Featuring rustic Italian fare that wets the appetite, Serafina Broadway prepares the freshest pastas, pizzas, seafood and meats that are unparalleled in Midtown Manhattan. Serafina Broadway is the restaurant of choice for theater-goers, young professionals, neighborhood locals and seasoned Italian food enthusiasts.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
Fried calamari served with our homemade spicy tomato dip
Whole fresh calamari on a skewer with a bouquet of parsley & thyme
Pizza for the Table
A large square pizza served on a wood board with two toppings of your choice. Extra topping (Not available for any Gourmet Pizza-Buffalo-Burrata)
The cocktail menu wasn’t too big. Not a huge selection.
They seemed understaffed and frantic but inattentive. We could hardly get the waiters attention and it took so long for us to get what we asked. The fish we ordered was tuna and it had a horrible smell and taste definitely not fresh. We ordered slices of cake for my mother’s birthday and they had it sitting at the bar infront of us for way to long before handing it to us because they were looking for candles or something which was very embarrassing. very poor service.
Server seemed to be overloaded by the amount of tables attending to and therefore, we had to be calling/raising hand, getting up to get help when needing to order additional items.
It was good. I would go again
Went to Serafina for a Sunday lunch with a friend after we had just been shopping on Fifth Ave. The host was incredibly rude when we arrived — didn’t say much and in a scene from The Devil Wears Prada, just sort of flinged his hand to where we should sit outside. He, nor a waiter, walked us over to the table and so we just sat in one of the many open spots. While two waiters saw us sitting down, and after we requested service twice, it took them 20min before someone came to take our orders; we were ready to get up and leave but stayed. I tried to order a cocktail and was told they only serve wine and beer for lunch (it doesn’t say this on their digital menu), and we ordered pasta. My order carbonara was good, but my friend’s aioli pasta was totally unseasoned. We definitely won’t be back soon!
Great food and service! It's one of our go-to restaurants when we visit NYC.
Serafina is always a safe choice. The food and service are pretty even, and it is a great place for a casual outing. If you are looking to impress someone, this is not the place for you, but for family and friends, it fits the bill.
Decent but bait and switch with the menus listed here on open table vs at the restaurant. We went for brunch thinking the brunch menu would be offered along with complimentary cocktails, it was not. We paid $16 for mimosas which is very high for what they were. Our server was not apologetic at all when asked why the other menu wasn’t being offered. His response to us asking was “no.”
We had a very enjoyable dinner here last week. I had an excellent dish with white sauce, mushrooms and pasta but I don’t recall the name. My family had rigatoni and loved it.
The dinner was disappointing. Although the food was excellent, the portions were really tiny as was the drink. Everything was small except the prices which were in the same price range as other nearby restaurants that do not leave you hungry. A restaurant should especially not skimp on lettuce and pasta which are not very costly but the salad and the pasta dish were both surprisingly small.
Wonderful lunch. Service was efficient and food was excellent.
This is one of a few locations in Manhattan. We have enjoyed the other locations, but it was our first time at this--and likely our last. Like the other locations, the food was very good. Unlike the other locations, the service was very slow and definitely lacking. For example, our hungry boys gobbled up the bread while we waited (a long time) for 2 salads and a pizza. We never got the bread. My mother-in-law ordered a cappuccino which she never received, but we were charged for (I had the waiter remove it from the bill). We were seated outside on a cool afternoon, but it took them a long time to get a working space heater. In general, anytime we wanted something, it took a long time to get the waiter's attention, even though they were not fully busy. The worst though, was when my wife took our kids to the restroom at the end of the meal, she overheard the waiter and busser saying something negative and uncalled for about our party. Very unprofessional and disappointing.
Delicious and attentive waitstaff
The service and the food were very good. But we ordered a bloody mary and it had much too much salt. We were told it came from a prepackaged drink mix. Personalized drinks would be better. Thanks...
Always serves up great food and ambience.
Cook had no gloves when handling food.
Waitress did nothing for our anniversary, even congratulations.
Waited 30+ minutes for water refills.
Overrated and overpriced.
Will not return again.
Food was terrific! Price was a little high, but typical for NYC. Service could have been a bit more consistent, given that the restaurant was not at all crowded. And what restaurant doesn't have iced tea? Otherwise a great weekday lunch.
Our trip from CT to NY brought us to Serafina. Outside dining was nice. The food was PERFECT. My experience was phenomenal.
What a lovely dinner at Serafinas! The food was delicious and service was very attentive. Will be coming back soon!
Muy buena la comida
This was truly the best Italian meal I have ever had! We will be going back.
Everything from start to finish was absolutely spectacular ‼️. The manager Ryan. Wilson our server & Andreanna our Hostess went above and beyond to accommodate ❤️❤️❤️. Top Notch. I highly recommend ‼️‼️‼️
We loveee serafina! specially this location, They are just great on every level soo attentive to my familie’s needs.
My food came cold meaning it was sitting also missing my salad that never was bought out. I frequent this chain and this was my first time at this location and I won’t be back I’ll stick to UES and midtown
What a beautiful way to spend Easter Sunday - a wonderful dining experience, superb food and service. Happy to recommend, and looking forward to a future visit
Great food and excellent service!
The food and services were amazing!
Espetacular a comida !! Atendimento nota 1000!
Amazing service from Luis . Great good and drinks !!
Love the food! Have been going there many times now!
Great good and service. Serefina has become my monthly dinner spot after my spa day.
best birthday dinner ever! we had the entire back to ourselves, beautiful restaurant, delicious food! shots and dessert on them
for my birthday!
This was probably the best date I’ve ever had. The service was impressive. Really charming staff ❤️
The service abs food was amazing. It was such a good date night idea.
Very quiet and staff was amazing. Food was great, little pricy but well worth it!
Fantastic food, great service. Tables were spaced out and had barriers, and they were following all covid safety protocols, so it felt safe for indoor dining.
One of the best Italian restaurant here in NYC.The service was great.
The atmosphere was great, as was the food and service. I'm never disappointed by Serafina. With all their precautions in place I felt safe eating there with my family.
Really nice treat
We arrived early. Were promptly seated by the bartender, whom was very helpful during our entire stay. The food was excellent, the drinks were great, noose level was very low, we could easily hear each other. I proposed at our table and I'm happy to say we are now engaged. So we plan to be back next valentine's day, if not before. I wish the bar had a bigger bourbon selection, but we enjoyed our drinks.
You can order delivery directly from Serafina Broadway using the Order Online button. Serafina Broadway also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 315-1700.
Serafina Broadway is rated 4.5 stars by 1551 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.