at a restaurant in a long time. ... I'll be back sooner rather than later to this little spot.
We love this restaurant chain. They never disappoint. This was a new location for us to try. The only trying feature was the parking. We were lucky to find a spot in their parking lot. Otherwise, everything else was great and we ended up closing down the restaurant as we were the last patrons to leave. Jerry was entertaining and funny. His service tableside was fantastic.
It was amazing!
My adult son and I had a great experience. Caprese salad was not on the menu but the waitress
said she thought she could get it done and it was beautiful. Great pasta, good wine for an affordable
Omg, I could eat here every day :)
Our favorite spot! Ordered the special ravioli and it was amazing
It started out lovely but then kind of went downhill. I swear the mashed potatoes were instant mash, which seemed so surprising considering the seemingly-high quality of the rest of the food. But then I was questioning the rest of the meal--was it all just prepackaged stuff? The service was great.
Cozy and welcome, The food was amazing 5 star amazing
The employees here don’t give a crap lol you expect sort of a refined restaurant with how good the food is. Waiter treated us like he wanted us the hell out. Wouldn’t go back, I care too much about overall dining experience to care that their Italian food was quite good. It was cold and awkward inside that little place.
Waiter Jerry and the manager I spoke to ruined the whole dining experience for my family tonight. After Jerry has already brought my daughter a cocktail, he had the audacity to ask her if she was having a boy or girl? My daughter pointed to her 17 month old baby sitting next to her and said he’s a boy. Jerry said no and pointed to her belly and again asked if she was having a boy or girl? My daughter was so embarrassed by him in front of our family and the restaurant. When I later quietly asked to speak to a manager on my daughter’s behalf, the manager dismissed my complaint saying “it must be a cultural thing.” Really!? (Jerry’s first language is not English so the manager blames his ethnicity?) I’ve seen more class and complaint management by chain/fast food restaurants. Absolutely no common sense and egregious behavior. Speaking of cents, Jerry I gave my daughter your tip. I asked her to do something fun and good for herself instead. I’ve never not left a tip no matter how bad service I’ve had, but you and your manager completely left a sour foul taste in my mouth. How dare you body shame a woman! Way to ruin our belated Valentines celebration. We were hurried out of the restaurant when we really wanted to linger and laugh together over coffee and dessert. Guess we are not worthy of even being asked if we’d like to have dessert?
Great food. Kim is fantastic server. Great ambiance. Loved the chicken Gorgonzola, salmon and gnocchi formaggi. Always quality food and service.
As always great service. Staff always makes us feel welcome. Consistently delicious food!
Jerry our waiter was fabulous And made my birthday by serenading me. He has a wonderful voice. Food was delicious!
One of best restaurants on the Wasatch Front. Atmosphere was great and service impeachable and food couldn't have been better.
The food is always amazing and the staff treats you like family!
It was nice we got the cardonara which was fantastic but they didn't do it in front of us. It was also super loud. They even sat us in front 9f the wine cabinet so every time they needed wine we had to shuffle around but the food was great
I so love the food but the service is off the charts
Buena comida y abundante
Amazing!!! The food is absolutely exceptional. I have to say it is by far the best Italian food in the whole valley. Also the service is ALWAYS exceptional. The entire staff always ensures that you have a wonderful experience. Thank for for the perfect birthday/dining experience.
Honestly initially the service was a little rough. Maybe it was an off day because there seemed to be a lot of indifference in regards to our table, maybe because we ordered water? For some reason our waiter was changed (we didn’t request it) and the following waiter was effortlessly charming and hilarious.
That being said, the food is unreal. Honestly it made me not even care about any other shortcomings. I had the Bistecca with mushrooms and I was absolutely blown away by the quantity and quality of the dish. Seriously the best steak I’ve had, ever, and we’ve been to Ruth’s Chris steakhouse. My wife got the Spaghetti Carbonara that gets completed in a wheel of cheese and again, I’ve never had a better dish and we were actually in Italy 3 months ago eating similar dishes. Seriously the food is so good that everyone needs to go there at least once. I wouldn’t even care if the waiters made fun of us the whole time or made fun of my own mother, the food is that good.
Food was fabulous, we will be back for more pasta and appetizers.
Authentic, delicious, casual!! Loved this on a trip to Utah last winter. I hope they make it through Covid and remain open. Support this family owned business. (From another Italian family who loved it)
Other locations are better. Very limited parking. Restaurant was cold and cramped.
Excellent food with excellent service! Love all of the Sicilia Mia locations
I would not recommend based on our most recent visit.
Great ambiance. Food is always excellent
First time to this location. We went there to celebrate three family members birthdays. The food was great, the atmosphere was great, the location was easy to find. The only thing that could be approved on was the service. A minor thing but, they would tease us about having bread they would be bring out, but never got any until reminding our server about it. It was a five star on everything else.
We had a wonderful birthday dinner. Everything that we tried was incredible! Best Bruschetta ever!!
Sadly this did not live up to the hype. I got the table side carbonara. The presentation was awesome but the pasta was on the cold side. Also the grilled artichoke just turned out to be warm marinated artichoke hearts. The service was great and I would go back to try something else but it was a bit of a let down.
Amazing food and fabulous service. A must to dine at if you enjoy Italian food and great service
We requested a corner table away from the front door and we were given the perfect table. The service was very attentive and the Lasagna is the best!!!
Poor experience. Both my wife & I had our entree delivered warm. My pasta was overcooked. I would expect overcooked pasta at a franchise restaurant, not here. Presentation was good. Service was good. We can’t even imagine going in the winter with the way the restaurant is laid out. Brrrrr.
Good Afternoon, I am sorry for your experience. At Sicilia Mia we strive for nothing but excellence. Fresh handmade pasta can feel overcooked, and it can overcook if kept 20 seconds more than needed. We are sorry to hear that it was not up to your, and ours, standards. We do have heating and a fireplace for winter, so for a place that small it should not be an issue. We invite you back, to make your experience a memorable one! Giro Messeri General Manager
Usually better than this. However, on this visit, we were forgotten. When we arrived, there were only about 4 other tables seated. We were seated and then forgotten for at least 30 minutes. People came in after and were served their food before they even took our order. Our table was right in front so wait staff had to notice we had not been helped. It did get busy but it was just an odd experience since we had a reservation and mostly empty when we were seated.
Make it bigger. They were turning people away at 5:30 pm because they did not have a reservation.
Great service. Authentic and delicious food.
The food was fabulous and our service was great. We will definitely be eating there again!
40th Wedding Anniversary we had a great time. The staff was wonderful. The food was delicious! Will definitely go back!
The food was amazing and so was the service. They were out of some of the items we had planned to order, but we were still happy with our alternate selections.
We have eaten here three times and every time there are issues with our order and giving us what we did not ask for. They immediately offer a free desert which amounts to one choice. The same routine all three times. Food is average at best and not worth the aggravation. Highly overrated.
Permanently Closed - Sicilia Mia - Cottonwood is rated 4.4 stars by 220 OpenTable diners.