Sicilia Mia - Cottonwood
We went to dinner Saturday night to celebrate my birthday. All 4 of us agreed that the entree's were delicious. The carbonara and cioppino were excellent. Unfortunately the waiter never checked back to see if we would like another drink. The meal fell apart with dessert. They came out covered in rainbow sprinkles and the tiramisu tasted like there was Hershey's chocolate sauce layered in. We also ordered coffee and it was terrible. I really expected more from the Best of Utah winner. I am disappointed to have spent quite a bit of money for a meh meal.
This location of Sicilia Mia is keeping up with the traditions of the other locations. Good food, and it's not too loud. It is small, so reservations are a MUST.
The food was amazing and the service was even better.
Excellent food. Staff was interactive and made it fun
We love the Sicilia Mia restaurants in Salt Lake! The new one in Cottonwood Heights certainly no exception. The food is fantastic, ambience great and wait staff attentive, thoughtful and fun! Make a point of trying this new Sicilia Mia in CH....
The food was amazing! The staff was so friendly! We will definitely be going back soon.
I have never been disappointed when dining at Sicilia Mia. The new Cottonwood location is a great addition to Cottonwood Heights.
We were blown away by this place. We walked in and 3 employees were have a passionate discussion in Italian- I was hooked from there!!! Service was excellent, food is fantastic. Weren't ready for the bill to be so much, but definitely worth the money
I love the new location. One suggestion, offer some entrees that aren't so rich. My husband and I would eat there more often if there were some lighter options.
Great food and atmosphere! Very friendly staff!!
Food and service are exceptional. It is a little loud. They should hang some curtains to dampen the noise and block the view of the gas station.
TOOK A CHANCE ON A NEW PLACE THIS PAST SATURDAY NIGHT AND IT WAS A WINNER. GREAT TO EAT DINNER WITH A STAFFF THAT LIVES AND BREATHES FOOD; NO HASH SLINGERS THERE.
VERY SMALL, ONLY 10 TABLES AND PARKING IS TIGHT. PROMPTLY SEATED AND SERVED. CEASAR SALAD WAS BIG ENOUGH FOR TWO. IN FACT, EVERYTHING WAS BIG ENOUGH FOR TWO; GENEROUS PORTIONS. FOOD WAS WONDERFUL. SERVICE WAS WONDERFUL. I HOPE THIS NEW PLACE CAN KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK.
Silcilia MIa is one of my new favorite places. I love how warm and inviting it is. They are so friendly and welcoming. But more importantly, the food was amazing!
Fantastic food. Staff made you feel like family/friends. Highly recommend.
Welcomed like we were family. Truly Italian welcome. Food was outstanding as well as service. You can’t go wrong here.
I’d rather go to one of their other restaurant locations next time. This one was so loud we couldn’t hear ourselves think let alone talk. The food was great as always but if that’s the same elsewhere I’d just assume avoid this location until they can put in some sound control. We had to give up on conversation altogether and sit in almost silence until we could leave.
Amazing food and service.
The food is amazing, the staff was friendly and very on top of things without being overbearing. The cozy atmosphere, with limited seating makes it perfect for a special occasion.
I went with three other women and we all enjoyed our evening at Sicilia Mia Cottonwood. The service was outstanding and the food and wine were excellent. It is a small space but didn't feel crowded and the noise level was very pleasant. I don't speak Italian so I can't remember the name of the dish I had, but it was a variety of seafood with pasta served in a cast iron skillet and was delicious!
Excellent homemade upscale Italian food. Welcome back Amici, the neighborhood missed you.
Always amazing. Great food. Excellent service.
Please open one un Utah county
The food, service, and ambiance were all excellent. Our server recommended a wine pairing which we particularly enjoyed. I recommend ordering several courses and sharing family style so as to sample many items without getting too full to enjoy them.
This is a fantastic addition to the Cottonwood Heights restaurant scene! This neighborhood locale is serving up some seriously delicious eats.
I cannot believe how lucky I was to discover this location the weekend it opened. I was not aware the other locations existed but they are on my radar now! Such a wonderful staff, such amazing food!! Not to casual (except for the one guy in hoodie, jeans and baseball cap who I hope felt out of place). We were greeted like we were family, and it just kept getting better from there! We had the spaghetti carbonara and oh my god it was amazing. I cannot wait to try many other menu items but my girlfriend and I agree that one of us will always get the carbonara.
The food was delicious and the staff was very helpful. Our server recommended an eggplant appetizer and an arugula salad which we split - both were wonderful (and we usually don’t like eggplant!) I had the ravioli and my husband had the Gorgonzola gnocchi and we cleaned our plates so well the chef teased us he no longer needed a dishwasher. Highly recommend!
Love the food. Love the people. So glad to have y’all in the neighborhood.